Dell Facing Canadian Class Action Suit

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
NewsFactor is reporting that Dell is facing a class action lawsuit in Canada over its Inspiron notebooks. The suit claims the PCs are susceptible to premature motherboard failure due to overheating.

Dell Canada is the target of a national class action suit on behalf of Canadian consumers who purchased several models of Dell's Inspiron notebooks. The suit claims the computer maker knowingly sold faulty machines. The claim was filed with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and contends that motherboards used in Inspiron models 1100, 1150, 5100, 5150, and 5160 are defective and that Dell should have known.
 
Good. About time this Dell pays for their questionable practices.

Mine was RMAd 3 times and finally upgraded to 6400. Never have they admitted it was a design flaw but yet exchanged it 3 times with no resistance? I bet it's because most people don't stress their laptop too much...
 
I wonder if those Inspiron share components with Latitudes since I saw 3-4 new Latitudes freezing non-stop and requiring repairs, up to 3 times for some cases.
 
A similar thing happened here in the U.S. last September. Dell was sued for a design flaw in the Inspiron 5150 laptop that caused the plastic of the case to melt, bending the motherboard, and damaging the recharging unit. Everyone (including me) with a 5150 has had their warranty extended to September of this year.
 
As an ex Dell warranty tech I can say that those models definently overheat right out of the box due to poor design and are pretty much guaranteed to fry eventually.
 
As the owner of a 5150 (with the 3.06Ghz P4 B), I can confirm that they have a serious heat dissipation problem. The main issue is the use of a small aluminum heatsink. In later models, this was replaced by a copper unit. Despite this, the heatsink is only about two inches long, half an inch high, and one inch deep. This is simply not enough area to cool the processor. I did have my mobo fry once and had to RMA it.

All of that being said, the reason the Dell engineers used this cooling solution is that it works just fine (under perfect conditions). In a 70F room with no dust on the heatsink, it is capable of keeping the processor reasonably cool. However, even a small amount of dust or a slight increase in ambient temps puts this laptop way over the edge. Dell surely didn’t expect everyone to regularly dust their heatsinks and operate the laptop only in cool environments. The lead engineer or executive that approved this design should be fired IMMEDIATELY.

One question for other folks that have a 5150, should I take advantage of the warranty extension? I haven’t had any problems with the laptop in the last two years, but that doesn’t mean the heat hasn’t damaged something inside. Also, I would like to use it to fold for the hord, but I just don’t think that crappy little heatsink would tolerate 100% load for any extended period of time.
 
I have 2 5150's that will be retired this year. THANK GOD..
These things are HEAVY as hell and HOT as HELL..

I woudl love to shove these back in dell's face. I hate the whole list of laptops listed on the lawsuit. I am glad someone is stepping up and beign hard fisted about dells crappy designs.
 
Back
Top