Dell 3007 and GPU power question

apcor

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 24, 2005
Messages
455
Thinking of getting a the dell 3007 but the native resolution - 2500x1600 seems a tad high. Right now there are only a few decent games (recent) that can be played at that res. My question is do you think new games will be able to be played at that resolution when the DX10 cards and vista comes out? Or will you still need something rediculous like quad SLI? (Example - say Crysis or cell factor on G80 or ATI equivalent at 25X16 possible)
 
I'm thinking that it is unlikely you'll be able to play most new games at that resolution reasonably. Also, the 3007 isn't exactly the best choice for gaming.
 
at that resolution, i don't think you'll be able to comfortably play any new games on any new hardware that comes out for a very long time. as video cards get better, game developers make graphics prettier, which pretty much takes up the extra power the cards afford. developers aren't even considering 2560x1600 as a resolution that people play at, and they won't for the forseeable future.
 
Sounds logical. Not sure if I should hold out for a 27-30" monitor with a lower native res - like 1900x1080 or 1920x1200 or just get the dell.
 
After gaming on a 30" Apple Cinema Display, I can quite honestly say that I find it absolutely excessive. It's real neat for about an hour, after which it actually becomes tiresome. Unless you're sitting a considerable distance from the screen, you're really putting your eyes through a workout. If you aren't prone to a good four hour gaming session now and then, this shouldn't be a big deal, but anything past a couple hours would really be pretty fatiguing. I have the 20" ACD, and I'd say that it could be slightly larger. 23"/24" would seem to be the sweet spot, and will do 1080 line video without any fuss.

If you're programming, ProTooling or Photoshopping however, anything less than 30" is a waste of money :)
 
I do sit back 2-4 ft depending on what type of game I am playing. Resolution and GPU power in games is all I am concerned about.
 
I guess I'll be the first to go in the oppsite direction as the other posters. I love gaming on my 30". Yes, you'll have problems with the new games at 2560x1600 even with top of the line hardware. I've found I really don't need AA at that resolution becase it looks damn good with out. Bottom line is, if you can afford to stay on current hardware then game on with it.
 
LittleMe said:
I guess I'll be the first to go in the oppsite direction as the other posters. I love gaming on my 30". Yes, you'll have problems with the new games at 2560x1600 even with top of the line hardware. I've found I really don't need AA at that resolution becase it looks damn good with out. Bottom line is, if you can afford to stay on current hardware then game on with it.


QFT.................Gaming will never be the same. I love it on the 30
 
I'd actually love to game at 2560x1600 on a 30" LCD. I'm perfectly comfortable with scaling back all of the other settings except texture resolution to work at that resolution. And with the next generation of games utilizing high res textures (e.g. UE3, Crysis, ET:QW, and definitely idNext) I would absolutely love it.

Not to mention the fact that I'd love to do programming/internet browsing with taht much desktop space as well.
 
you will always need quad sli for decent games, and some games even now like oblivion dont run fast enough at this.

if you scale back resolution, the quality is not very good on an lcd, instead get a 24" dell. they have just brought out a new and improved one with hdcp support! has 1920x1200 resolution, and this will be much more realistic. however again for this res you will need top of the range sli/crossfire once a year...
f
 
freddiepm61 said:
you will always need quad sli for decent games, and some games even now like oblivion dont run fast enough at this.

if you scale back resolution, the quality is not very good on an lcd, instead get a 24" dell. they have just brought out a new and improved one with hdcp support! has 1920x1200 resolution, and this will be much more realistic. however again for this res you will need top of the range sli/crossfire once a year...
f

24" is too small - love my 27", just want higher res than 1280x1024. Really want a 27-30" to game at 1920x1200. But sadly no monitor exists with those specs.
 
I cannot even see the mid-high level AA & AF on higher resolutions, unless I stare & compare!
 
High-resolution gaming is always a high investment with quickly-diminishing returns. In lay terms, it's an expensive proposition and you'll continually be putting more money into your setup just to be able to play. The benefits are there though, as I'm positive that playing a game like Oblivion at 2560x1600 much be simply gorgeous.

Go with a quad-SLI setup...it's really the only way to go in my opinion.
 
apcor said:
24" is too small - love my 27", just want higher res than 1280x1024. Really want a 27-30" to game at 1920x1200. But sadly no monitor exists with those specs.
The dot pitch would be very high. A 30" monitor doing 1920x1200 natively would look nearly identical to a 30" monitor scaling 1920x1200. I imagine the 3007 uses Genesis hardware, which is quite good for scaling. Native is great, but the cost of trying to drive 2560x1600 is substancial. You're going to have to figure out whether you want poor performance, lower resolution gaming or a gaping hole in your wallet.

cyks said:
I cannot even see the mid-high level AA & AF on higher resolutions, unless I stare & compare!
Aliasing will almost always be as evident on a high resolution LCD as it would be on a low resolution LCD. Resolution has little impact, as most PC LCDs lie within a fairly narrow PPI range.
 
phide said:
The dot pitch would be very high. A 30" monitor doing 1920x1200 natively would look nearly identical to a 30" monitor scaling 1920x1200. I imagine the 3007 uses Genesis hardware, which is quite good for scaling. Native is great, but the cost of trying to drive 2560x1600 is substancial. You're going to have to figure out whether you want poor performance, lower resolution gaming or a gaping hole in your wallet.


I guess that is what is holding me back from the dell. I dont know how things look at 1920x1200 or even 1600x1200 which would not be bad either. Also I heard at lower resolutions you can't get full screen and have to use black bars outside the picture. Dont want to deal with that if indeed that is true.
 
Even with Quad SLI you aren't gonna have a good gaming experience at native on a 30 incher. Really for gaming your best bet is SLI or Crossfire and a 24 incher.

I would totally dig 2560x1600 for the programming work I do though. If only it didn't cost as much as my left kidney!
 
hello! new to this forum. i would say the future dx10 cards should be able to handle this monitor on future games. i game on this monitor with a single x1900xt along with AMD X2 3800+, and 2gigs of ram and am satisfied with the performance. i play BF2 on this mainly and i have the settings all on medium except for the texture (no aa or af) which is on high and gives me 50-60fps average (still a fragfest fps in my book). with this kind of resolution i dont feel the need for aa or af. i suppose if you want to have all the eye candy and still run at 90fps+, then yes you will need crossfire/sli. i highly recommend this monitor to any who can afford it. i cannot stress what kind of a magnificent experience it is to game on this monitor, even if i cannot put every bell and whistle at max (which in my current case does not make a big noticeable difference to how the game looks). also, this monitor is a godsend when watching dvds as well as surfing the net, and doing office work at the same time :D
 
&ru said:
hello! new to this forum. i would say the future dx10 cards should be able to handle this monitor on future games. i game on this monitor with a single x1900xt along with AMD X2 3800+, and 2gigs of ram and am satisfied with the performance. i play BF2 on this mainly and i have the settings all on medium except for the texture (no aa or af) which is on high and gives me 50-60fps average (still a fragfest fps in my book). with this kind of resolution i dont feel the need for aa or af. i suppose if you want to have all the eye candy and still run at 90fps+, then yes you will need crossfire/sli. i highly recommend this monitor to any who can afford it. i cannot stress what kind of a magnificent experience it is to game on this monitor, even if i cannot put every bell and whistle at max (which in my current case does not make a big noticeable difference to how the game looks). also, this monitor is a godsend when watching dvds as well as surfing the net, and doing office work at the same time :D

Agreed, even with SLI I have not felt the need to enable AA/AF. The resolution is so high you really don't need it. I love gaming on my 3007 and wouldn't go back now.
 
If you want to THINK about playing games on that, you're gonna NEED SLI/CrossFire to get decent framerates....
 
How well does it scale at lower resolutions like 1600x1200 or 1920x1200. My current monitor has native @ 1280x720 but scales beautiful at 1280x1024 so I always scale up. Never tried going down. Also, can you tell me how others run/look. Say, FEAR or Quake at 16x12 or 19x12.

LittleMe said:
Agreed, even with SLI I have not felt the need to enable AA/AF. The resolution is so high you really don't need it. I love gaming on my 3007 and wouldn't go back now.
 
Quake looks and runs awsome. I haven't played FEAR on it, but for jacuzz1 has posted screen shots and such on it in the "Got My 3007!! its huge" thread. There's actually a lot of screenshots, pictures, and benchmarks in that thread on different games.
 
apcor said:
How well does it scale at lower resolutions like 1600x1200 or 1920x1200.
Well, I owned a 2005FPW for a short while (returned due to the fact that the panel's edges were as bright as the sun), and it scaled quite well with lower resolutions. With a 1680x1050 native, even 800x600 looked passable. My Apple display is not nearly as forgiving. And no, you can do all sorts of fancy scaling with the Dell panels - stretch to fit, horizontal stretch only and centered (no scaling).

Can't dig up any information on this, but the 2005FPW and the 3007FPW probably use the same DSP - the Genesis gm1501/1601.
 
I guess the bottom line is with the games I play I wont be doing 2500x1600 if I get the dell. Will have to check out that thread by Jacuzzi. It would also mean a GPU upgrade (most likely 2 GPUs) so I got serious $$$ at steak. Or Wait till G80 and see how it pans out.
 
Back
Top