Dell 2007WFP Praised by Behardware

I'm surprised since several other sites gave it great reviews a few months ago as well. The newest issue of PC Magazine even gives it it's Editor's Choice award. I've been meaning to send them an email asking how they could ignore the banding issue.
 
The don't say hardly anything about image quality. The praise they give it is on the design of the stand more than anything.

The mention comparing it in gaming to the NEC, which is clearly ahead.

The also point out that it is a crap shoot the way Dell changes panels at a whim. Though there has been no change to PVA/MVA in the WFP yet, just in the FP.

In order to see banding you actually have to display something that shows it like some kind of gradient. Highly likely that they didn't even bother to look.
 
it's because some of those sites probably aren't even looking for banding or throughly evaluation the thing, take a look at the video review Cnet has which is practically worthless, I did a double take on it, the chick says it has a wobbly stand.. there's your review.. gee thanks
 
Eagle156 said:
http://www.behardware.com/articles/619-6/updated-survey-13-lcd-20-5-6-8-16-ms.html

Go to the final few pages to see the results of their testing, it's quite contrary compared to what alot of the people in this forum are saying. Perhaps they just recieved a perfect sample?

I would hardly call it praise. They didn't mention the banding issue at all. And they didn't recommend it for gaming. They did point out the fact that Dell likes to change components (panels) without informing the consumer. What a surprise! The only good thing they had to say was that it's ergonomics were great! I think everyone agrees with that.
 
Sobek said:
I'm surprised since several other sites gave it great reviews a few months ago as well. The newest issue of PC Magazine even gives it it's Editor's Choice award. I've been meaning to send them an email asking how they could ignore the banding issue.

Its because the banding issue is fixed. Check the Dell monitor forum for information on users that have the new A02 revision. I've also seen plenty of people say thats its great for gaming as well and havn't noticed any kind of ghosting problems. I havn't gamed much on mine yet but its been perfect for everything else outside of a slight amount of banding when i ran some gradient tests but my replacement with the upgraded firmware should be here before long. The stand a lone is a great reason to choose this LCD over many others in the price range. It has a really nice look and is very functional. And none of the other manufacturers even come close to touching Dell's warranty exchange process. If you bought a NEC or a Viewsonic you would be stuck with it if it only had a couple dead pixels or a little backlight leakage. With Dell i can get a replacement for about any reason so that i am satisfied with my purchase and the exchange is advanced replacement where they cover return shipping. With NEC or Viewsonic you will be the one paying to return the monitor for any reason.
 
Given Dell's track record for quality, that level of warranty comes in real handy.
 
deb0 said:
I would hardly call it praise. They didn't mention the banding issue at all. And they didn't recommend it for gaming. They did point out the fact that Dell likes to change components (panels) without informing the consumer. What a surprise! The only good thing they had to say was that it's ergonomics were great! I think everyone agrees with that.
Did you look at the results intsead of just reading the conclusion? The Dell had one of the best color reproduction results out of the box, and it had a low amount of ghosting.
 
I'm interesting to get an update on the Dell 2007WFP... how is it performing now a days with the new revisions?

Is banding totally fixed? Any issues?
 
Dell monitors great reviews from everybody all the time. They also spend a fortune advertising. The S-IPS panel is a good panel though - if you get one and it works.
 
Who the h*ll is behardware? What a crappy name for a website. I believe these wacko's about as much as I trust Fox News for fair and balanced news!
 
Back
Top