Defective video memory w/ new core i5 & integrated gpu?

multiplexed

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 8, 2003
Messages
88
Not sure whether to put this in CPU, memory, or video category.


I bought a new dell optiplex tower. It has a core i5-3470 3.2 Ghz processor, with an integrated intel HD graphics 2500 GPU.

The dell diagnostic utility reported bad video memory.

I also tested with this software
“video memory stress test”
http://mikelab.kiev.ua/index_en.php?page=PROGRAMS/vmt_en

This bootable .iso tested video memory as bad as well.


I ran the same software from within windows, and everything tested fine. Memtest86+ tests out OK after 9 hours. I’ve swapped out memory with a known good stick of memory. I’m running the (only) latest bios. In my limited usage of the machine, I haven’t noticed anything wrong.

So, I have two apps telling me I have bad video memory, and two apps telling me my memory is OK.


Q1) I’m assuming the GPU core is using system memory, right?

Q2) If so, and if memtest86+ checks out OK, then I should be safe, right?

Q3) Should I just add a new video card?

What could the problem be, and how do I fix this?


update: Also, this machine is hooked up to my KVM right now, if that matters.

Q4) I'm not looking at a defective CPU/GPU chip or motherboard, right?
 
Last edited:
Q2) If so, and if memtest86+ checks out OK, then I should be safe, right?

No. 9 hours of memtest86+ does not prove your ram is 100% stable. I have seen ram take days before spitting out the first error.
 
Thanks for the comment. I would agree with your point. However, for this situation ...


I did swap out with a known good stick of system memory.

Also, the bootable .iso detects bad video memory within seconds of starting up. If it detects the bad memory that quickly, then memtest "should" pick up any flaws in a short period of time also. But, memtest comes up clean for 9 hours.
 
Do you have any graphical corruption in any 3D Applications?

I'm betting it's a false positive.
 
3DMark11 sometimes errors out the ‘first’ time I run a test. Something about a “DirectX 11 call”. DXDiag shows no problems. Everything is enabled. Though, there are no tests to run to verify this. It then errors out a second time. Something about “exclusive access” to the monitor. The monitor error is probably due to my KVM or my crap monitor keeps autoadjusting. After the first crash, it then works fine whenever I use 3DMark11, from then on, until I reboot.


Some New Happenings
------------------------------
I just found a PCIe card to put in the machine. It now passes the bootable .iso test with the dedicated video card. 3DMark11 no longer crashes the first time. I also found in Win7, with my original integrated video, in the Control Panel\Display\Adjust Resolution\Advanced, it brings up a bunch of tabs. The first tab mentions ..

64 MB Dedicated Memory
1632 MB Shared System Memory
1696 MB Total Memory

So, I’m figuring that “64 MB Dedicated Memory” is the problem, since that’s out of the loop, and everything works OK now with the new dedicated PCIe video card. Nothing in the “Shared System Memory” has changed. New drivers are irrelevant in the bootable .iso. There's nothing relevant in the BIOS.

----------
--> So, my new question is, where is that “dedicated” memory? Is it built into the chip, on the motherboard, somewhere else?


---------
Side Note - Holy crap is there a difference in 3DMark11! That Intel GPU sucks. It’s choppy, like 2 to 5 fps and the graphics are chunky and look like from the Win98 era. Even my old Radeon HD 5770 has a smooth framerate and graphics look modern.
 
--> So, my new question is, where is that “dedicated” memory? Is it built into the chip, on the motherboard, somewhere else?

It just means you'll never free up that 64MB of system memory as long as you're using the HD 2500. It can use a whole lot more ram if it needs to, but the 64MB is the smallest it can go.

This means that the errors you experienced were most definitely in your system ram. Run memtest+ for several days, and try in different slots before you can call it safe.
 
Jorona - I can't disable the iGPU in the BIOS.


Notes ...
This is a UEFI bios in legacy mode.
I put a new 450 watt PSU in the system. It doesn't seem to affect anything.
The system will only boot with a stick of memory in slot one.

I still don't think this is a memory issue. I've used two separate sticks of memory from a known good machine, to the same results. Also, the bootable .iso detects memory problems within 5 seconds every single time. I'd think that memtest would find find something wrong in less than 9 hours if the system memory was that bad.


I don't know what's changed, but the Dell utility now passes all tests. Before, it would error out with 2000:0332 which on Dell's website is a video memory error. It also mentions PSA v4222 which I can't find.

So, the Dell utility, the windows version utility, and memtest check out. The bootable .iso doesn't.

Right now, I have a PCIe card in. I'll probably just put a cheap/decent PCIe video card in. Test it's memory. Then let memtest run for a couple of days. If those come up clean, then I'll deliver this machine.
 
Back
Top