Dedicated Intel NIC recommendation (desktop)

Sabrewulf165

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 23, 2004
Messages
2,978
Any favorites out there? All I'd really be using it for is surfing, gaming, and occasional large file transfers over a GigE switch. Is it worth it over Marvell onboard? And which cards are good without being too expensive? More or less looking to stay under 60 bucks, but I might stretch it to 80 if a particular card stands head-and-shoulders above it's cousins.

Educate me.
 
I've heard good things about Marvell onboard NICs. I don't think it's worth it though. If you had frequent large-file transfers, maybe. For surfing, you probably won't do any better than your onboard. For gaming, you might gain 1-3fps, but is that worth $30+?
 
I've bought used Pro/1000 PT dual-port cards on eBay for around $50 each; it's nice and speedy combined with a managed switch and link aggregation.

Probably overkill for you though. I suggest getting an Intel Gigabit CT or the older 1000 PT and call it a day. That's about as good as you're going to get with a reasonably priced single port gigabit card.

Of course, this will really only help you for large file transfers. The onboard NIC will be adequate in most other cases.
 
Any favorites out there? All I'd really be using it for is surfing, gaming, and occasional large file transfers over a GigE switch. Is it worth it over Marvell onboard? And which cards are good without being too expensive? More or less looking to stay under 60 bucks, but I might stretch it to 80 if a particular card stands head-and-shoulders above it's cousins.

Try measuring your on-board to find out for yourself. E.g using iperf version 1.7.

server: iperf -s
client: iperf -c server -l 64k -t 15 -i 3 -r

where server is the name or IP of the remote machine running iperf -s.

If you run this under Vista, you should launch the command prompt as an administrator and turn off the music.

Note that NICs on both ends will matter, and that PCI NICs typically have a performance penalty, which can be somewhat mitigated with jumbo frames if your switch and NICs support them. If your NICs do but switch doesn't, you can test with a direct wire connection.

I don't have any on-board Marvell PCIe NICs here, but have seen > 950 Mb/s with add-on Marvell PCIe-based NICs, and also ~ 950 Mb/s or greater with several on-board NICs.
 
Bah, I don't know why I thought I had a Marvell controller, but it's actually Realtek. May have been the Asus P45 I had before that was Marvell. Does that change any opinions?

Capture.PNG
 
Realtek's PCIe gigE implementation is better than their PCI version (as is Marvell's), and can probably easily beat the speed of the average HD or OS. IIRC I've benched one doing > 900 Mb/s as well.
 
They're a waste of money if you have a top of the line dual gigabit LAN motherboard. They usually come with Marvell chips which do over 950Mbps sustained transfers.
 
I have a few systems with various Marvell and Realtek chips, can't fault them really.
Only went for an Intel PT card for it's teaming options
 
They're a waste of money if you have a top of the line dual gigabit LAN motherboard. They usually come with Marvell chips which do over 950Mbps sustained transfers.

Um, no.
Just because the Marvell NIC/chip is capable of those transfers, doesn't mean it can handle offloads, multiple connections without drops, NIC teaming, and about a hundred other features.

The server board I just setup for my server has dual Intel NICs, 82574L and 82574LM, which are both far superior to any Marvell chip in terms of quality, performance, and reliability.
Even the PCI-E Intel NIC I'm using has the exact same 82574L chip, and hasn't skipped a beat in all of the HEAVY usage and time I've put on it.

I've had Marvell NICs burn out after two weeks of heavy usage, which makes them, for anything outside of basic Internet and simple file transfers, impractical.
"Sustained transfers" does not equal reliability. ;)

Also, the CPU offload from the Intel NICs is huge, whereas for the Marvell NICs, tack on another 20-30% CPU usage.
 
Back
Top