Decision help...8800GTS Vs 3870x2

nk6600

n00b
Joined
Jan 11, 2004
Messages
25
Hello,

In the next 48h i will by a graphics card, my budget lets me think in the 8800GTS 512 or the 3870x2.

The card will be used to play games with resolutions of 1920*1080 and 1680*1050...and also in a multimedia environment...

Well, i´m asking for your help in the decision of chosing one of these two.

Witch one is better and if were you, wath would be your choice...

Thanks for your help, and please give your opinion!
 
Get them both and test them yourself. I had both and returned the 3870x2. The thing is your gonna get alot of mixed responses from people that never even tried the hardware on the internet forums. Best way to find out.
 
Not that you shouldn't get the 8800GTS (I love mine), but if you're willing to spend ~$450 for a 3870x2 (going price on newegg) why not go with an Evga 8800GTX @ ~$360, which you could conceivably set up later?
 
Well,

There is money for only one of these cards, and, i´m from Portugal over here the prices are the follwing:

Asus 8800GTS TOP 512Mb GDDR3 - 329€

Sapphire ATI Radeon PCI-E HD3870 X2 HDMI 1Gb DDR3 - 379.90€

The 8800GTX goes pass the 400€ barrier, that i can not pass...

So...keep sending your opinions cause one of these will be ....the one...

Is the ATI able to keep up with this resolutions in real life...what are your experiences.

And the GTS with this resolutions...what is it capable of...

I´m reading a lot of reviews...but your experiences are more valuable to me!
 
The 3870x2 wins at 1920x1080 and higher. The drivers for it though frustrated me with the games I played. I can say without a doubt you will experience the same driver frustrations if you game alot.

The 8800gts runs all my games just as good but certain games like CoD4, bioshock, and TF2 run way better on the 3870x2.

You should ask yourself this: would you rather have a less performing card without worrying about drivers or get a higher performing card that relies heavily on good drivers (that aren't available yet)?
 
Well,

There is money for only one of these cards, and, i´m from Portugal over here the prices are the follwing:

Asus 8800GTS TOP 512Mb GDDR3 - 329€

Sapphire ATI Radeon PCI-E HD3870 X2 HDMI 1Gb DDR3 - 379.90€

The 8800GTX goes pass the 400€ barrier, that i can not pass...

So...keep sending your opinions cause one of these will be ....the one...

Is the ATI able to keep up with this resolutions in real life...what are your experiences.

And the GTS with this resolutions...what is it capable of...

I´m reading a lot of reviews...but your experiences are more valuable to me!

Hey fellow portuguese :)

Both are good cards, but the X2 depends heavily on driver Crossfire support, which may turn your 400 euros card into a 200 euros card, in terms of performance. Also, AA is not a strong point for this card, as is the case with any R600 derivative,

The 8800 GTS 512 does not suffer from this and is usually as fast, and sometimes even faster, than the X2. Up to 1600x1200, the GTS 512 performs as a 8800 GTX. Beyond that, the GTX is usually faster, especially with high levels of AA (past 4x), but not by a huge margin.

You are better off with the GTS 512. It's a safer bet and you don't have to wait for drivers to improve your performance.
 
Let me see, for now the 8800GTS is the winner with more predictable performance and being a good and reliable performer until de 1680*1050, with good driver support...

The 3870X2 is probably better with 1980*1050 but needs a good driver to get a real boost.

What do you think...is ATI working in a good driver for their top performer or is a risk move going with that thought...

The cloking is ticking and nvidia is winning...
 
With the 9800 GX2 just weeks away, I would probably wait for that. Until it is realesed, we won't know how it will perform, but I think it is worth waiting for just incase it fits your requirements better.
 
I have two of each of the cards in question (G92 GTS and 3870x2). Comparing single card vs. single card, the 3870x2 will be the better performer in just about every game. The G92 GTS is no slouch though, and I wouldn't consider it a "mistake" if you go with the GTS over the 3870x2.
 
Matters what motherboard you currently have......

If you are running a newer Intel chipset go with the 3870x2 as you can always add another one or a 3870 to get some nice gains. If you have NV for your chipset, go with a 8800GT.
 
Back
Top