Deciding which to build

Shane_c82

Gawd
Joined
Mar 26, 2004
Messages
812
Updating my S939 in sig.

AMD:
2GB Crucial Ballistix DDR-800/$89
3600+ Brisbane/$63
Asus M2N-SLI Deluxe/$79 Open Box from NewEgg

Intel:
2GB Crucial Ballistix DDR-800/$89
E4300/$117
Asus P5B/$68 Open Box from NewEgg

Mainly for getting max OC, gaming, video encoding, multitasking, limit of about $290 for all 3 components. Anyone have any better suggestions on motherboards? Which is more futureproof? The Intel I can get a quad later and the AMD an AM2+ cpu if they keep their word and the upcoming Phenoms are backwards compatible. Any suggestions welcome, thanks.
 
The intel for pure overclockability. :p Dunno about the motherboard though.
 
Let me rephrase that, I'm looking for the most bang for my buck when ocing. Is the P5B going to hold me back on the E4300? How much of a difference is a Brisbane @ 2.8 to an E4300 @ 3.2, give or take a few hundred MHz on each of course depending on oc.
 
Tom's doesnt have the E4300 or the 3600 listed in their dynamic chart. They are slow to update their list and hard to say when they'll ever get around to it.

If it were me I'd go Intel if performance and overclocking is top priority. The 4300 is better in this regard. If you want budget as priority then the 3600 is cheaper. AMD says their chips are going to be backwards compatible but until they prove it its not true in my book. Not saying it wont be but I like proof. Many Intel mobos though are already quadcore compatiable however so the upgrade path is already there and proven.

For the two setups you show there is about a $43 difference. For the extra money I'd go with better performance and overclockability and a proven upgrade path but thats just what I would do.
 
Tom's doesnt have the E4300 or the 3600 listed in their dynamic chart.

Yes but you would have to have a really good excuse not to overclock to 2.5ghz which would put you on the chart as a e6300 or whatever.
 
Tom's doesnt have the E4300 or the 3600 listed in their dynamic chart. They are slow to update their list and hard to say when they'll ever get around to it.

If it were me I'd go Intel if performance and overclocking is top priority. The 4300 is better in this regard. If you want budget as priority then the 3600 is cheaper. AMD says their chips are going to be backwards compatible but until they prove it its not true in my book. Not saying it wont be but I like proof. Many Intel mobos though are already quadcore compatiable however so the upgrade path is already there and proven.

For the two setups you show there is about a $43 difference. For the extra money I'd go with better performance and overclockability and a proven upgrade path but thats just what I would do.

I agree.
 
Back
Top