Decent 3.5 inch bay card reader?

NMR Guy

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 12, 2004
Messages
154
OK, perhaps one of the most boring storage related pieces of hardware, but... I need to replace the piece of junk Super Talent Card Reader I have now, as it doesn't read anymore.

Can anyone recommend a hassle free and reliable internal (3.5 inch bay) card reader? A lot of the stuff out there seems really flaky, which isn't surprising considering how little they cost. (My dead Super Talent reader was $7.99 1.5 years ago. The hardwired USB cable is too short, and the case isn't quite square, so shoving it in the bay was a bit of work.)

Alternatively, if you've experienced a bad reader, please tell me which one so I can avoid it.

Thanks!
 
I was placing an order with NCIX and had free shipping already so I threw a http://www.ncix.com/products/?sku=21448&vpn=NG-35INT-BK-CR&manufacture=nGear%20Technologies%20Inc. into my cart which was on sale for $4.99.

It was pleasantly surprised that it's been faster on all media types than my previous, external, not-so-cheap reader.

The problem that I have with it is physical. It will accept many cards properly and upside down, and still turn on the little green light that says it's properly inserted (just a mechanical switch). The becomes more of a problem because, I think, Sony MS is taken right side up and SD is taken upside down, and I keep forgetting which way is which.

The CF slot only accepts the card one way, but it's a little tough to get aligned properly and inserted.

So it cleaned up my desktop, runs pretty fast, hasn't had any compatibility problems, but still sucks in some ways. Of course I'm not sure that there's anything out there in a true "all format" reader that doesn't suck. Good CF-only readers (ie. Firewire Lexar) are $100 for one type of card...
 
Shane, Surly,

Thanks for the input. At $9 with free shipping, I figured what the heck, I'll try the shell shocker from newegg. Actually, I was going to also order the NCIX deal, too, and just try them both since they were both so cheap. Unfortuntely, the shipping from NCIX was more than the item :-p, so I passed. Sometimes that's a killer on small items, huh?

Anyway, thatk you both for the links!
 
Back
Top