DEA Can’t Intercept iMessages

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Attention criminals, buy an iPhone and use iMessages if you don't want the feds to know what you are doing. :D

An internal Drug Enforcement Administration document seen by CNET discusses a February 2013 criminal investigation and warns that because of the use of encryption, "it is impossible to intercept iMessages between two Apple devices" even with a court order approved by a federal judge.
 
Wouldn't this also go for BBM users as well? Or any encrypted messaging really.

If i recall Blackberry had to give up methods to decrypt BBM or certain counties were going to prohibit them , will be interesting if they try the same with apple
 
One day the Feds will complain that they can't decrypt 2 people whispering. Think of the children!
 
If i recall Blackberry had to give up methods to decrypt BBM or certain counties were going to prohibit them , will be interesting if they try the same with apple

I think that was regarding India IIRC. But I think I remember what you are referring to.
 
Hate to burst your bubble, but while the DEA may not be able to crack the encrypted message, the NSA can do it in almost real time if they single out that message from all the other traffic they routinely record. Normally all the data just stays "as is" in storage until they need it for something specific, and then all the data belonging to that specific # or identifier gets processed on request as it's needed. All your cell traffic, as well as land line communications are collected in this way. Also, sms messaging gets sent out over the airwaves in plain text. No law enforcement agency needs a warrant to read them because there's no expectation of privacy with unencrypted messaging.
 
In this case, if not obvious, the term "intercept" also implies decrypting the messages.

Honestly iMessage has one severe fatal flaw. It's brutally easy to both intercept and read everything coming through and something I've always considered a horrible security flaw.
 
Honestly iMessage has one severe fatal flaw. It's brutally easy to both intercept and read everything coming through and something I've always considered a horrible security flaw.

You know what they say about a claim without evidence. ;):D
 
"it is impossible to intercept iMessages between two Apple devices"

They never said anything about intercepting iMessage between THREE Apple devices. ;)

2 of which are signed into the same Apple ID, presumably.
 
Hate to burst your bubble, but while the DEA may not be able to crack the encrypted message, the NSA can do it in almost real time if they single out that message from all the other traffic they routinely record. Normally all the data just stays "as is" in storage until they need it for something specific, and then all the data belonging to that specific # or identifier gets processed on request as it's needed. All your cell traffic, as well as land line communications are collected in this way. Also, sms messaging gets sent out over the airwaves in plain text. No law enforcement agency needs a warrant to read them because there's no expectation of privacy with unencrypted messaging.

I feel so much safer now
\sarcasm
 
One advantage ... with Congress in such a dysfunctional state they are probably unlikely to modify the 1994 law that prevents this legally ;)
 
Steve is a terrorist for telling would-be criminals how to communicate securely! :p
 
I feel so much safer now
\sarcasm

I concur. Every year our rights get eroded in the name of security, with the entities claiming they need the increased powers to protect us looking more and more like the real enemy in the process.
 
This is most likely a ploy to make stupid criminals think imessages are safe so they can gather evidence.
 
Hate to burst your bubble, but while the DEA may not be able to crack the encrypted message, the NSA can do it in almost real time if they single out that message from all the other traffic they routinely record. Normally all the data just stays "as is" in storage until they need it for something specific, and then all the data belonging to that specific # or identifier gets processed on request as it's needed. All your cell traffic, as well as land line communications are collected in this way. Also, sms messaging gets sent out over the airwaves in plain text. No law enforcement agency needs a warrant to read them because there's no expectation of privacy with unencrypted messaging.

Because it's so easy to capture all the data traveling between all devices everywhere and then standardize it so it can be placed in a data warehouse with enough storage in such a way that it can be easily searched and recovered. The USG can't even manage to merge independent data silos between departments within the same organization without hiring outside companies as contractors. Something that big would have required tons of manpower, interception equipment at just about every router, and a stupid amount of storage along with the necessary pipes to handle the full extent of data traffic captured. It's a monumentally difficult task to accomplish and something that big is strictly in the realm of tinfoil hat sorts.

Targeted observation based on suspicion is perfectly reasonable as are the capabilities to crack open encryption, but a huge net that broadly sucks up copies of every data packet without anyone noticing and blowing the whistle? That's in the same domain as the inexpensive beachfront property in Wyoming that I have for sale.
 
I feel confident that all the eye messages I've been sending over the last day or so have been properly intercepted, decrypted, and recorded. I'll know for sure this weekend.
 
I can picture one day the DOJ, DEA and DOD leak some memo that says they can't intercept such and such a standard, all the bad guys switch to said standard and BAM! All the bad guys get locked up. I'm kind of suspected that the government may have some powerful computers for a while now that can crack some common forms of encryption, how else to you explain their complete 360 on encryption from the late 90s, through 9/11/01 to today. It use to be treason, yes treason, to take forms of encryption outside of the US, though I have never heard of a case involving enforcement. I talked to people that were put on the no fly list after 9/11/01, not because they were a national threat, but because they were an asset and yet still encryption stayed on the back burner after the 90s roller coaster ride.
 
@RangerXML

The nature of (and the technical aspects of) encryption have at this point been rendered somewhere between pointless, obvious, and easily hackable. This is mainly due to the advancements in computer technology and the tremendous proliferation of the internet as it comes down to the lot of every man, women, and child on the planet. It has essentially been transformed into what is now "obfuscation". This is the single biggest reason that so many things CAN happen right under the noses of so many people (right in front of them). Facebook is a fantastic example of this. Webpages that we all see everyday are setup as a mix of so many other things that no one sees unless they are specifically looking for it. It's often said that the best place to hide something is in plain sight. The thing is, people either don't 'want' to see it or simply don't care. Some of the best encryption at this point is seen through the eyes of those we commonly refer to as hackers (which the government has little, if any control over). THAT'S what scares them so much. That's why we end up with the Kim Dotcoms of the world all over the news.

This is the way things are.....this is not conspiracy theory.
 
A friend and I were playing around with Facebook actually, testing it as a bulletin board with images holding encrypted messages, was a fun experience...until the picture turned to the disturbing and too funny.

Trust me, I believe in conspiracies, but I'm sure not going to loose sleep over it. Just right on loving my happy little ignorant life playing with my toys.
 
@RangerXML

The nature of (and the technical aspects of) encryption have at this point been rendered somewhere between pointless, obvious, and easily hackable. This is mainly due to the advancements in computer technology and the tremendous proliferation of the internet as it comes down to the lot of every man, women, and child on the planet. It has essentially been transformed into what is now "obfuscation". This is the single biggest reason that so many things CAN happen right under the noses of so many people (right in front of them). Facebook is a fantastic example of this. Webpages that we all see everyday are setup as a mix of so many other things that no one sees unless they are specifically looking for it. It's often said that the best place to hide something is in plain sight. The thing is, people either don't 'want' to see it or simply don't care. Some of the best encryption at this point is seen through the eyes of those we commonly refer to as hackers (which the government has little, if any control over). THAT'S what scares them so much. That's why we end up with the Kim Dotcoms of the world all over the news.

This is the way things are.....this is not conspiracy theory.

Except that even junky encryption used on home WiFi networks is such a pain to brute force break that most people rely on a massive rainbow table and cross their fingers that the stuff that's been precomputed will contain a match.

Encryption is pretty effective if implemented properly. There's lots of great information published about modern encryption methods which make it exceptionally difficult to obtain the information once it's been turned into ciphertext. It's much easier to just hit someone with a stick for a few minutes every hour until they give you their passwords.
 
@CreepyUncleGoogle

lol....beat'm with a stick :)
The method your describing is what crackers and script-kiddies use. What I'm talking about is the next level. The more professional way that ends up producing far better results.

Breaking WiFi encryption is a waste of time when you can just walk right in. it's alot easier to get the data out when your already in. Easier, more efficient, and more accurate.

One must be mindful of what is allowed to enter via the browser or any other installed software. Most people only worry of things like trojans, viruses, malware. But you end up with the exact same thing via so-called "legit" cookies, updates, games, office software, email, instant messaging, JAVA, Flash, etc. etc. etc.

One of the things that so many people fail to realize is that when it comes to being online....we surely can see me (my website) AND I can see you too (because you accessed my website). The door swings both ways.
 
One must be mindful of what is allowed to enter via the browser or any other installed software. Most people only worry of things like trojans, viruses, malware. But you end up with the exact same thing via so-called "legit" cookies, updates, games, office software, email, instant messaging, JAVA, Flash, etc. etc. etc.

One of the things that so many people fail to realize is that when it comes to being online....we surely can see me (my website) AND I can see you too (because you accessed my website). The door swings both ways.

There's a connection in your thoughts that I'm missing. Exploiting a system through software vulnerabilities and breaking encryption so you can get your hands on plaintext data aren't directly related spheres of system security. Certainly, someone might be able to use an exploit to get access to data at the storage device, but that hasn't got anything to do with whether or not that information is encrypted and its not at all related to intercepting and collecting encrypted information while its in transit between nodes.
 
He is basically saying its easier to attack someone from the inside then it is to break in through a strong encryption. Loads of nasty out there on the web, an encrypted network is still relatively save unless that threat is already on the inside of the network, either via worm, virus trojan or something as simple as social engineering. I agree, I wouldn't attack something head on, its like ramming your nice soft head against a nice hard brick wall, why not just find a nice door and try knocking or an unlocked window.

I still think with what we have versus what the military might have, most modern encryption might already be obsolete, like where I'm trying to smash through the wall the military has missiles and other things a lot more powerful. iMessager is not some kind of super secret weapon that the CIA developed, its something that most 1st graders now have on their iPads and iPod Touch (and maybe even iPhone, heaven forbid).
 
I C.....

But how are you going to make Bob who lives across the street access your exploited web page, when it is specifically him you want to target?

Chances are if people really have something to hide it will be a dang near impossible to trick them into an exploit. I for one, do all my web browsing on a VM on it's own NIC.
 
I C.....

But how are you going to make Bob who lives across the street access your exploited web page, when it is specifically him you want to target?

Chances are if people really have something to hide it will be a dang near impossible to trick them into an exploit. I for one, do all my web browsing on a VM on it's own NIC.

That's a good question to ask Sony regarding their Playstation Network, or Lockheed regarding PSA fobs, or various police organizations regarding their officers' personal info, or the untold masses that have had to deal with ID theft, or the church of scientology regarding Anon.......we all hear about things so often. A big part of what hacking is all about is social engineering.

How many people, businesses, and organizations have you dealt with and been witness to a serious lack of logic, intelligence, and security as it relates to IT? People WILL activate their ISP account using a seriously infected (barely running) computer. Everyone wants this stuff and everyone wants access, but no one cares to understand anything about it. All anyone cares about is their ability to communicate with a friend or relative over Facebook (which has become one of those vulnerabilities you yourself spoke of).

The government (as per federal law) already has backdoors into cable and DSL modems. They are NOT going to let Apple put these devices in the hands of so many people without having some way to access them. Especially with so many other things happening in the world (think...war on terror and DHS).

Encryption is only important to a certain degree but is basically a joke at this point. It's biggest point is to make people "feel" better. There is nothing you can encrypt that can't be decoded without a bigger, faster, and more powerful computer (or network).
 
Encryption is only important to a certain degree but is basically a joke at this point. It's biggest point is to make people "feel" better. There is nothing you can encrypt that can't be decoded without a bigger, faster, and more powerful computer (or network).

Nobody is going to bring the warehouse of supercomputers to bear on 99.999% of people here including most of the drug dealers, embezzlers and murderers.

The number one thing that would help encryption become worthless, is discouraging people from using it so volume of encrypted data to crack is small.

As for the article mentioning iMessage, something tells me that is not necessarily singling out iMessage vs. the rest, just a statement about iMessage itself. But iPhone needs the boost in making their owners still feel elite which isn't true anymore and getting harder to pretend everyday.
 
Nobody is going to bring the warehouse of supercomputers to bear on 99.999% of people here including most of the drug dealers, embezzlers and murderers.

I agree...I'm not suggesting otherwise.

But once the hole is there, it's there. It doesn't take much at that point to filter out certain key words or phrases (or cookies) to raise red flags and then call attention to oneself. wether or not that particular hole is used or that particular person is looked at becomes as easy as a few mouse clicks. Most people refuse to see that these things exist in the first place. It alot like refusing to acknowledge that there is a God. Make no mistake about it...to many of these people....this IS a religion (a belief system). People hell bent on world domination at any cost. People that can and will facilitate those that seek such domination. Then there are those that see big dollar signs by being part of the process (like advertisers).

There are many things that will get the attention of the average user. Like porn. It's not the pictures, it's the code in the page that serves up the pictures. Who needs encryption when you have stuff like that?

I used to use Yahoo IM. Most people never understood that when your in a private message session with someone (anyone) that both parties have access to eachothers' direct IP address. All kinds of people that I don't know would try to talk with me over a private session...specifically to get that IP. People too often let that happen without ever thinking about that.

My over-all point to any of this is that this article does talk about a more (or less) specific thing, but to truly understand why this is even a topic in the first place....you can't just stop there, there is a much larger picture here.
 
I used to use Yahoo IM. Most people never understood that when your in a private message session with someone (anyone) that both parties have access to eachothers' direct IP address. All kinds of people that I don't know would try to talk with me over a private session...specifically to get that IP. People too often let that happen without ever thinking about that..

AIM'S direct connection did the same.
 
http://securitywatch.pcmag.com/security/310015-the-real-reason-the-feds-can-t-read-your-imessages ... it is the CALEA law passed in 1994 that is creating the problem, not the strength of the encryption ... they can't legally or easily intercept the messages since messaging services like iMessage and others didn't exist when they passed the original law ... eventually Congress will likely update the law to make it legally possible and require the companies, like Apple, to comply with the tap requirements (probably right around the time the changes they make will be outdated by some new technology ;) )
 
Back
Top