DDR2 533 is it overkill?

DaveH

n00b
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
5
I'm deciding between three RAM combinations. They will run on a P5B Deluxe (haven't bought it yet so suppose it will be the newer revisions) with the new E6420 and I do intend to overclock like mad. Prices Canadian Dollar

1. g.Skill 2GB 6400 DDR2 800 HK ($229)

2. 2GB G.Skill HZ (everybody knows these) ($245)

3. mushkin eXtreme Performance 2GB DDR2 1066 ($250) AFTER REBATE

4. Mushkin HP PC2-6400 HP2-6400 2GB (190) AF

Obviously I'm looking for the best value but am willing to buy item# 3 if its not overkill.

thanks


DAVEh
 
I'm deciding between three RAM combinations. They will run on a P5B Deluxe (haven't bought it yet so suppose it will be the newer revisions) with the new E6420 and I do intend to overclock like mad. Prices Canadian Dollar

1. g.Skill 2GB 6400 DDR2 800 HK ($229)

2. 2GB G.Skill HZ (everybody knows these) ($245)

3. mushkin eXtreme Performance 2GB DDR2 1066 ($250) AFTER REBATE

4. Mushkin HP PC2-6400 HP2-6400 2GB (190) AF

Obviously I'm looking for the best value but am willing to buy item# 3 if its not overkill.

thanks


DAVEh

Link for #3 isn't coming up. Maybe the following link is the one you wanted.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820146677


And your title seemed misleading when you said ddr2 533, because the memory is able to run stock ddr2 1066.

If you were running 1066 and your memory multiplier was set to 1:1, then your fsb would need to be 533 for the memory to be ddr2 1066.

Maybe you should change the title to say ddr2 1066, that is actually a speed most people like to get close to for overclocking.

I am running ddr2 1010 @ 3.535, if you had a cpu with 7x multiplier that you were trying to hit 4ghz with, then the 1066 would probably be a good choice as long as it could overclock higher. You would need to run almost ddr2 1150 to have a 7x multiplier run at 4ghz.

I think the e6420 has a higher multiplier than 7 though, so if you had 8x multiplier, you would only need memory to run at ddr2 1000 to get 4ghz.

I personally think you would be fine with the HK's or the HZ's, or any other memory that will overclock to around ddr2 1000.

I don't think you will be reaching 4ghz with the e6420, and if you do, that is awesome and you have a nice cpu.

I personally think those mushkin may be a little more than you need.

if you want something like that for sure, here are some crucial ballistix ddr2 1000 that are cheaper and will overclock to ddr2 1100+ if you really need that.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820146563
 
updated link, and i'm somewhat restricted to these choices because these are on sale here in canada.

thnks
 
updated link, and i'm somewhat restricted to these choices because these are on sale here in canada.

thnks

i would just go with the HZ's since they aren't that much more than the HK's. HZ's will leave you with head room also to go over ddr2 1000, HK's will run a little over ddr2 1000 with lower voltage, but might not go quite as high as the HZ's.
 
HZ will go higher with more voltage. However, beware of killing your D9's if you go 2.2v+ volts. The HK will do DDR-1000 4-4-4-10 2.1v(some 2.2v). I don't think the D9 HZ's can do that.

I'd say get the HK because they are more reliable, better timing at lower volt, and a little cheaper.
 
Back
Top