Data loss - WD software says drive is fine = ?

Korgun

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Mar 9, 2000
Messages
6,619
On my D drive (250 gig 7200 RPM 8mb cache WD running off abit IDE > serial converter on Abit NF7-S Revision 2 - athlon xp 3200 not overclocked) files/folders started to get corrupt, so first thing i di dwas backup as many files as i could (most)

then i tried doing the disk check with the WD software (on ultimate boot disk) and it wouldn't start the test.... then i thought maybe the serial converter was bad - so i replaced it with an extra one i have lieing around, then bam the test went 100% fine and most of the files/folders that windows claimed to be corrupt were uncorrupt and life was good

this was 3 days ago and tonight it started happening again... i did the WD utility again and it says the drive is fine....

Any clues what I should do?

By the way the reason it's on the serial converter is all my IDE slots are full... :( 2 optical drives, 4 hard drives - 1 a real serail HD and the other (the one this thread is about) the WD :(

the thing that irks me is the same setup has been running 100% fine for the last 5 months...
 
I did a full test and the full test passed as well and I updated symantec anti virus and did a virus scan on all of my drives and it didn't find any viruses...
 
I was goign to suggest virus scan until I read your reply. Download Free-AV and AVG and run those also. It's best to use several virus scanning software to make sure you pick up all viruses.
 
Run a CHKDSK D: /R from the commandline (I'm assuming you're running Win2k or XP) and see what happens. It'll take awhile, because it'll be checking the disk surface. If the report at the end shows any bad sectors, you know your answer. If not, I'd look into your data cables, power supply, or how the drive is setup in BIOS, and if these check out okay, I'd back up your data and re-partition/re-format.
 
I had the same idea too... but i didn't do the windows chkdsk, i just deleted partition, re-created partition and then did a full format and now i'm transfering my files back onto it

hopefully they stop corrupting :) i'll do the windows chkdsk after this is done.... in the morning

roughly 2 hours down, 2 hours to go
 
Corruption 101
alot more possibilities await you ;)

if all those check out there are some real esoteric ones like MOV shunts to common ground in networked hardware and EMI induced corruption

Power is often an overlooked area, but test memory first ;)
 
Ice Czar said:
Corruption 101
alot more possibilities await you ;)

if all those check out there are some real esoteric ones like MOV shunts to common ground in networked hardware and EMI induced corruption

Power is often an overlooked area, but test memory first ;)

Thanks for the link, I read most and skimmed through parts.

I highly doubt it's a power issue, but I did switch the cable connected to it *just in case* and hasn't changed the situation one bit.

I really hope it's not one of those esoteric ones you mentioned... that has the potential to be a real headache...

I am thinking one thing though... I recall using windows update and it found updated drivers for my Silicon Image SiI 3112 sata raid controller... I remember it working fine after that but it is possible. I did a driver roll back and I'm still losing data... :(

I'll read the corruption 101 link you mentioned a little bit more
 
I am thinking one thing though... I recall using windows update and it found updated drivers for my Silicon Image SiI 3112 sata raid controller... I remember it working fine after that but it is possible.
This is just FYI, but I wouldn't recommend using Windows Update to ever update drivers. The main reason being they're usually older than the drivers you're currently using, especially if you went to the manufacturer website for the driver originally. The other reason being they aren't always the correct driver and you may have problems after installing them or lose functionality on your devices.

It might be a good idea to reinstall the real Silicon Image driver (check their website for the newest) and make sure you're using the driver you think you are.
 
The partition is probably "dirty." Theres a command that checks if it is. I have the same setup and my 250 was running chkdsk at bootup and all my files would slowly get bad (even though they looked fine).

It came to a point where I'd MKD and I then could del the dir. A format would "del" for good, but eventually it'd happen again.

Scan the Disk storage forum for the "dirty" partition syndrome.
 
I was having a massive problem with corruption (no data loss, but that was probably in the future) until I updated the SiI 3112 BIOS to the newest revision (4.2.50)

This has solved the corruption issues I was getting on my SATA RAID, and it may solve your problems.

 
After lots of frustration, a format and several backup/restores later i have figured out what is wrong.

I am nearly positive that the secondary serial adapter is borked. I took out the drive and put a native SATA drive on it (an extra 34 gig raptor i had which i took out when i upgraded to the large raptor). And now files on that 34 gig raptor are getting corrupt.

This time it only has the newest SI drivers.

I changed the cable and still have the same issue :(
 
Back
Top