InvisiBill
2[H]4U
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2003
- Messages
- 2,608
I love the idea of the ECP, but I'm really not happy with the product itself. I'm currently doing something like this so that I can use it, but it's obviously not all that pretty just sticking out the front of my RC-690. This is better, but I still don't like the way the component heights are mismatched and it uses big unfinished buttons and jumpers and stuff.
I was looking at components and thinking that it'd be pretty simple to make my own custom ECP out of the individual components. From what I can tell, there really isn't anything on the ECP's PCB, it just serves as a holder for all the components. This means I should be able to just put wire leads on each component and mount it as desired in my case.
Here are the things I'd like to improve...
I thought some others might not be satisfied with their ECP as well, but not familiar with getting their own electronic components. I'm probably going to do this (eventually) anyway, and just though I'd see if anyone else was interested. Also, the E760 (original non-NF200) and E769 (Hydro Copper) versions don't come with the ECP, but do appear to have the ECP connector, if those owners would like to add this feature.
My thought is to just have each component with wire leads connected to it, which plug into the connector on the board. You would need to find a way to mount each component as you desire, but you wouldn't have the PCB or other components getting in your way. For example, you could use DIP switches for the voltage boost and PCIe disable and have them mounted in a drive bay, get a bigger LED digit display to mount in the front of your case, use your case's existing power/reset/HDD buttons and LEDs, and just ignore the CMOS reset button. It would require some work to mount the stuff, but you'd basically have complete freedom in doing so.
Anyone else interested in this? Got suggestions for anything?
For those of you not familiar with the ECP, http://files.invisibill.net/1244156544.mov (20MB) is a clip I made when having problems with the board, if you want to see it in action.
P.S. No, this won't work on other motherboards. The Classified has additional pins made specifically for this. You could try doing this with another board, but you'd have to solder to the right points on the board to tap into those circuits. It could be done, but those capable of doing it probably aren't reading this note.
I was looking at components and thinking that it'd be pretty simple to make my own custom ECP out of the individual components. From what I can tell, there really isn't anything on the ECP's PCB, it just serves as a holder for all the components. This means I should be able to just put wire leads on each component and mount it as desired in my case.
Here are the things I'd like to improve...
- I love the ECP's power and reset buttons/LEDs. A quick search didn't seem to turn up any switches exactly like that though. I'll have to keep looking. For those of you not familiar with it, the power LED is in the middle of the power button, and the HDD LED is in the middle of the reset button. See the second link above for a pic.
- I hate the jumpers for PCIe disable. I can understand jumpers on the motherboard, especially since that's how the ECP can easily connect to it. However, DIP switches would be much more "finished" in my eyes. You don't have to worry about trying to pull little jumpers off or losing them or having them stick out too far. Just a nice little row of four on/off switches. For you old timers, just like on the old modems.
- I'm pretty sure the buttons they use for the voltage boost are meant to be internal, and have some sort of cap over them to actually push them down. Even when you've got them pushed in, I think they still stick up higher than anything else on the ECP. Another case where a row of three DIP switches could be used. The biggest issue I can see is that you may want to turn them on or off quickly, and DIP switches aren't always the easiest to use. However, as you can see in the link above, there are some that have decently sized levers. I think the right switches could make this less likely to get bumped accidentally, but still easy enough to use quickly.
- The CMOS reset switch is ok in that it's small and recessed, like the one on the I/O panel of the board. However, without some sort of cover plate, it's just sitting out in the open and easy to press. This could also be run into a DIP switch - flipping it on would be like holding the button down, and turn it off to release the button.
- I don't really have an issue with the BIOS code/temp display, but a custom one could be made larger (or smaller) if preferred.
I thought some others might not be satisfied with their ECP as well, but not familiar with getting their own electronic components. I'm probably going to do this (eventually) anyway, and just though I'd see if anyone else was interested. Also, the E760 (original non-NF200) and E769 (Hydro Copper) versions don't come with the ECP, but do appear to have the ECP connector, if those owners would like to add this feature.
My thought is to just have each component with wire leads connected to it, which plug into the connector on the board. You would need to find a way to mount each component as you desire, but you wouldn't have the PCB or other components getting in your way. For example, you could use DIP switches for the voltage boost and PCIe disable and have them mounted in a drive bay, get a bigger LED digit display to mount in the front of your case, use your case's existing power/reset/HDD buttons and LEDs, and just ignore the CMOS reset button. It would require some work to mount the stuff, but you'd basically have complete freedom in doing so.
Anyone else interested in this? Got suggestions for anything?
For those of you not familiar with the ECP, http://files.invisibill.net/1244156544.mov (20MB) is a clip I made when having problems with the board, if you want to see it in action.
P.S. No, this won't work on other motherboards. The Classified has additional pins made specifically for this. You could try doing this with another board, but you'd have to solder to the right points on the board to tap into those circuits. It could be done, but those capable of doing it probably aren't reading this note.