Curious about other experiences with WD

Stormrider

n00b
Joined
Sep 4, 2004
Messages
61
I bought 2 WD 80gb 7200 for my computer last august/september. Since then they have both died - one over Xmas, very inoccuous and inasuspicious death. Just stopped working. And just this weekend I lost my other in a large puff of acrid smoke. For roughly 4 and 6 months, respectively, I am not very pleased.

Has anybody else had similar luck with WD? I wanted to go Seagate, but the local shop guys eventually got me to buy their WDs after they price matched (no shipping costs). I think I am gonna order a 73gb Raptor to replace those chumpy drives.

So yah, I am just curious if anybody else has had any streaks of bad luck like myself or?
 
Sometimes you get bad drives, happens with any manufacturer, i've got 20 and 40 gig WD's that have been running solid for years. Hell i've got an old 2 gig that still runs.
 
I have had Seagates that went bad after six months and I have had Western Digitals that have lasted years. That being said, I did have one WD go bad; after it fell off the hard drive rack. It's never been quite the same... ;) Of the ten WD drives or so that I've had, this is the only time I have had one go bad on me.

Don't even get me started on Fujitsu SCSI drives. :mad:
 
Well to be fair I've owned half a dozen WD's previous to these two, but they were all unremarkable, though reliable, drives. I am just kinda miffed that 2 new drives died so soon. It would have been enough of a push to send me to another company - cept nobody else has something like the Raptor. So I will stick with them for that.
 
Are you certain the PSU isn't killing those drives?

Anyway, I've better experiences with WD than with Maxtor, but neither of them would be considered over Samsung, Seagate or Hitachi (their own, not the Deskstar ones) HDDs.
 
Well, I had that suspicion, but A) I cant afford a good new PSU now and B) it SHOULDNT.. I went semi budget with a ThermalTake 420 PP, but I did check alot of different reviews of it. They all seemed to say the stability of the lines was pretty good except under heavy draw, and my system isnt that bad. 2 opticals, 1 HD, a 3400+ on a Soltek, and an X800 Pro. If I absolutely have to I can blow the rest of my tax return on a new PSU, was thinking the modular Neopower from Antec, but I really dont want to.
 
Stormrider said:
Well, I had that suspicion, but A) I cant afford a good new PSU now
It's more expensive to replace components damaged by a bad PSU.
and B) it SHOULDNT..
It's not like the PSU cares whether it is frying your HDDs :)
I went semi budget with a ThermalTake 420 PP, but I did check alot of different reviews of it. They all seemed to say the stability of the lines was pretty good except under heavy draw, and my system isnt that bad. 2 opticals, 1 HD, a 3400+ on a Soltek, and an X800 Pro. If I absolutely have to I can blow the rest of my tax return on a new PSU, was thinking the modular Neopower from Antec, but I really dont want to.
At the very least test the rails with a DMM while the system is running.
 
I've had several (3 or 4) WD 20GB drives die on me. click-click-click-click (and were those effers HOT).
 
As a matter of fact I just replaced my TT PP420 with an Enermax 600W SLI PSU because it was killing motherboards and NICs... I trusted that PSU for a couple of years but I had to come to grips sooner or later, and just FYI, I currently have 6 WD drives in my machine, all running happily =]...

And as for the Seagate Cheetah SCSI drives, sure they're fast, but even the 15K drives aren't more than 3-4 percent faster than the 74GB Raptors, hit up Anandtech.com and StorageReview.com for their review and you'll see that most of the 15K SCSI drives actually lag behind the Raptors when they're on a good controller...
 
Elledan said:
At the very least test the rails with a DMM while the system is running.

Not only while running, try to get a reading on cold startup. Could be your 12 volt rail is just a bit on the lite side. It's worth a check anyway.

Raptors and drives like those are sensitive to heat. I have a fan blowing outside air directly on my 74 and the drive is cool to the touch even while running 24/7.

Just some stuff to check

Luck
 
Nikola said:
And as for the Seagate Cheetah SCSI drives, sure they're fast, but even the 15K drives aren't more than 3-4 percent faster than the 74GB Raptors, hit up Anandtech.com and StorageReview.com for their review and you'll see that most of the 15K SCSI drives actually lag behind the Raptors when they're on a good controller...

I am not a big fan of AnandTech reviews...

Even so, they are indeed faster (even if by 3 to 4%). The poster said that there was nothing like the Raptor, so even if the Cheetahs were identical in speed to the Raptors, the Cheetahs would, in fact, be a viable alternative for the poster. ;)

For that matter, the new Diamonds by Maxtor -- though I wouldn't touch one -- are supposed to be almost as fast despite having a slower platter (that's where the 16 MB cache comes in).

My wife has a 160 GB Seagate Barracuda drive and I have the 74 GB Western Digital Raptor drive. I don't notice much difference at all between our two systems on drive access. You can get the Seagate (with double the capacity) for less than the Raptor, and I think that would be a better deal overall.

All my 0,02 USD, YMMV, IMO, etc.
 
There is only one Seagate drive faster than the Raptor in single user performance, the Cheetah 15K.4, and that's only when you switch its firmware to 'desktop' mode. The 15K.3 is fairly close, but still goes down in defeat. We won't even talk about I/Os per dollar, as the Seagate SCSI drives are totally put to shame there. A 37GB 15K.4 is $300 on ZZF - the 73GB is $575. I love my Seagate drives - the 350G non-op shock resistances and 5 year warranty give me a lot of peace of mind when I'm moving my SFF system - but those looking for blazing SCSI performance need to look to Fujitsu and Maxtor. Seagate does make the quietest SCSI drives, but if I'm going to pop over $5 per GB, I'm going to want the fastest drive in that price range, acoustics be damned, which is delivered by Maxtor with Fujitsu in a fairly close second. Seagate has not had a drive on SR's Leaderboard since Q3 of _2002_ - they have really lost their way on performance. I must admit that the Savvio is pretty darn slick - but like many Seagate drives, I can't afford one. I really cannot understand why so many people out there recommend Seagate for high performance storage, when Seagate's strong points of late have been most everything but raw performance.

EDIT: On the original topic, out of all of my drives (see sig) I have had 2 WDs fail. All other brands have been flawless in this millenium. I did lose an 8GB IBM Deskstar back in 1999. I almost forgot to make an on topic post :D
 
I was singularly unimpressed with that review on StorageReview. The fact that it took two samples to generate those positive numbers implies to me quality control issues that seem to be Maxtor's hallmark.
 
MalfurionStormrage said:
I was singularly unimpressed with that review on StorageReview. The fact that it took two samples to generate those positive numbers implies to me quality control issues that seem to be Maxtor's hallmark.

Are you talking about the MaxLineIII first review sample that had a average read service time that was off by about 3ms? I can't find any data about Maxtor having to ship out a replacement review sample on either of the latest generation Atlas drives (10K V and 15K II). Don't forget that Maxtor's SCSI division is basically what's left of Quantum, and I'm sure that Maxtor's management is well aware that things that will work in the ATA consumer arena will fly like a lead zeppelin in the enterprise arena.

Also, I never said that Seagate drives suck, and Seagate drives maintain many advantages that their competitots cannot/will not offer. But it is a simple fact that users looking for the fastest hard drives available should look to Fujitsu and Maxtor SCSI, and they should only consider Seagate if factors such as noise, heat, etc are more important than the raw performance.
 
Don't buy anything between 20 and 60 GB. I have a pile of 13 dead WD disks of that era on my desk. They're about 2 or 3 years old and just do not work.

I can't speak for anything else, but that era is absolute crap.
 
Both Fujitsu and Maxtor have bad reputations in my book. Only Maxtor's purchase of Quantum gives me hope that they have left their crappy reputations behind and can make platters that don't resemble plowed fields. I have several failed RAID 5 arrays that "featured" Fujitsu drives in them (two drives failed simultaneously in each case) where Seagate drives performed flawlessly when we replaced the Fujitsu drives with them.

I'm not a huge Seagate fan myself. I happen to like Western Digital drives above all others -- in non-SCSI solutions -- (except when Quantum was not a subsidiary of Maxtor), but if someone wants a recommendation other than Western Digital, I will go ahead and point them towards Seagate.

unhappy_mage said:
Don't buy anything between 20 and 60 GB. I have a pile of 13 dead WD disks of that era on my desk. They're about 2 or 3 years old and just do not work.

I can't speak for anything else, but that era is absolute crap.

That's funny. I have a 20 GB and a 40 GB WD that are on their third and fourth year, respectively, of absolutely flawless performance.
 
I actually like WD and Seagate drives over Maxtors. I have not had the chance to try out Hitachi or Samsung drives though. Seagates have been quiet for me, and I run a WD in each of my two computers (and one Seagate). One is about 4 years old (WD400BB), another is over a year old (WD1600JB), both have been fine.

If I were to get a new drive, it would probably be a Seagate though.
 
Basically, you will get screwed by every HD manufacturer eventually, and it is very difficult to make unbiased decisions untill you get screwed over by each and every manufacturer once :)

I have personally had good luck with WD and Maxtor, and I just bought my first Seagate drive yesterday due to its competitive price and 5yr warranty. So, basically you are bound to find a lemon eventually, just make sure you backup your data regardless of your choice.
 
MalfurionStormrage said:
That's funny. I have a 20 GB and a 40 GB WD that are on their third and fourth year, respectively, of absolutely flawless performance.
We bought 30 disks and a year later 4 were down. 2 years, 12 disks. in their 3rd year, we lost another one. Your Mileage May Vary, but that's what we had.

I'm using all seagate disks now, except for a pair of Maxtor 60GB disks that are in my file server in raid0 soon to be raid1.

As others have said, sooner or later you'll accumulate a lemon from every company, it's just a matter of which lemons you find first. Keep backups and you can ignore the lemons.
 
there's bad batches from all drive makers, just sucks to be on the end that gets hit

my psu seems to hold up alright with my loads, left my multimeter recording the high-lows for about 10mins while playing games and it was 12.27v-12.32v
 
I have one 80GB WD that is functional, yet it isn't used very much. And I have one 160GB WD that started failing at about 14 months.

I've sticking with Maxtor now, since I've used many of their drives and have never had one fail.
 
Back
Top