Crysis vs Counter-Strike: Source

SBSuperfly

Gawd
Joined
Feb 1, 2006
Messages
865
I've been watching a lotta video of Crysis and I have to say the multiplayer looks great. I've been playing CS:S for years and I may have to abandon it later this year. Does Valve have something up its sleeve to compete?
 
I don't think they need too. Since cs 1.6 is still the #1 most played fps in existence and source ain't that far behind, why change anything?

Besides getting rid of the stupid ads, of course.
 
Counter strike 1.6 and Counter Strike Source have more players than any other FPS online by about a factor of 10 they don't need to do anything to compete with any game currently out.

I doubt crysis will pull in many multiplayer fans, the singleplayer will no doubt be great but I don't see it being massive online.

Counter strike is popular because HL is/was popular, it's a mod that was built upon a very popular engine at the time which meant that it's reachable fanbase was very big. It was also one of the first games to heavily introduce competative play online is a more realistic environment. It's been around for so long that it will probably never entirely die.

I'd like to see more players into other FPS games, I hope UT3 takes off big that engine is going to crush the source engine.
 
I don't think we can tell seeing as how the game isn't out yet.
 
What does Valve need to worry about? There is a reason why CS1.6 is the most played FPS ever. It has about 100,000 people online at any time, that is three times and more as CSS has. In the end, the game play will determined everything.
 
I doubt there's any "competition" here. They're in the same market of FPS gaming, but in different subsections. Counterstrike released a long while ago and has already accrued the bulk of their sales, and runs on much lower specs.

Crysis appeals to the consumers with higher end specs who are capable of running that game well, those higher end gamers would have already purchased Counterstrike by this time, if they haven't, it's likely that they won't. It's just unlikely that many people will face a decision of, "Should I buy Crisis, or Counterstrike?". For the most part, those people can afford to just get both:p

Valve's Orange box vs. Crysis may be a better comparison of a two packages that could be competiting for a sale in the future.
 
You're pretty close about the 100,000 for CS1.6, this morning there are about 86,000 per gamespy stats, but CSS has about 71,000 running on it as well so they are pretty close....

In the end though, you're absolutely right, the next closest game is Battlefield 2 at 17,000, 4 times less than CSS and 5 times less that CS1.6. That's pretty incredible.

What does Valve need to worry about? There is a reason why CS1.6 is the most played FPS ever. It has about 100,000 people online at any time, that is three times and more as CSS has. In the end, the game play will determined everything.
 
Valve's Orange box vs. Crysis may be a better comparison of a two packages that could be competiting for a sale in the future.

This is the first i've heard of the orange box. It seems to have a lot of goodies. However, I am disappointed in Team Fortress 2 going cartoony-- seems like a waste of DirectX 10 fanciness.
 
I doubt there's any "competition" here. They're in the same market of FPS gaming, but in different subsections. Counterstrike released a long while ago and has already accrued the bulk of their sales, and runs on much lower specs.

Crysis appeals to the consumers with higher end specs who are capable of running that game well, those higher end gamers would have already purchased Counterstrike by this time, if they haven't, it's likely that they won't. It's just unlikely that many people will face a decision of, "Should I buy Crisis, or Counterstrike?". For the most part, those people can afford to just get both:p

Valve's Orange box vs. Crysis may be a better comparison of a two packages that could be competiting for a sale in the future.
I never suggested CS:S and Crysis would compete for sales. I was just wondering if Crysis would be the next BIG THING in online gaming resulting in gamers abandoning some of their older games. Dear GOD! I hope WoW fades away.
 
Counter strike 1.6 and Counter Strike Source have more players than any other FPS online by about a factor of 10 they don't need to do anything to compete with any game currently out.

I doubt crysis will pull in many multiplayer fans, the singleplayer will no doubt be great but I don't see it being massive online.

Counter strike is popular because HL is/was popular, it's a mod that was built upon a very popular engine at the time which meant that it's reachable fanbase was very big. It was also one of the first games to heavily introduce competative play online is a more realistic environment. It's been around for so long that it will probably never entirely die.

I'd like to see more players into other FPS games, I hope UT3 takes off big that engine is going to crush the source engine.

There is nothing realistic about Counterstrike.
 
This is the first i've heard of the orange box. It seems to have a lot of goodies. However, I am disappointed in Team Fortress 2 going cartoony-- seems like a waste of DirectX 10 fanciness.

TF2 isn't DirectX 10, and it's a game based on gameplay, not on graphics. Most companies have forgotten this caveat, which is why their multiplayer will never compete with a game like Counter-Strike.
 
This is the first i've heard of the orange box. It seems to have a lot of goodies. However, I am disappointed in Team Fortress 2 going cartoony-- seems like a waste of DirectX 10 fanciness.

I suggest you check out this trailer.
http://www.gametrailers.com/player.php?id=19522&type=wmv&pl=game

I was pretty impressed by Valve's facial animation technology(as opposed to sticking dots to an actor's face in a mo-cap lab). That's pretty damned good. But it's a subtle effect.

More vids here:
http://www.gametrailers.com/gamepage.php?id=3034

The graphics are quite nice, just not aiming for photo-realism. The different goal in terms of artistic theme isn't necessarily better or worse, just different. By nice, I mean it's polished and consistent.

For what it's worth, graphics can be good on an artistic basis as well as a technical basis. It can be highly detailed and well constructed, but if the sum doesn't stand out in terms of imagination then it can still be deemed mediocre. Consider the look of some outrageous-looking Japanese games like Katamari Damacy, Viewtiful Joe, and Okami. They have a very memorable and distinct look even though there are quite a few games that are more technically advanced.

TF2 is taking an art theme similar to NOLF, and as another poster mentioned, Evil Genius.
 
Well SC series is impresive as king off the hill online game.
And with that the most sucsesfull Mod.

Crysis have Mplay to, but it's not a pure online game.

So even if it can't take a dent in SC numbers. It's zero vs a whole lota offline Players. Doing the single player storyline of Crysis.

That why this is apple vs banana's.
 
There is nothing realistic about Counterstrike.

Gee you're right I don't recognise anything in the whole game thats even close to realistic :rolleyes:

Seriously though, when I say "more realistic" I mean more realistic than other games, for example Quake or Unreal Tournament which are not grounded in reality which CS obviously is.

Although I get your point, counter strikes gameplay veers quite steeply away from actual gun fights, doesn't really change what I'm saying though, what it offered at the time was unique.
 
What's with the all or nothing viewpoint on this topic. Is there some unknown rule that you can't play more than one online shooter at a time? Online gaming isn't a marriage.

Maybe in the morning I'll roll off Crysis, take a shower and then play a little source. Later that day Ill finish lunch, and enjoy a little afternoon delight with HL: Deathmatch. Oh, whats this? Night has arrived and it's time to dim the lights and take Crysis for another go.

If only I were joking.
 
What's with the all or nothing viewpoint on this topic. Is there some unknown rule that you can't play more than one online shooter at a time? Online gaming isn't a marriage.

Maybe in the morning I'll roll off Crysis, take a shower and then play a little source. Later that day Ill finish lunch, and enjoy a little afternoon delight with HL: Deathmatch. Oh, whats this? Night has arrived and it's time to dim the lights and take Crysis for another go.

If only I were joking.

I like to play competetively, so thats why it's pretty much all or nothing for me. To be good enough to be competetive in CAL requires a ton of practice. If I didn't have a job, wife, and baby on the way; I'd have the entire day to play whatever I wanted as you suggest.
 
Seriously though, when I say "more realistic" I mean more realistic than other games, for example Quake or Unreal Tournament which are not grounded in reality which CS obviously is.

What kind of reality allows me to jump off of a 10 foot ledge holding a large and very heavy sniper rifle, spin around in mid air, scope in, and fire for a kill as soon as I touch the ground?
 
What kind of reality allows me to jump off of a 10 foot ledge holding a large and very heavy sniper rifle, spin around in mid air, scope in, and fire for a kill as soon as I touch the ground?

Don't forget the bunny hopping assholes from earlier versions. Yeah, real realistic. They have gun models that somewhat resemble the real thing. That's about where it ends. In any case, I don't see why there is even a comparison to Crysis and CS. One is a sci-fi shooter with a story and the other is a mod of a FPS that was designed for online play alone. There is no reason you can't play both at different times.
 
What kind of reality allows me to jump off of a 10 foot ledge holding a large and very heavy sniper rifle, spin around in mid air, scope in, and fire for a kill as soon as I touch the ground?

I know you're kidding, but still:

It's from movie reality. Similar to Action Quake 2(Named so because it wants to recreate the feel of action movies), the project Gooseman had been with before branching off to work on Counter-strike.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minh_Le
 
You people are rediculous.... do you guys even forget when CS came out? I'm sorry... but for its day... I thought it was pretty close to realism.... This game changed the whole era on team based, round based FPS. Sure its not as real as the games out now... but for its day... I mean come on.... :rolleyes:
 
Crysis wont even make a dent in mp because for one you need a friggin monster of a pc to enjoy this game.... whereas CS well u get the picture.
 
The main reason Crysis MIGHT compete for a significant share of online gamers is the because of the destroyable world. If they take that aspect far enough it could be pretty cool....

Sniper can't see the enemy through the forest? No problem, a heavy weapons guy can just chain gun all the trees down, predator style.
 
Crysis wont even make a dent in mp because for one you need a friggin monster of a pc to enjoy this game.... whereas CS well u get the picture.

Not really. I guess if you want to play Multiplayer with every detail on ultra mega super high and with 16x AA and 16x AF, then sure its going to run like ass... but why would you even try to play multiplayer with high graphics settings anyway? It'd be like playing trying to play UT with the coronas on and world detail on high.
 
Don't forget the bunny hopping assholes from earlier versions. Yeah, real realistic.

It was the bunny hopping alone that made me sick of the entire UT series. OTOH, I got into CS just as they crippled bunny hopping, so I'm on the opposite side of the fence there.
 
It was the bunny hopping alone that made me sick of the entire UT series. OTOH, I got into CS just as they crippled bunny hopping, so I'm on the opposite side of the fence there.

Only newbs bunny hop in UT. Bunny hopping just makes you an easy target for ... well, any weapon in the UT games.
 
What kind of reality allows me to jump off of a 10 foot ledge holding a large and very heavy sniper rifle, spin around in mid air, scope in, and fire for a kill as soon as I touch the ground?

Stop being pedantic. "Realistic" is well accepted as being used to compare CS to the Sci fi type shooters. Everyone knows it's not real in the sense of the physics, guns, bullets, or anything else. It's a matter of degree, stop being an ass.
 
You people are rediculous.... do you guys even forget when CS came out? I'm sorry... but for its day... I thought it was pretty close to realism.... This game changed the whole era on team based, round based FPS. Sure its not as real as the games out now... but for its day... I mean come on.... :rolleyes:

This is also true. Swat, a mod for quake was the first FPS game with rolling recoil from hit-scan bullet-based guns. That mod led to Action Quake 2, leading to Counterstrike, leading to the slew of bullet-based games that are out today. Counterstrike was pretty special in that it was a game that revolved around bullets and recoil(quake, UT, halflife, duke nukem, these were the sorts of weaponry you'd see, rather than bullet-based guns). Before these games, you could go full-auto and have every bullet land on top of the other.
 
What kind of reality allows me to jump off of a 10 foot ledge holding a large and very heavy sniper rifle, spin around in mid air, scope in, and fire for a kill as soon as I touch the ground?

So for you to think games to be real, you should limit how fast the mouse moves? Because I'm sure that would piss off a lot of people and make the game relatively not fun.

As per dropping a 10 foot edge.. you've never jumped off of anything 10 feet?.. and you can spin in air...

Sure all together its really really far fetched...


But show me something thats more realistic besides Americas army.. that is actually fun.
 
stop being an ass.

No! ;D

So for you to think games to be real, you should limit how fast the mouse moves? Because I'm sure that would piss off a lot of people and make the game relatively not fun.

As per dropping a 10 foot edge.. you've never jumped off of anything 10 feet?.. and you can spin in air...

Sure all together its really really far fetched...


But show me something thats more realistic besides Americas army.. that is actually fun.

Um... I wasnt trying to argue that I want reality in games, thats actually what I don't want. I was just trying to say that CS isnt exactly a good model of realism besides the real life rifles.
 
Remeber FarCry? Sorry but online play was very very under populated

Nice graphics doesnt mean good multiplayer action..


[EDIT] For Crysis to really take over, or compete it NEEDS to allow 3rd party add-ons to be made for it easily, this is why Valve has been so sucessful, provide tools and code for ANYONE to be able to make add-ons.
 
Remeber FarCry? Sorry but online play was very very under populated

Nice graphics doesnt mean good multiplayer action..

It was under populated because it was just awful to play. FarCry multiplayer was the most random and bizarre multiplayer experience I've ever had. You can fire a shot right into an enemy, watch them wince in pain, see the bullet trail pass right through them, but somehow miss.

You can kill someone in one hit with the pistol in what seems to be pure random luck. Trying to jump up on rocks or other platforms is even more fun too, because you either slide off of the ledge you were aiming for, or fall 2 feet and lose all your health. I feel like nobody in the studio even playtested the multiplayer before release, or maybe they were all just really, really drunk when they did.
 
<snip>

For Crysis to really take over, or compete it NEEDS to allow 3rd party add-ons to be made for it easily, this is why Valve has been so sucessful, provide tools and code for ANYONE to be able to make add-ons.

I'm pretty sure this is one of their goals, and from what I've read so far, they are implementing it.
 
Crysis has demanding reqs and therefore won't be very popular online... at least for a while. CS will continue to pwn every other MP game until the end of human existence... Why dust map never gets old? Only god knows that... monotony is praised by the majority of gamers. :p
 
Don't forget the bunny hopping assholes from earlier versions. Yeah, real realistic. They have gun models that somewhat resemble the real thing. That's about where it ends. In any case, I don't see why there is even a comparison to Crysis and CS. One is a sci-fi shooter with a story and the other is a mod of a FPS that was designed for online play alone. There is no reason you can't play both at different times.

Gun models are quite accurate to their real counterparts, the character models are fairly realistic (as much as the engine will allow) all the basic rules of physics are in the game, most relevant real life systems are modled, health, accuracy, money, ammunition, reloading, hitboxes. Maps are scaled correctly to real life, and largely contain real life objects.

I'm not saying it's the most realisitc game out there but for it's time when it was created (way back when) it was the only real attempt at that sort of thing and thats why it gained so much popularity.

And yes, it's true, there's no real reason why you cannot play Crysis and CCS on and off at the same time, although I would suggest that anyone who plays CS of any veriaty needs to play a lot of CS to be any good, and IMO you need to be reasonably good to enjoy yourself in that game.
 
Gun models are quite accurate to their real counterparts, the character models are fairly realistic (as much as the engine will allow) all the basic rules of physics are in the game, most relevant real life systems are modled, health, accuracy, money, ammunition, reloading, hitboxes. Maps are scaled correctly to real life, and largely contain real life objects.

I'm not saying it's the most realisitc game out there but for it's time when it was created (way back when) it was the only real attempt at that sort of thing and thats why it gained so much popularity.

And yes, it's true, there's no real reason why you cannot play Crysis and CCS on and off at the same time, although I would suggest that anyone who plays CS of any veriaty needs to play a lot of CS to be any good, and IMO you need to be reasonably good to enjoy yourself in that game.

QFT
 
Gun models are quite accurate to their real counterparts,

Like hell they are. As an owner of at least a couple of the weapons shown in that game I disagree. The AK-47 for example is far from correct.

http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=56928

The AK-47 ejects spent shell casings to the right of the shooter. The M4/M16 also eject the shell casings reward, and then they are deflected off a portrusion built into the side of the weapon forcing the casings to move to the right and back. Thus ejecting at a right hand-rearward angle. The M4 in counterstrike doesn't take this into account and ejects the casings to the left of the shooter as the weapon model is half assed reversed. Also if this weapon were simulated correctly, but reversed the shell casings would hit the shooter in the chest every single time as the casings are ejected in a rear-left manner. Additionally the Desert Eagle doesn't eject to the left either.

Guns in games are typically operated incorrectly as well. The M4 for example has a slide lock as does any other automatic or semi-automatic weapon. When ammunition in the magazine is expended the slide locks back. When you insert another magazine, all you need to do is hit the slide release and your ready to go again. That's one thing that pisses me off in games. Reloading actually takes longer in the game in some instances than it would in real life making it easier for you to get killed all because you can't return fire in a timely fashion. Also if you relead without being completely out of ammo, all you need to do is replace the clip or magazine and your done. The fact that every game forces the weapon to have to be cocked again is stupid. Also whenever you reload, and you are not out of ammo, the weapon should eject a round if it wasn't completely out of ammo as well.
 
Crysis wont even make a dent in mp because for one you need a friggin monster of a pc to enjoy this game.... whereas CS well u get the picture.

Not relevant. You'll always get the pubstars going around in DX7 with all particle effects off to give themselves any advantage they can, from higher framerates to turning dust and leaves off. It doesn't matter how it looks, because there'll be people taking it far too seriously whatever.
 
Back
Top