CRYORIG Official Statement Regarding Skylake PCB Conerns

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We at CRYORIG have the following information and statement to make, regarding the recent news and discussion regarding damaged PCB’s on Skylake CPU’s, which many in the industry believe is caused by abnormal heatsink mounting pressure during transportation of the PC system. First of all we want to assure users of CRYORIG products that currently no CRYORIG heatsinks have displayed this problem, either through media reports, third party sales channels or internal testing. CRYORIG heatsinks are fully compatible with socket 1151 processors, and follow specifications set forth by CPU manufacturers. But as a note of precaution we suggest users to lay their PC system flat (with the heatsink in a vertical position) whenever they are transporting their PC system.

Based on the information and testing reports we currently have at hand, although CRYORIG’s own products did not show this problem, we have derived the following suggestions and insight into the Skylake PCB damage problem. From our observation the cause of the bent/damaged PCB is caused by the combination of two factors.

  • High mounting pressure from the CPU heatsink mounting system, with no flexibility in the system.
  • Increased directional force created by the weight of the heatsink and movement of the PC chassis.

In the cases that have been reported by media, it holds true that these issues have only been observed in “Pre-Built” systems. These systems have the heatsink installed before shipping, which are subjective to both point A+B. Thus if a heatsink already has high mounting pressure with no system of flexibility, heavy weight and is tossed around during shipping, then the force of the heatsink is possible to bend at the softest point. In this case the softest point is the Skylake PCB.

Click HERE to learn what makes CRYORIG heatsinks safe.
 
This whole Skylake PCB thing (Skylakegate? :eek: ) kinda sucks. I just put a Cryorig H5 Universal on a 6700K in my son's rig, but I built it on a HAF XB EVO for transporting between homes (~30 miles apart), so this whole thing is a bit worrisome for me...especially when you add in the fact that he's autistic (he paid for the parts himself). Maybe I should've had him go with a Z97 or X99 instead. :(
 
This whole Skylake PCB thing (Skylakegate? :eek: ) kinda sucks. I just put a Cryorig H5 Universal on a 6700K in my son's rig, but I built it on a HAF XB EVO for transporting between homes (~30 miles apart), so this whole thing is a bit worrisome for me...especially when you add in the fact that he's autistic (he paid for the parts himself). Maybe I should've had him go with a Z97 or X99 instead. :(
CRYORIG did say they suggest laying the computer flat with the heatsink vertical, and this is the way the motherboard is oriented in that case. So I think based on that suggestion that the chance of the CPU being damaged is small in your case so long as it's not being shaken around.
 
CRYORIG did say they suggest laying the computer flat with the heatsink vertical, and this is the way the motherboard is oriented in that case. So I think based on that suggestion that the chance of the CPU being damaged is small in your case so long as it's not being shaken around.
That helps relieve some of the anxiety. My original thoughts about a horizontal mobo were related to the GPU stressing the PCIe slot, but it appears there are other benefits to it in a Skylake build.
 
Ever since mobo tray cutouts, I've never transported a computer with a heatsink attached aside from AIO blocks.
 
Ugh, this breaking the CPU thing is just one more reason to buy an inexpensive laptop that doesn't need a huge cooler and there are enough of them that don't even waste time with a cooling fan now thanks to stuff like Braswell. So much simpler do to stuff that way.
 
Sure, you just have to deal with designs that prioritize form over function and assemblers who apply thermal compound like whipped cream.
 
Back
Top