Crossfire beats SLi in Doom3!!!

Take these results with a grain of salt people.
Its running at low resolutions, its running on Beta Drivers and the tech isnt even out yet.
All though it gives you some slight insight into how Cross Fire might perform.

Just a thought, but is there any reason a Crossfire setup not walk all over a SLI setup? SLI is what 6-7 mounths old? Since its been stocked on shelves? And crossfire is not even out yet? I would think newer is better....

The newer it is the more problems it might still have. While one can never fully remove the problems with software or drivers during a period of time they gradualy improve. SLi has been out for a while thus the drivers have improved thus the performance in games has gotten higher and compatibility has gotten better. The game I like benchmarked is Far Cry though, as it seems biased to no one.
 
Rollo said:
Notice this as well:
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=881152

I got 83fps at 12X10 4X8X and 67fps at 16X12 4X8X with 3800+/6800GTs. I think Hardinfo should change their name to Tardinfo if they're using the standard Doom3 benchmark.

After these benchmarks..with different preformance..I can't wait to see the [H]ardOCP's benches...
Ban NDA's! ;)



Achtung is german, not danish :p *L*

Terracide - In danish that would be "GIV AGT!" ;)
 
{NG}Fidel said:
The game I like benchmarked is Far Cry though, as it seems biased to no one.

FarCry is know to run better on ATI hardware than Nvidia, what are you talking about?

Terra...
 
Brent_Justice said:
The best thing to do is run multiple games, which we will of course do ;)

And that is why we eagerly await your verdict ;)

Terra...
 
mohammedtaha said:
But ATI said that both the X800 and X850 cards are AFR compatible. This means that thought has been put into it already. I guess the problem essentially was they might have lied. Their cards aren't AFR ready, the new cards are and this is the only way it can be done.

We, however, can not think this way because there's always a different way of doing things. Not necessarily better, or worse, but different.

Well, technically the X800/850 cards are AFR compatible, but only when combined with a crossfire card lol. Believe me, if ATI could run two normal cards in AFR mode, we would have seen it a long time ago.
 
FarCry is know to run better on ATI hardware than Nvidia, what are you talking about?

Their is a diffrence from running better on one card than being MADE to run better on another card.
I choose Far Cry because its a the way its meant to be played game that runs faster on ATi hardware.
Of course Brent is right anyway, its better to run multiple games based off of various engines.
 
Brent_Justice said:
The best thing to do is run multiple games, which we will of course do ;)

You say that like you've rarely done it.

What he meant to say was...

Wait for our review ...
 
{NG}Fidel said:
Their is a diffrence from running better on one card than being MADE to run better on another card.
I choose Far Cry because its a the way its meant to be played game that runs faster on ATi hardware.
Of course Brent is right anyway, its better to run multiple games based off of various engines.

I don't think any company actually makes a game with the intention of it running best on one companies hardware. Why? They won't make as much money. They will make far more money if they design the game to run well on as many video cards as possible. Doom3, while it runs the best on nVidia cards, still runs pretty good on ATI cards. HL2 which runs best on ATI cards, still runs great on nVidia cards.

In reality, ALL games are going to work better on one type of hardware - it's just the nature of the beast. Someone has to come out on top.

The small sum of money that nVidia or ATI pays to a developer to put the "meant to be played" logo on the screen pales in comparison to the amount of money the company will make off of sales if they design a well balanced product.
 
1c3d0g said:
I'm trusting on [H] and FiringSquad (they have a 2405FPW ;) ) to benchmark in 1600x1200 4xAA 16xAF and in 1920x1200 4xAA 16xAF. Now that'll be interesting to see who comes out on top... :)

Where did you see this? I too have a 2405FPW, and find it very annoying that I cant find any reviews done in 1920x1200.
 
Their is definitly some collaboration on the part of the game maker and the card sponser on how to make the game run faster on their cards.
That logo is not all they buy. Some times its vicious what the game dev sometimes its not.
HL2 runs fine on current Nvidia cards, but the money(6mil) was send during the reign of the 9x00 and 5x00 thus the devs targeted their efforts towards the 9x00 series vs 5x00 series.
Any card in the current gen can churn through HL2 like butter.
I do agree with you though.
But optimizations still exists of course they dont really bother me all that much.
And in the end game benchmarks like DOOM3 and HL2 are still real world tests.
 
Like sands through the hour glass........................so are the days of our lifes.........*cough* ahem sorry....

yeah so i read the first page, full of fan boys and nvida is better NOOOOOO ati is better.......so i skiped to the 5th page (thinking all there is is more drama and omg wait till this comes out its gonna lay the smackith downith on _______) so i decide to post

and tell you....you are all WRONG i am right......

in the year 2019, I! will relese a video card that will revolounatize the world as we know it today! you can have res of 16 BILLION by 29 MILLION omg yes

now i tell you brothen jump on my bangwagon of fan boys and join me!!!

ok, serriously, stop fighting about whos is better, its kinda boreing seeing all the video card threads turn into a fight about whos tech is better........and for those fan boys saying "wait till 7800 comes out" or wtfever its called......serriously, to that i say wait till the year 2019 my friend!!!

soulsaver_8229
 
I(illa Bee said:
Just a thought, but is there any reason a Crossfire setup not walk all over a SLI setup? SLI is what 6-7 mounths old? Since its been stocked on shelves? And crossfire is not even out yet? I would think newer is better....

I think ATI should be working on a new card and not just dubbling there current line.. I hope they are anyway...

Personally I think they'll scale exactly the same as they scale now. X850XT-PE's are faster than 6800Ultra's at everything except maybe Doom 3. Even there its close.

The 6800GT's are as fast as the X800XL and some cases on is faster than the other.

Between SLi and Crossfire I would suspect the SAME thing we see now. Even at 100% effeciency on BOTH SLi and Crossfire, they'd scale exactly the same as they would in single card mode.

The real advantage to the ATi implimentation is with the drivers not being profile dependant. I would expect some more efficiency out of Crossfire, because most of the work is done in hardware. What I don't like is the master/slave card situation. I agree this hardware should have been on the motherboard.

What I predict will happen is this, Crossfire will be faster than comparable SLi by a slight margin, but ONLY because of better implimentation with drivers. However, current SLi owners will not likely feel the need to upgrade, as the difference will be small between SLi and Crossfire. The same as it is between current ATi and Nvidia single card configurations.

Also when it comes to cost, expect the cost of a Crossfire capable motherboard to be higher than that of an NForce 4 SLi board due to it being new and at first, out only in limited quantities. Also I'd expect a price hike on the Crossfire Edition cards.

I would also expect early driver difficulties, and some issues relating to its use in certain games. Just like SLi, but no doubt better than SLi was at launch.

So overall, I expect Crossfire to be faster by a small margine, Nvidia will improve the SLi drivers, and the best bang for the buck will likley still go to Nvidia like it does today for most price points, simply because you'll get more performance for less money out of the tried and true SLi setup vs. Crossfire.

People who are building a new system may seriously want to pay the extra for the performance of Crossfire vs. SLi, but existing NForce 4 owners and SLi users probably shouldn't worry about switching over to Crossfire. Remember, even if the Crossfire setup was 100% efficient (highly unlikely), it still wouldn't be *THAT* much faster than SLi. Still SLi will be cheaper for a long time to come.

If you really look at how everything works, under the best case scenario, it will be the SAME as it is today between ATi and Nvidia. The cards that ATi has that are faster than their Nvidia counterparts will be faster in Crossfire than Nvidia's SLi, and the reverse is true for those cards that Nvidia has that are faster than comparable ATi cards. At least the SLi platform and the NForce 4 will or already have all the major issues worked out already and they've been through a couple price drops.

So, while there are no real benches of final product available, even in the best circumstances, they'll still be roughly even. Crossfire, based on the cards its using can only be at *MOST* 20% faster than a top end SLi system *IF* it were %100 efficient. (Which it won't likely be) and the rest of the difference would be in the power of the X850XT-PE over the 6800Ultra.

That is all. You may now resume the flames and !!!!!! banter. Seriously if you reason on the matter and look at the possibilities for the technology as it stands, knowing what we know about the cards and platforms, you'd realize that this OMFG Crossfire pwnZ!!! is BS, just as SLi is l33t and can't be beat!! Yes Crossfire WILL likley be a bit faster. It will not be so, by any revolutionary amount that destroys SLi completely.
 
{NG}Fidel said:
but the money(6mil) was send during the reign of the 9x00 and 5x00 thus the devs targeted their efforts towards the 9x00 series vs 5x00 series.
Any card in the current gen can churn through HL2 like butter.

i'm getting tired of this accusation

that money was used for the HL2 coupon bundle deal

remember all those Radeon cards you could buy and get a coupon in that would give you a free copy of HL2?
 
Terra said:
I know there is a default benchmark build into Doom3, but you can also make your own.
It just seems like bad benchmarking to me if they use individual benchmarks, leaving us users to second guees how the new rigs will preform compared to what we got, thats all...

you got a problem reading danish ? :p

"Tweaktown havde ingen timedemos at benytte til testen af DoomIII! HARDiNFO var dog på pletten med vores egen ingame demo til Doom III"

they where using there own timedemo "HARDiNFO Boss Demo"
 
Hey, Brent. Is it possible to get Kyle to ask ATI @ computex why they didn't implement AFR's compositing engine into the motherboard or video cards' from the beginning

Was ATi caught off-guard when nVidia announced SLI, or were their cards AFR ready to begin with.
 
mohammedtaha said:
Hey, Brent. Is it possible to get Kyle to ask ATI @ computex why they didn't implement AFR's compositing engine into the motherboard or video cards' from the beginning

Was ATi caught off-guard when nVidia announced SLI, or were their cards AFR ready to begin with.

I know this wasn't directed at me, but I think that SLi did catch ATi off guard. Now I do believe that ATi was partially telling the truth when they said AFR has been built into all thier cards for quite some time. This is probably accurate. They've had the MAXX cards forever which always had two ATi GPU's on them. Its very likely they built that feature in, so they could have put multiple GPU's on a single card to increase performance if they had to in order to compete against Nvidia. Say if the X800's would have come out 40% slower than the 6800 series for example. It is possible that this is the case.

ATi's having to use an external dongle and havnig to create a Crossfire Edition card makes this seem very likely to me.

So while its not entirely new for the GPU's, it is a new implimentation for the cards. Hence the compositing chip on the Crossfire card.

Really, since ATi is still far from ready to sell the whole platform to the public, a year after Nvidia dropped the SLi bomb, it seems very likely that they were caught off guard and have had to work very hard to catch up. Also if they had this in the beggining its likely enough work would have been done to get this stuff released 6 months or even a year ago when Nvidia announced SLi.

Nvidia was slick about it, they announced the AGP cards and that PCI-E cards were comming later. Then BAM right before the PCI-E cards showed up, they announced that with PCI-E cards you could connect them together in SLi. I think it was a huge win for Nvidia and a big shock to ATi.
 
{NG}Fidel said:
Their is definitly some collaboration on the part of the game maker and the card sponser on how to make the game run faster on their cards.
That logo is not all they buy. Some times its vicious what the game dev sometimes its not.
HL2 runs fine on current Nvidia cards, but the money(6mil) was send during the reign of the 9x00 and 5x00 thus the devs targeted their efforts towards the 9x00 series vs 5x00 series.
Any card in the current gen can churn through HL2 like butter.
I do agree with you though.
But optimizations still exists of course they dont really bother me all that much.
And in the end game benchmarks like DOOM3 and HL2 are still real world tests.


Second time you've brought this up in the same thread. Let it go man.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
Nvidia was slick about it, they announced the AGP cards and that PCI-E cards were comming later. Then BAM right before the PCI-E cards showed up, they announced that with PCI-E cards you could connect them together in SLi. I think it was a huge win for Nvidia and a big shock to ATi.

I would agree that ATI was caught off guard. While crossfire works, it isn't the most cost effective solution, and it does look like it was put together at the last second. Since the SLi instructions are built in to the NV40 chip itself, all nVidia has to do is produce a $2 SLi bridge connector and you are good to go. With crossfire, ATI has to include a whole nother chip on every crossfire board which probably costs them an extra $50 to make which is probably gonna mean a $80 increase in consumer price to an already expensive card. Then there is the chance that there is going to be chip supply problems which will drive the price up even further until 4-5 months after the product hits the shelves.

So from a technological standpoint, crossfire is probably just as good if not better than SLi, but from a business standpoint, SLi is a lot better.
 
Although it seems like ATI was caught off guard, this is all speculation. ATi did release the faster card and still today have the fastest card out there. The fact that nVidia has sold SLI cards that "work" automaticaly makes them the only manufacturer winning the gamers' dual card solution award.

We have yet to see "real" benchmarks with "real" motherboards and 1600 x 1200 res.

I would like those questions answered if possible. The response would be very interesting.
 
ivzk, sorry if I come off as some sort of fan Boy on a rant.
I know ATI did not sabatoge the 5x00 cards (they just sucked) I was just replying to the poster above that post. I am going to leave this thread now as it seems that I must be saying something wrong everytime.
Brent I know what you mean sorry for that post.
Was just being stupid I guess! :D
 
fallguy said:
Where did you see this? I too have a 2405FPW, and find it very annoying that I cant find any reviews done in 1920x1200.

Face it...Widescreen gamers are STILL a minority...like it or not :)

Terra....
 
{NG}Fidel said:
ivzk, sorry if I come off as some sort of fan Boy on a rant.
I know ATI did not sabatoge the 5x00 cards (they just sucked) I was just replying to the poster above that post. I am going to leave this thread now as it seems that I must be saying something wrong everytime.
Brent I know what you mean sorry for that post.
Was just being stupid I guess! :D


Don't leave. We lova yah. It's just that a few members here were trying to unsuccessfully prove the point you brought up for quite a long period of time, and the point frankly got a little stale. Nothing against you.
 
Terra said:
Face it...Widescreen gamers are STILL a minority...like it or not :)

Terra....
Don't bring this stupid crap into this discussion. :mad: Of course we know that. Does that mean that we (widescreen LCD owners) can't have widescreen benchmarks?! You're a pretty selfish person if that's the case...
 
I thought SLI had issues with widescreen setups, or is all that resolved now?
 
mohammedtaha said:
Yes you're a minority because you have more money than us and can run better resolutions :mad:
Where did I say that? Can you quote me on that? I'm waiting...

Just because some people with widescreen LCD's are asses doesn't mean everyone is.
 
1c3d0g said:
Don't bring this stupid crap into this discussion. :mad: Of course we know that. Does that mean that we (widescreen LCD owners) can't have widescreen benckmarks?! You're a pretty selfish person if that's the case...

I hope that's full of sarcasm.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
I know this wasn't directed at me, but I think that SLi did catch ATi off guard. Now I do believe that ATi was partially telling the truth when they said AFR has been built into all thier cards for quite some time. This is probably accurate. They've had the MAXX cards forever which always had two ATi GPU's on them. Its very likely they built that feature in, so they could have put multiple GPU's on a single card to increase performance if they had to in order to compete against Nvidia. Say if the X800's would have come out 40% slower than the 6800 series for example. It is possible that this is the case.

So ATI would have had a better shot if they had gone the Dual Core route instead. Why did they decide to do dual slot? :confused: So far we've only seen pics of 6800 dualcore cards (Not sure if they're released yet), but ATI would have had been able to do this from the beginning. But instead, simply rigged together a dualslot solution. Why would they do that? :confused:
 
Skrying said:
The same could be said about any Crossfire/SLI setup.

Yup :)
But I think more people are interested in SLI/Crossfire than Widescreen gaming...hence the lack of reviews...
Time and effort must match the target group...

Terra...
 
1c3d0g said:
Where did I say that? Can you quote me on that? I'm waiting...

Just because some people with widescreen LCD's are asses doesn't mean everyone is.

Do you know how to take a joke ?
 
Sly said:
So ATI would have had a better shot if they had gone the Dual Core route instead. Why did they decide to do dual slot? :confused: So far we've only seen pics of 6800 dualcore cards (Not sure if they're released yet), but ATI would have had been able to do this from the beginning. But instead, simply rigged together a dualslot solution. Why would they do that? :confused:

those MSI cards aren't Dual core, they just have 2 actual GPUs built onto the card.
 
jon_k said:
those MSI cards aren't Dual core, they just have 2 actual GPUs built onto the card.

Whoops! My bad :D I meant dual GPU's :p

EDIT: Still if ATI had released a dual GPU card, which they actually have more experience with, they would have come up with a less complex and cheaper single slot card that could have blown SLI out of the water.
 
I wonder if a dual core GPU is a viable solution for ATI and nVidia to release to the market. Imagine the gaming goodness with a dual card, dual core CF/SLI setup. Ooooweee!
 
Sly said:
Whoops! My bad :D I meant dual GPU's :p

EDIT: Still if ATI had released a dual GPU card, which they actually have more experience with, they would have come up with a less complex and cheaper single slot card that could have blown SLI out of the water.

Not necessairly. They would still need to put the crossfire chipset on the card. The crossfire cards are already pretty big, and adding another GPU and the card wouldn't fit in the case. I'm actually very suprised that MSI was able to make a card that was a decent size.
 
jon_k said:
Not necessairly. They would still need to put the crossfire chipset on the card. The crossfire cards are already pretty big, and adding another GPU and the card wouldn't fit in the case. I'm actually very suprised that MSI was able to make a card that was a decent size.

The corssfire chips didnt do anything to change the size of the zrossfire cards, they are the same size as regular X850s
 
Sly said:
So ATI would have had a better shot if they had gone the Dual Core route instead. Why did they decide to do dual slot? :confused: So far we've only seen pics of 6800 dualcore cards (Not sure if they're released yet), but ATI would have had been able to do this from the beginning. But instead, simply rigged together a dualslot solution. Why would they do that? :confused:

so all the current users out there of x800 and x850 cards can do crossfire also

also, nv hasn't put any cores on a single pcb, that was done by third party manufacturers

perhaps someone will figure out how to do it with crossfire as well, of course they'd need to buy compositing chips as well
 
Back
Top