Critique these components for a HD-video editing PC

Joined
Oct 2, 2003
Messages
2,173
I am going to do a build for a friend who will be using his PC for HD video editing. He already has most of the components in his existing PC, he just wants a better cpu, memory, motherboard, etc.

He wants to be able to edit High Definition video without it taking all day long. He also wants to play BF2 and other games at max setting and high AA/AF. This is what I am thinking of setting up for him:

Opteron 165 or 170 (possibly 3800 X2)
DFI nF4 SLI Infinity ATX AMD Motherboard - Retail (should I get him the SLI-DR one instead?)
2 x 7800 GT's (not sure on brand yet, probably will look for a deal. 2 GB enough?)
G.Skill Value 2GB (2 x 1GB) memory (feel free to comment/suggest other brands)

I am fairly knowledgible when it comes to hardware and building PC's, but I haven't built a PC specifically for HD video editing before. Would it be a good idea to get a raptor 10k drive, or would this be a waste of money?

I may set up a mild overclock for him (since the opterons overclock very well), but nothing serious. He isn't a hardware enthusiast like I am, so he doesn't need a board that will have tons of BIOS options, etc

I just don't want to end up building a system that isn't up to par for HD video editing, which is rather intensive from what I understand.

Thanks.
 
For video editing, more ram is always better. More than 2 gigs prolley won't help any for gaming, but when dealing with large video files like HD, more ram would definately help.

Make sure to get a really high quality PSU, with lots of room for expansion. Video eats up alot of hard drive space.

What is the plan for Hard drives? One really fast drive (or possibly a raid0 array) for what he is currently working on, and one very large raid 1 or raid 5 array would be best for both speed and data safety..

A good dvd burner, or possibly two (since you have dual core) is always nice.
 
go with kingston or crucial value ram, I trust those names and those rma policies and as previously stated more ram, the sli may be overkill why not spend that extra cash on maxing out system ram as when this machine is still kicking ass in a long time it will be because it has a shit load of ram. Thats the difference maker to me.I could be and have been called a moron however.
and no offense to DFI but if you aren't gonna push the OC then why get an OC board?
 
This is one of the very few areas where a raid 0 array will really pay off. If he is editing uncompressed HD the sustained transfer rates will need to be 200MB/s or more and a raptor is not going to cut it. That kind of disk speed is not cheap. I'd find out if that is the case. Define the required sustained transfer rate he will need and plan the disk sub-system from there.

Also if he will be using a multithreaded encoder I would not hesitate to go for a dually. The more cores chomping away at the task the better. 2GB of ram is a good starting point and you cant go wrong with the 7800's.

A budget would be helpful too :)
 
dirtydr said:
This is one of the very few areas where a raid 0 array will really pay off. If he is editing uncompressed HD the sustained transfer rates will need to be 200MB/s or more and a raptor is not going to cut it. That kind of disk speed is not cheap. I'd find out if that is the case. Define the required sustained transfer rate he will need and plan the disk sub-system from there.

Also if he will be using a multithreaded encoder I would not hesitate to go for a dually. The more cores chomping away at the task the better. 2GB of ram is a good starting point and you cant go wrong with the 7800's.

A budget would be helpful too :)

He told me his absolute limit was 3k, but he wants to keep it as low as possible too. If need be, I can get the DFI board but forego the 2nd video card and suggest the single 7800 GT for the time being.

Would it be a better idea to spend the exta cash from the other 7800 GT on dual raptor drives (raid 0) and perhaps another GB of ram (for a total of 3)? He doesn't need a fault tolerant system like raid 5.

Come to think of it, dual channel isn't possible with 3 GB of ram, is it (or is it possible with rev. E and higher chips)? Anyway, if this is the case, should I get 4 GB of ram or 2 x 1gb sticks and 2x 512 mb sticks? I think he has a couple 512MB sticks as it is, so I could always use those assumin compatability.

TheTMan, thanks for the comment for a quality PSU. I completely forgot that he will need a really good one if we go the SLI route. He has a 600W one now that he bought, but I don't know the specs. He didn't know about ratings on the 12V lines and such when he bought it. I'll check out how many amps are on each rail when I look at his current system.

For ram, what about corsair value select (1 gb sticks)?
 
Ok, we have pretty much decided on the components. He wanted SLI, and since 7800 GT's are only around 320, that was a plus.

Now, my only worry is the PSU. He currently has a Rosewill 550W PSU with 35A on the 12V rail. No dual rails. I don't know the model number...I forgot to write that down, unfortunately.

Anyway, he will be powering quite a bit of stuff:

Opteron 165
2 raptors in raid 0
Up to 5 other HD's and 2 optical (can cut the other HD's down to 3)
2 7800 GT's in SLI
The rest of the system.

Do you guys think his current PSU will be enough, or should I tell him to get new one?
 
I don't know what kind of editing software he will be using on this computer but I looked up a program called VT[4] by Newtek.

Here is a link to the system requirements:

http://www.newtek.com/vt/requirements.php


Here is a portion of text specifically talking about hard drive requirements:


"NewTek does not recommend use of IDE video drives. This includes the new SATA (serial ATA hard drives). Hard drives used for video storage and retrieval should be striped in Windows. Hardware RAID cards push data in burst speeds which are not appropriate for video editing. The sustained speed attained by Ultra 160 and 320 SCSI set up in standard Windows stripe-sets is what is needed for dependable video recording and playback."


I don't know if this would apply to your situation or not but just thought I would post the info.

Good luck with your build!!
 
reddhaus said:
I don't know what kind of editing software he will be using on this computer but I looked up a program called VT[4] by Newtek.

Here is a link to the system requirements:

http://www.newtek.com/vt/requirements.php


Here is a portion of text specifically talking about hard drive requirements:


"NewTek does not recommend use of IDE video drives. This includes the new SATA (serial ATA hard drives). Hard drives used for video storage and retrieval should be striped in Windows. Hardware RAID cards push data in burst speeds which are not appropriate for video editing. The sustained speed attained by Ultra 160 and 320 SCSI set up in standard Windows stripe-sets is what is needed for dependable video recording and playback."


I don't know if this would apply to your situation or not but just thought I would post the info.

Good luck with your build!!

Nah, he uses premiere pro, adobe products, and will possibly use avid and degas in the future. Unfortunately I personally know nothing of these applications, but I would think that dual SATA 150 raptors in raid 0 would be sufficient.
 
Here's my 2 cents on your setup.

For video editing, you want to spend your money on the CPU and hard drives. You want a CPU with a large cache, so I would agree with the Opteron CPU, dual version preferably as video editing software is normally multi-threaded. Additionally, 2 gigs of RAM would be best, and good RAM at that. I like Corsair myself. Spend a few extra dollars and get dual-channel fast RAM.

Next, the hard drive. Quick access speed is not important (like the WD Raptor), moving large amounts of data is. I would recommend something like 4 WD4000YR drives ($225 each) in a RAID 5 (I'm not a fan of unprotected RAID 0). This setup will give you really good throughput plus the added protection in case a drive fails. Yes, RAID on a motherboard works fine, but if you can afford it, get yourself something like a good 4 or 8 channel RAID card. I like 3ware (which is now part of AMCC). Their new 9550SX-8LP card for roughly $470 will give you fantastic read/write speed and backup in case of drive failure. Your total drive space will be 1.2TB.

For the primary O/S drive, get a drive with 16 MB of cache or the WD 74 gig Raptor. Depending on your tolerance for drive failures, you may want to get a second drive of the same type and RAID 1 them together using the motherboard's RAID ability.

Also, depending on the type of video you are working with, you'll want to consider a monitor that is either fast in terms of pixel response, or one that does a better job of accurately displaying colors. Since your friend playing games, then faster pixel response, but again, it depends on how accurate the colors need to be for his video editing.

You'll of course want a DVD burner. Good power supply - I like Enermax.

Now, lastly, the graphics card. Yout don't need fastest graphics card out there (by today's standards) for video editing. Since your friend wants to play games, then have at it.

So dual CPU and RAID-5 hard drives. I trust this helps.
 
Thanks for the reply.

Unfortunately, he doesn't want to spend a ton of money on new harddrives for a good SATA controller card. Even though they are IDE, he already has a few large drives...2 300 gb, 1 200, 1 120, and 1 80 IIRC. So far we plan on using his IDE PCI card.

Our original idea was to keep these drives intact and buy the raptors and put them in raid 0. On the raptors the OS will be loaded, along with the programs that need fast loads times (i.e. BF2). In addition, we plan on using the raptors to edit video directly. After the editing is done, he will copy this data to one of the 7200 RPM storage drives. Will this work decently?

Would it help to get IDE->SATA convertors for his current drives and run them as SATA using the controller on the motherboard?

Another reason we want the raptor raid 0 array is he wants his games to load quickly and his system to boot quickly (yeah, raid 0 is a bit overkill for this, but I DID see there are significant benefits when it comes to encoding and editing via benchmarks on anandtech). I understand that there are risks with the system being unprotected, but I let him know and he said he is willing to risk it. He will simply make backups often using his other storage.
 
For video editing I'd forgo the SLI GT's and focus more on processor power and ram.

FYI for ram theres NOTHING wrong with G.Skill
There are threads upon threads of praise for G.Skill over on XS. There is some G.Skill DDR400 ram running over 300Mhz for example the stuff in my opteron 165.
They just don't have the name recognition yet as some of the higher priced brands.
 
DarkenReaper57 said:
He told me his absolute limit was 3k, but he wants to keep it as low as possible too. If need be, I can get the DFI board but forego the 2nd video card and suggest the single 7800 GT for the time being.

Would it be a better idea to spend the exta cash from the other 7800 GT on dual raptor drives (raid 0) and perhaps another GB of ram (for a total of 3)? He doesn't need a fault tolerant system like raid 5.

Come to think of it, dual channel isn't possible with 3 GB of ram, is it (or is it possible with rev. E and higher chips)? Anyway, if this is the case, should I get 4 GB of ram or 2 x 1gb sticks and 2x 512 mb sticks? I think he has a couple 512MB sticks as it is, so I could always use those assumin compatability.

TheTMan, thanks for the comment for a quality PSU. I completely forgot that he will need a really good one if we go the SLI route. He has a 600W one now that he bought, but I don't know the specs. He didn't know about ratings on the 12V lines and such when he bought it. I'll check out how many amps are on each rail when I look at his current system.

For ram, what about corsair value select (1 gb sticks)?

Forget G.Skill value or Corsair Value.
Spend the couple extra bux and get the G.Skill Extreme Series.
 
Back
Top