Critique my prospective build

SethKinast

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 8, 2007
Messages
167
With the Intel price cuts almost here it's just about time for me to pull the trigger and finish up buying the rest of the parts I need. I've been using AMD stuff forever, so I'm not exactly up to snuff on the Intel scene. However, I've done lots and lots of research and have hopefully put together what I think will be a great system.

Not to mention, my current computer is an Athlon XP 2000+ and an MSI Geforce4 Ti4400 so pretty much anything will probably seem amazing :D

I would really appreciate feedback on the parts I'm looking to purchase so that I can be saved from any potential mistakes. I would be looking to overclock moderately, not more than 400FSB or so I think. While not bleeding-edge, I wanted to pick parts that will last a long time without becoming horribly outdated, as I don't upgrade very often.

Parts I already have
Case: Antec p180
My thoughts: Seems like a very popular case, and I love the build quality of the one I ordered. I have the room for it and don't need to move it often, so I don't mind the heft.
PSU: Corsair 620-HX
My thoughts: Yes, this is definitely overkill for the amount of power I'll be drawing without running SLI. However, I only paid about $15 more for it than the 520 model as I got a good deal, and I could definitely see going SLI in the future.
RAM: Buffalo Firestix DDR2-1000 2x1GB
My thoughts: Micron D9, but are they crazy overkill if I don't want an obscenely high overclock? I got them for the nice $200 deal a couple months ago so I'm not too put out if I'll never use their full potential.
Sound: Audigy2 ZS Platinum
My thoughts: From my old rig. Mmm front panel.
Cooling: Scythe Ninja Plus B (I also grabbed some Yate Loons and a Sunbeam rheobus)
My thoughts: SPCR loved pairing this thing with the p180 because of the positioning of the top and back exhaust vents. Sounds good to me.

Planned parts to buy:
Motherboard: eVGA 680i (A1 revision)
My thoughts: Again, some overkill for what I want. But I love the dual gigabit and the support for 1333 FSB (cheap 3Q quad-cores, yay), and the lifetime warranty is a HUGE plus for something I don't want to have to worry about replacing for a really long time. And it looks so pretty :p
Processor: Core 2 Duo e6420
My thoughts: No reason to go e6600 when this one has the full 4MB cache too.
Video card: eVGA 8800GTS 640MB
My thoughts: I still don't know if this is the right choice. I want to avoid having to upgrade to play new games anytime soon, and I have a 20" widescreen that I may soon swap out for a 24". So if I want to run at 1680x1050 with lots of eye candy, I need the 640 MB instead of the 320 MB version, right? If not, 320MB is $110+ cheaper and I'd love to stick with it. I picked eVGA for both mainboard and video card since I figure you can't go wrong matching the manufacturer, and I like eVGA.
HD: Seagate 7200.10 500GB
My thoughts: Seagate or WD is all I buy. No Raptor needed though.

Thanks for any thoughts :)
 
Looks like a very quality build to me. You may want to hold off on a video card purchase for a few more days until the R600 has been released. This should drop prices of the 8800 series quite a bit, and you may even want to go with XT version of the card.
 
You will not regret the 640MB GTS. If your max resolution is 1680x1050, there is no reason to go higher. I have the EVGA 8800 640 GTS and it handles two 20.1" benq widescreen lcds without a problem. I've checked fear, oblivion, command and conquer 3, HL2, CS:S, etc. Everything has been handled at the resolution 3360x1050. As for the heat of the card, you'll want to manually set the fan to run a bit higher (by default, it is set to 50%). I run the fan at 85%, and the noise is subtle.

edit - one question that might help everyone viewing your post, what OS are you planning to install on it? I heard Vista runs a lot better with 4gbs of RAM instead of the normal 2gbs.
 
There's a copy of Vista Business sitting here looking at me. I'll be dual-booting with Ubuntu.

I doubt I'll be going to 64-bit anytime soon so I didn't want to put in 4GB yet, but prices keep falling so who knows?
 
There's a copy of Vista Business sitting here looking at me. I'll be dual-booting with Ubuntu.

I doubt I'll be going to 64-bit anytime soon so I didn't want to put in 4GB yet, but prices keep falling so who knows?

Solid system you outlined. A possible alternative would be to go with the e4300+ Gigabyte DS3 + 320MB 8800GTS to save a bit of money.

As for the operating system you probably already know that gaming isn't as great on Vista but you'll get a much nicer looking OS. Anyhow have fun with your build! :cool:
 
Solid system you outlined. A possible alternative would be to go with the e4300+ Gigabyte DS3 + 320MB 8800GTS to save a bit of money.

As for the operating system you probably already know that gaming isn't as great on Vista but you'll get a much nicer looking OS. Anyhow have fun with your build! :cool:

If he wants DX10 he needs Windows Vista.

As to the motherboard

DS3 or a DFI Infinity 975 would be fine probably and I am going with a E4300 myself for 110$ and am going to put on a tuniq tower or Thermalright Ultra 120 and o/c it to 3.2+ghz. Then on the Third quarter buy yourself a Core 2 Quad. :cool: 640mb seems overkill to me though.
 
Yes, I'll definitely be going Vista and because I'd prefer not to upgrade the video card anytime soon I'd like to get a DX10 card now.

This is the sort of info I'm interested in. I looked at the DS3 but I think I would prefer to use an nVidia chipset because there is no possibility I will use an ATI card (bad Linux support). If I use a 650i or 680i I can always do SLI later. I like the lifetime warranty of eVGA's 680i and also would find the dual lan useful.

Do you have any info on whether the 8800GTS 320 or even the 8600GTS can drive 1680x1050 at acceptable levels? I can only find benches that run 1600x1200 and 1280x1024.

I guess I hadn't considered going all the way down to E4300. Does the 2MB of cache really not make that big of a difference? How likely is it that I would get an E4300 that can go all the way past 3 GHz?

Thanks for the useful replies so far :)
 
if you're planning on going with a 24" monitor in the future, definitely go with the 640mb 8800gts. as for the e4300, you'll likely get to 3.0ghz assuming your mobo and ram are up to it, anything past that means you got a pretty decent chip. as for the 2mb vs. 4mb cache issue, it really depends on the apps you use.
 
The extra 2MB cache doesnt help much right now, but it may in future games/apps. The 640MB GTS is apparently only needed if you like the high detail settings at high resolutions. So if you like AA/AF, then get the 640MB. 1680x1050 is a bit less than 1600x1200 :p so use the 16x12 bench numbers ;) .

You're building a system with a TON of potential, but don't plan on reaching all of it... just most of it... and you're OK with the price... so go for it. If you want to save money, you obviously could, since you already know you won't be using the system to its full potential. SLI would depend on how soon you see yourself getting that 24", lol. One thing I usually suggest is getting more than one HDD. So, in case one fails and needs to be RMA'd, you have a backup drive to use in the meantime.
 
I would go with the E4300 I am going to be buying one now myself. 2mb is find for what you need next year get the Quad 2 Core or so since it will be better plus your saving that money now.
 
Do you have any info on whether the 8800GTS 320 or even the 8600GTS can drive 1680x1050 at acceptable levels? I can only find benches that run 1600x1200 and 1280x1024.

The general consensus is that the 320 8800GTS is good up to 1600x1200/1680x1050. Anything higher and the consensus is to get the 640 variant.

Sources:
http://www.guru3d.com/article/Videocards/416/20/
http://www.pcper.com/article.php?aid=364&type=expert&pid=1

I guess I hadn't considered going all the way down to E4300. Does the 2MB of cache really not make that big of a difference? How likely is it that I would get an E4300 that can go all the way past 3 GHz?

Thanks for the useful replies so far :)

Very high chance unless you get a dud. Certain applications can take advantage of the extra cache on the E6600 but the difference isn't huge. I would go with the E4300 unless you need virtualization.

Source:
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1138241
 
Back
Top