Creative Tactic 3D Omega vs Turtle Beach PX5

VulcaN

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 22, 2001
Messages
1,917
Has anyone tried the new Tactic 3D Omega's from Creative?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16826158141

51WA6od9GDL.jpg


I've been using the PX5 (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16879459005&Tpk=px5) for a while now and am wondering if they are worth the switch.

The main thing they finally seem to have done right is transmit voice and receive audio over the same wireless device. With the PX5 you have to have a bluetooth adapter for your PC (the toshiba bluetooth stack I have installed for my cirago adapter has 5+ services, a tray icon and all kinds of crap that it needs to function) that is really finicky (people on TS / vent / mumble say i sound quiet even at max volume / boost, and that I crackle).

---But oh boy did they go wrong in other areas. With the PX5 you can use AA batteries. I use rechargeable eneloops and have to change them out every 1-2 days. With the creative the battery is wired / sealed in place, so you get ~8 hours of time then have to reconnect the charging cable. We all forget to put things back on their charging stations now and then, AA batteries were the best route or if they needed slimmer than AA's at least include a second battery for hot swapping. One reason for wireless headphones is when you're not sitting near the PC, such as playing on a TV, so sitting near the USB port to charge them isnt always an option.

---Second, they connect to the PC using .... USB? Thats the last thing I want, something taking up processing power and possibly sounding worse. The PX5 lets you use toslink / spdif optical.

---Last they seem to require you to install a software package thats possibly always running. At least with the PX5 you just see the device in device / sound manager and thats it, no drivers, no software just good clean sound.

So we get wireless audio and voice over the same device, but we lose any decent input method such as spdif or even analogue out. We are forced to use usb and lose the option to hot swap in a pair of batteries. At least it has less buttons and gimmicky features unlike the PX5 which is riddled with them (to target the younger XBOX crowd I assume).

It sounds like a lose situation for a $200 headset, but if the quality of the sound is better this might be worth it. I wonder how many valuable processor threads USB audio steals?
 
Last edited:
There's no reason USB audio should be processor intensive. It's a fairly low bandwidth task, and USB implementations on modern hardware are generally much more efficient than they used to be. Not to mention, processors themselves are much more powerful. I wouldn't write off an audio interface just because it uses USB.

Also, USB will not affect the quality of the audio. The data that reaches the DAC will be the same over USB, optical or coax, except USB offers error detection/correction that isn't available to S/PDIF.
 
There's no reason USB audio should be processor intensive.

I'd read an article on this.

It sounds like a lose situation for a $200 headset

A $200 headset sounds like a lose situation to me. I won't even start on how I feel about Creative.

At least with the PX5 you just see the device in device / sound manager and thats it, no drivers, no software just good clean sound.

werdcat.jpg
 
Another thing I just thought of, but the PX5 has dolby digital bit streaming, I cant find anything on creatives site about bitstreaming. This can be very annoying because if you have your computer hooked up to a receiver as well, every time you go to play a movie on it you will have to turn bitstreaming on and then turn it back off when you want to use the headphones.
 
Back
Top