Creative Pays Up In Class Action Suit

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If you bought a MP3 player made by Creative between 2001 and 2008, you could be eligible for part of this class-action settlement.

The settlement -- not the first of its kind -- will force Creative to "make certain disclosures regarding the storage capacity of its hard disc drive MP3 players" and give a 50% discount on a new 1GB player or 20% off any item purchased at Creative's online store. Applications are due by August 7, 2008, so start digging up those serial numbers.
 
will force Creative to "make certain disclosures regarding the storage capacity of its hard disc drive MP3 players" and give a 50% discount on a new 1GB player or 20% off any item purchased at Creative's online store

Lol, Creative is hardly paying up as punishment, in fact they will probably end up profiting from the people who use the 20% discount on there next purchase. What a great punishment indeed.
 
Hmmm, what i meant was profiting from people using the 20% off who wouldnt have normally looked at the creative store. (couldnt edit)
 
Hmmm...I own 2 creative MP3 players that qualify. Too bad I'm not about to spend MORE money just to "win" this lawsuit...
 
I've bought and sold a coupel of Creative players during this time period. Too bad I have no proof of purchase or serial numbers anymore.
 
I still use my Nomad Jukebox Zen (it's great for bringing my audio library to work), but doubt I'd like anything more. Besides, I can drop a 60GB laptop drive into it when I run out of space this year -- can't do that with most other MP3 players.
 
What is with these lame lawsuits that gives you credit to buy something (marked up nontheless) at a discount from the company who screwed you over in the first place?
 
Um let me see if I understand this: People who bought previous players are SOL unless they buy a new one.. oh they get a discount, but still they have to buy another one instead of trading it in.

So that means Creative keeps the profit from past sales and gain more from future sales, and with the price of storage space these days, they can easily not sell at a loss, and profit a boatload more money.

That's not including marking up prices so they wouldn't lose as much money when "discounting" their products.
 
meh, only the scumbag lawyers get a "settlement".

love my zen vision M 30GB, but i have little use or desire for a 1GB player or 20% off.
 
Is this the 1000 vs. 1024 crap again?

Winnah!
1024 cubed is 1,073,741,824
1000 cubed is 1,000,000,000
That's a 7% difference. Strange how the lawsuit claims a 7% shortcoming.
I told my IT guy here that we should sue HP for exactly the same thing. My HDD was configured on their site as 160GB, and I only have roughly 149GB.
 
Winnah!
1024 cubed is 1,073,741,824
1000 cubed is 1,000,000,000
That's a 7% difference. Strange how the lawsuit claims a 7% shortcoming.
I told my IT guy here that we should sue HP for exactly the same thing. My HDD was configured on their site as 160GB, and I only have roughly 149GB.

Well you do have that space. You just have to reclaim it after creating a recovery DVD.
 
I still use my Nomad Jukebox Zen (it's great for bringing my audio library to work), but doubt I'd like anything more. Besides, I can drop a 60GB laptop drive into it when I run out of space this year -- can't do that with most other MP3 players.

I have a 30g Vision M, is there an easy way to do the same thing?

Don't know what I might get with the 20% off, even though I finally have a lawsuit that I could join
 
Is this the 1000 vs. 1024 crap again?

Ding ding ding ding.....

Reminds me way back in the usenet days when some UseNet KOTM went on and on about this. Of course for them it was some sort of bizarre MSFT conspiracy. Not sure which KOTM it was, maybe "Redmond Rose."
 
That's a settlement? a 20% or 50% discount, meaning you're supposed to give Creative MORE of your money after they already burned you? Brilliant, simply brilliant. Creative has a hell of a team of lawyers, that's all I can say.

If this were really a settlement, Creative would be sending out checks, not offering a "discount" - you can get most of their stuff cheaper anywhere on the net or even B&M stores without their so-called settlement. 50% off a 1gb player. Really ... you know they've probably been looking for ways to unload those. Pffft
 
I have a 30g Vision M, is there an easy way to do the same thing?

Based on a little cursory glancing around the net, it appears very possible to replace the drive with something larger. It appears to use a standard IDE drive, just make sure the dimensions are right when you're buying. This fella did it with his 'W' (http://onemansblog.com/2007/07/20/tutorial-how-to-upgrade-the-creative-zen-vision-w-hard-drive/), and it's even more simple on my Zen.

http://www.rapidrepair.com/ looks to be a great place to ask about dimensions, disk replacement and cost.
 
Back
Top