CPU for WHS, i3 or/vs i5

Asposium

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 13, 2009
Messages
351
I'm building a new server, but hopefully this thread might of wider use

What socket1156 CPU for a WHS?

i3 or i5

Is there any reason to spend the extra money on an i5?

Afterall, an i3 seems plenty fast enough for WHS duties; so is the i5's extended instruction set of benefit?
 
What are you doing with your server that requires something that powerful? Both i3 and i5 processors consume too much power for basic server needs.
 
the mobo i want is socket1156
i want something that will last a couple of years, and certainly be suitable for WHS version 2 when it eventually arrives

surely the CPU will throttle back when not under load?

when i built my first WHS i used an atom CPU thinking it would be lower power than a desktop CPU (then socket775)
i then started the Watts/TB thread
from that thread it seemed even people with what could be considered a high-spec CPU were getting a very good Watts/TB. so, under low load the CPUs were throttling back

as i understand thermal design power (TDP) is the maximum thermal load, though, that does not mean the CPU will dissipate that power
 
There is no need to upgrade the CPU unless you plan to run something on the server in addition to serving files. If you are going to be doing transcodes, running a fair sized mail server, or something else then yes, the i5 might help, but just as a file/media server go with the less expensive, less power-hungry choices. Even under heavy loads WHS does not need faster CPU - and the effectiv speed limits imposed by the LAN and the disk IO mean it probably never will, even with Vail.
 
I'm building a side project to the i7 920 based WHS (well it's really 2008 R2 with WHS in a VM). Will be using the Intel H55 mATX mobo + an i3 530. Intel onboard lan + 2x PCIe x1 for Intel NICs + 1x PCIe x16 for a raid card.

WHS runs fine on ATOM based machines, so the i3 will be plenty. You can probably even run a virtual box on it and do a bit of encoding if you wanted.
 
an i3 will last you a while, and will be WHS v2 ready.
 
You can use 5 year+ old hardware and that will run WHS just fine. But a more economic way to pursue this is to evaluate how much power you need from your WHS and not to overbuild it. Not only will you save significantly more in power costs, but in 5 years from now they will probably have something faster and cheaper than a core i3/i5 and at a much lower price.
 
i3 is not even necessary, and for 'just' WHS is overkill. However if you are dead set on an i3/ i5 build I would suggest an i3.
 
Back
Top