CPU Bottlenecks and Vid Car Decision

oozish

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 27, 2003
Messages
1,465
What's the best card without going for more than I can use for a P4 3.0 ghz cpu? In other words, am I just spinning my wheels getting the XT since I might not be able to push past the limits of my 3.0ghz CPU limitations and realize the card's performance potential.

Maybe I'd be better off getting a mid range card (assuming price is no object but I want to make a sound investment) when limited to a cpu. From what I've read, the 3.0ghz is the lowest you'd want to go to even start to consider the hi end cards.

Any facts or advice concerning cpu limitations and how they will work with the card would be appreciated. And yes, I have read the article on this at Firing Squad. :)
 
A p4 3.0 would be the slowest processor (intel anyways) I'd use with an XT. While there is still a CPU bottleneck, the combination still makes for a kickass system, I don't think anyone can argue against that.

If you're strapped for cash, going down to a Pro model might not be a terrible idea. Or maybe going the AMD route (A64 3000+ or higher). But I definately wouldn't go any lower than those two processors with an X800 XT.
 
intercollector said:
A p4 3.0 would be the slowest processor (intel anyways) I'd use with an XT. While there is still a CPU bottleneck, the combination still makes for a kickass system, I don't think anyone can argue against that.

If you're strapped for cash, going down to a Pro model might not be a terrible idea. Or maybe going the AMD route (A64 3000+ or higher). But I definately wouldn't go any lower than those two processors with an X800 XT.

Thanks....I think overkill at this point might be a good idea, then when prices on the EE P4's drop with the new shift this summer to PCI Express, I can get the fastest processor my mb will allow and maybe catch up to the card. I'm still thinking the fastest card, since it's only going to be about 100 buck difference anyway and that would be a shame.

I'm still interested in some hard facts on CPU SCALING anyone got any info?
 
oozish said:
Thanks....I think overkill at this point might be a good idea, then when prices on the EE P4's drop with the new shift this summer to PCI Express, I can get the fastest processor my mb will allow and maybe catch up to the card. I'm still thinking the fastest card, since it's only going to be about 100 buck difference anyway and that would be a shame.

I'm still interested in some hard facts on CPU SCALING anyone got any info?


Hard facts are sort of tough to get for that sort of thing. It's odd, but CPU scaling is easier to predict with 1 processor and multiple video cards, than it is to put multiple CPU's with 1 video card. This is because the cards are fairly predictable in scaling, whereas processors are not. So this sort of method will give you a better idea of what future processors might be able to do. From what I've read, most reviews come to an agreement that there is at least a little bit of CPU bottleneck with the XT for certain games. It really comes down to the certain game though. It's all about the ratio of the difficulting in physics engines and somewhat the AI (both done by the processor) compared to the difficulty in graphics (video card).
 
OC that Pentium 4 3.0C to 3.4GHz or so to take better advantage of your X800XT or an X800Pro. I've got a X800Pro and a Pentium 4 3.0C OC'ed. But even at stock speeds its a kickass combination.
 
intercollector said:
Hard facts are sort of tough to get for that sort of thing. It's odd, but CPU scaling is easier to predict with 1 processor and multiple video cards, than it is to put multiple CPU's with 1 video card. This is because the cards are fairly predictable in scaling, whereas processors are not. So this sort of method will give you a better idea of what future processors might be able to do. From what I've read, most reviews come to an agreement that there is at least a little bit of CPU bottleneck with the XT for certain games. It really comes down to the certain game though. It's all about the ratio of the difficulting in physics engines and somewhat the AI (both done by the processor) compared to the difficulty in graphics (video card).


Thanks, that's an intelligent and well thought out answer. Guess I'll have to look at each game I want to play individually, which won't be hard there are only TWO. hehe.
 
CPU's come out more often than video cards really. So I say even if your somewhat CPU limited you should get a higher end video card anyway. Gives you more room to grow.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
CPU's come out more often than video cards really. So I say even if your somewhat CPU limited you should get a higher end video card anyway. Gives you more room to grow.


You realize I'm overclocking my 2.4C already? Just making sure. ;) Anyway, yes, I agree with you. Despite what everyone's saying that cards come out every 6 months and blah blah blah....I hold my cards for about 2 years, barring some game and card combo that I simply must have (case in point, upcoming DOOM3 and HL). i currently have a Ti4400 and that was a good choice at the time since I've overclocked it since I bought it and it performs decent to great in any games I've played over the last couple years. Thing is, it doesn't hack it anymore with the advent of Thief3 and Far Cry, obviously.

So I'll be buying the most future proof card in a few months, after everything is out (that is, at the stores, where i can pick one up) and these games are out....whichever comes first. I think alot of people are like me and waiting it out like this, however, I envy your card and I know you'll be set for a few years as well already if you want to hold onto that x800.

:D
 
You should be fine with at 3.0...

I wouldnt see any real reason to upgrade your proc just yet, since you are just about running as fast as everyone else.
 
I didn't really read what CPU you had. But the point is if your over 3GHz your doing fine. Get the fastest card you can afford and keep it as long as you can.

I really think that for future proofing your going to need to get the 6800Ultra over the X800Pro/XT/XT-PE. The ATi offerings are really giving no new technology. They are just speed increases. Hardly what I would call future proof. I got one because at the rate I upgrade future proofing doesn't mean anything to me. I just get the fastest thing at the time.

So with the 6800Ultra and its more advanced features, I think that its a card that will work for alot longer. The card may even be faster than an X800XT PE with Shader 3.0 running. Who knows. Nvidia's also good about getting speed upgrades out of thier drivers every few months.
 
There's almost *always* bottlenecks in PC system no matter what kind of PC we use. (be it CPU, graphic card, RAM, PCI/AGP bus...etc) Simply, where the bottleneck occurs within the system largely depends on games/engines, settings such as resolutions, visual quality settings (texture quality, AF, AA) etc.

As long as you have a fairly recent CPU (I would say 2.5 Ghz+ ), CPU bottlenecks to X800, and/or 6800 is not simple yes or no answer.
IMO, thread starter's P4 3.0 GHz is more than enough for X800XT PE and/or GeForce 6800Ultra.

Also, new DX9 (shader intensive) games will be much less CPU dependent, which means that anyone who is buying a 9800Pro now will suddenly find themselves with 30fps in all the new DX9 games in mid-late 2004. You only have to look at FarCry to see that far from being CPU limited.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
I didn't really read what CPU you had. But the point is if your over 3GHz your doing fine. Get the fastest card you can afford and keep it as long as you can.

I really think that for future proofing your going to need to get the 6800Ultra over the X800Pro/XT/XT-PE. The ATi offerings are really giving no new technology. They are just speed increases. Hardly what I would call future proof. I got one because at the rate I upgrade future proofing doesn't mean anything to me. I just get the fastest thing at the time.

So with the 6800Ultra and its more advanced features, I think that its a card that will work for alot longer. The card may even be faster than an X800XT PE with Shader 3.0 running. Who knows. Nvidia's also good about getting speed upgrades out of thier drivers every few months.

I usually get 1 DOWN from the fastest, if I can overclock it and get it close to the fastest and it otherwise supports the fastest's features. That's why i'm waiting to see what becomes of the GT, potentially (if it overclocks easily) close to the ULtra performance.

That said, I really haven't made up my mind about the ps3.0 issue and whether that ability will translate into perormance over the next 2 years. I agree basically with you, but I'm not beyond buying a x800XT for the right price and if a game I wanted to play was out and the geforces weren't.

My decision will be driven by game and card availability, basically. Maybe the games won't come out till the cards are readily available, in which case that'd be best for me to keep me from making a mistake. It would be an expensive mistake.

Sure both cards are about as fast blah blah blah. But I want the best value and the best card anyway, for peace of minds' sake. If I could get a card that had the same lifespan as my Ti4400, I'd be happy. ;)
 
Back
Top