Courts Won't Block Remote Storage DVR Systems

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Supreme Court has declined to hear arguments on whether a remote-storage DVR system violates copyright laws. That is good news for consumers, bad news for big studios and television networks.

For consumers, the action means that Cablevision and perhaps other cable system operators soon will be able to offer DVR service without need for a box in their homes. The remote storage unit exists on computer servers maintained by a cable provider.
 
"The Obama administration, which urged the court not to hear the case, said the ruling by the federal appeals court in New York in favor of Cablevision was correct."

Woot! Go consumer rights!
 
I don't know that I want the cable companies able to do this. I don't know how Cablevision is, but the cable company I know and hate in my area is Comcast, and I wouldn't trust them with this. How long until they won't give out anything but their 'remote-storage DVRs'? Think about it. Right now you pay $X amount for Y amount of storage one time. Once the cable companies have your data on their end instead you really think they'll sell it to you one time? No, they'll sell you your storage area time and time again, month after month. You'll end up spending WAY more than you would with a DVR in your home, but the cable companies will have realized that way before you and stopped offering the versions that stored data in your home. Not to mention if problems happen suddenly you have a whole wide area unable to record or watch TV. At least if the DVRs are in your home you probably have more than 1 and can just watch something on a different one.

You watch - this will end up becoming a way for the cable company to profit more, customers to pay more for more unreliable service and then to top it off it'll all be at the expense of the people actually producing the content as more and more people skip the commercials.
 
I don't know that I want the cable companies able to do this. I don't know how Cablevision is, but the cable company I know and hate in my area is Comcast, and I wouldn't trust them with this. How long until they won't give out anything but their 'remote-storage DVRs'? Think about it. Right now you pay $X amount for Y amount of storage one time. Once the cable companies have your data on their end instead you really think they'll sell it to you one time? No, they'll sell you your storage area time and time again, month after month. You'll end up spending WAY more than you would with a DVR in your home, but the cable companies will have realized that way before you and stopped offering the versions that stored data in your home. Not to mention if problems happen suddenly you have a whole wide area unable to record or watch TV. At least if the DVRs are in your home you probably have more than 1 and can just watch something on a different one.

You watch - this will end up becoming a way for the cable company to profit more, customers to pay more for more unreliable service and then to top it off it'll all be at the expense of the people actually producing the content as more and more people skip the commercials.

Your right, they were just heavily lobbying the SCOTUS to over turn the ruling that this was legal for show. :rolleyes:
 
I don't know that I want the cable companies able to do this. I don't know how Cablevision is, but the cable company I know and hate in my area is Comcast, and I wouldn't trust them with this. How long until they won't give out anything but their 'remote-storage DVRs'? Think about it. Right now you pay $X amount for Y amount of storage one time. Once the cable companies have your data on their end instead you really think they'll sell it to you one time? No, they'll sell you your storage area time and time again, month after month. You'll end up spending WAY more than you would with a DVR in your home, but the cable companies will have realized that way before you and stopped offering the versions that stored data in your home. Not to mention if problems happen suddenly you have a whole wide area unable to record or watch TV. At least if the DVRs are in your home you probably have more than 1 and can just watch something on a different one.

You watch - this will end up becoming a way for the cable company to profit more, customers to pay more for more unreliable service and then to top it off it'll all be at the expense of the people actually producing the content as more and more people skip the commercials.

....You know you do pay monthly and one time for the current dvr boxes in homes right?
 
Right now:
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and pay us 1 time $200 for the 500GB model.
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and pay us 1 time $300 for the 750GB model.
etc.

If the cable company controls the storage:
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service and get 100GB free!
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service and pay us every month forever $20 for 200GB.
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and oh, either downgrade and delete some of your shows or pay our new higher price of $30 a month for the same storage size...<insert some BS about rising costs here>

Once the cable companies realize the same thing do you REALLY expect them to continue to offer the storage at your home? No, they're only going to offer these remote storage DVRs because they know they can get away with charging you for the storage time and time again.
 
You watch - this will end up becoming a way for the cable company to profit more, customers to pay more for more unreliable service and then to top it off it'll all be at the expense of the people actually producing the content as more and more people skip the commercials.
If it's that big a problem for you, then buy a Tivo. You can buy a Tivo HD with a 160GB hard drive for under $300 if you shop around. You can then upgrade it with a 1TB internal and 1TB external drive for about $250. So you can have 2TB of storage which translates to 300 HD / 2800 SD for about $500. And it'll only cost you $12.95 for the Tivo service and another $5 for the multi-stream cable card.
 
im old school i got tivo lifetime for like 200 something its awesome but i dont use it anymore :( also fuck comcast COX is an awesome cable company
 
Remember the courts declined to hear arguments, they didn't make a ruling. Anytime down the road they could favour the companies.
 
Right now:
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and pay us 1 time $200 for the 500GB model.
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and pay us 1 time $300 for the 750GB model.
etc.

If the cable company controls the storage:
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service and get 100GB free!
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service and pay us every month forever $20 for 200GB.
Pay us $15 a month for the DVR service, and oh, either downgrade and delete some of your shows or pay our new higher price of $30 a month for the same storage size...<insert some BS about rising costs here>

Once the cable companies realize the same thing do you REALLY expect them to continue to offer the storage at your home? No, they're only going to offer these remote storage DVRs because they know they can get away with charging you for the storage time and time again.

You have made the assumption that some company offering to do this service is going to suddenly make it so you can't buy a DVR to put in your home. It doesn't do that. Furthermore, this ruling (or rather the lack to hear arguments against a former ruling of the lower courts) says it legal for me to start a DVR company and compete with the DVR that is in your home provided by the cable company. What part of this don't you get? This gives teh cable company competition, but somehow them having competition is going to let them jack up prices? Do you understand how free markets work?
 
Just build a HTPC if it's that big of a problem.
 
You have made the assumption that some company offering to do this service is going to suddenly make it so you can't buy a DVR to put in your home. It doesn't do that. Furthermore, this ruling (or rather the lack to hear arguments against a former ruling of the lower courts) says it legal for me to start a DVR company and compete with the DVR that is in your home provided by the cable company. What part of this don't you get? This gives teh cable company competition, but somehow them having competition is going to let them jack up prices? Do you understand how free markets work?

You sure you didn't read something wrong?

DIRECT from the linked article:
"The remote storage unit exists on computer servers maintained by a cable provider."

How exactly does that equate to more competition for the cable companies? If the cable provider now controls something they didn't previously control that is LESS competition. Based on your own talk of free markets less competition means higher prices. Do you not understand how free markets work?

Let's see, if the cable company stands to both control more of what you are allowed to do, AND they can make more money while doing it what makes you think they wouldn't stop offering the DVR boxes you put in your home and try to solely promote the remote storage versions where all your shows are on their equipment?
 
I think this is a huge idea. The biggest thing that most people are not realizing is theat a DVR records content from a cable provider. They only have so many shows on their scheduel to even record. How many thousands of copies of Lost or CSI are recoreded on DVRs across the US alone? Well they already have the episodes on their systems... all they really need to do is tage who wanted to save it and let them stream it whenever they want. They only need one copy. Think of the storage space they can save. Some systems are already running streaming TV so it really makes no difference. Litterally it could be a free service now.

Now there is one thing. What is to stop someone with the service just saying they want everything saved and the ability to watch whatever they want whenever they want. This is what cable TV needs to get too. The lineup of new episodes are just added to the list of currently avaliable shows and consumers stream what shows they want whenever they want. I would also love to see a pay by episode version that would let casual TV users pay less. I hate paying $60 a month for something I watch maybe 5 hours a week at most. That is basically like paying full Pay-per-view charges. I think charging $.50 for shows with ads and $1 for shows without ads (some stuff being free and sponsored) per hour.
 
I think this is a huge idea. The biggest thing that most people are not realizing is theat a DVR records content from a cable provider. They only have so many shows on their scheduel to even record. How many thousands of copies of Lost or CSI are recoreded on DVRs across the US alone? Well they already have the episodes on their systems... all they really need to do is tage who wanted to save it and let them stream it whenever they want. They only need one copy. Think of the storage space they can save. Some systems are already running streaming TV so it really makes no difference. Litterally it could be a free service now.

Now there is one thing. What is to stop someone with the service just saying they want everything saved and the ability to watch whatever they want whenever they want. This is what cable TV needs to get too. The lineup of new episodes are just added to the list of currently avaliable shows and consumers stream what shows they want whenever they want. I would also love to see a pay by episode version that would let casual TV users pay less. I hate paying $60 a month for something I watch maybe 5 hours a week at most. That is basically like paying full Pay-per-view charges. I think charging $.50 for shows with ads and $1 for shows without ads (some stuff being free and sponsored) per hour.

It could become a free service but it wont. It will become PayPerView all over again. Cable Co records all possible new shows for a month, lets the consumer watch them anytime-- for a price. Plus a monthly fee to be able to have this feature... Plus a monthly fee for a box capable of recieving this streaming video.
 
Cable companies see this as a win because they will no longer have to support individual hard drives in (company supplied) boxes out in the field. They can instead buy terrabytes of SATA/SAS drives to install in one location and stream to the consumers. If they're smart, they don't do it like current PPV, but develop a box capable of receiving a unicast stream to install in people's houses. (I know they have current technology for this, but something newer and more efficient). People would then be able to pause/rewind without affecting other users watching the same program.

There are some times where I can't watch current PPV because a lack of resources in my neighborhood. Moving 50,000 DVRs to the headend without upgrading the infrastructure isn't going to work. IP Multi/Unicast could fit the bill nicely if they build a system capable of sending/receiving the data.
Systems that already use IPTV have a real advantage over older RF based systems in this. Too bad Qwest just got out of that business.
 
Just buy a 100 dollars TV card and plug it into your machine... record what you want... watch it anywhere..simple and cheap :D

I went one step further and built a HDPC :D
 
Back
Top