Cornell University Develops Fake Review Detector

Sounds like most of the AMD Bulldozer "reviews" as of late.
 
Well if that is to be believed then most of the reviews I don't for hotels were fake as that's not to far then something I would have wrote for a very nice hotel.

What's I'm curious about is to do an evaluation like this you would need to review a large number of real and fake reviews and compare how they differ, but if you don't know for sure which reviews are fake in the first place how do you begin?
 
Looking at that example, anything I genuinely liked would be flagged a fake review. I guess that means all reviews are fake, unless the reviews say the product/service sucks. That is one great detector let me tell you.
 
My Girlfriend and I love Cornell New Yorks super awesome fake review detector! I was very impressed with how accurate and useful it sounds! We didn't get to try it out on our own website yet but it really looks great!

:rolleyes:
 
The way I like to do reviews is to list what I like about the place, then what I do not like. Listing both will set it apart, even if it's rated 5 stars, or highest score (although, quite frankly, I rarely give highest marks). So what these fake guys need to do is insert some reality into their reviews. Not everything has to be good for it to still be enjoyable, and fun.

Any review I see that does NOT include negative items, immediately signals one of two things for me. Fanboi or Fake. And either way, it gets ignored.

For example: I enjoy reading the HardOCP website. They have some great articles. However, don't get caught up in the forums because some of those guys there are really iffy... (lol, sorry, please don't take offense!)
 
IF source = gawker.
THEN flag_review = fake.

IF genre = FPS
AND publisher = Activision
AND score > 80
THEN flag_review = fake

There's a start.
 
I thought it was established fact and common knowledge that any time an exclamation point is used, outside of a shouty context, everything preceding it was bullshit.
 
I always loved game reviews on websites that sold the products (amazon, etc) that came out before the game did, and strangely had the same exact review elsewhere. Either there's way too many fanbois out there or those pay-per-review companies are really jumping the gun.
 
If any website used this software to remove fake reviews, fake reviewers would just work around it. So, it's worthless.

Another source of fake reviews, which this doesn't touch, are professional reviewers who benefit from the companies whose products they're reviewing. Like, who's going to say something bad about Apple and lose out on getting the next new Apple gadget for free, before others get it?
 
Aww, this was fake?
Certain people might consider paying well over four grand just a tad much for a pair of cables, but they just don't comprehend the pleasure to be found in spending extravagantly on fancy toys. There's a difference between the men and the boys! Unfortunately, when I attempted to connect the high-end stereo system at my opulent mansion to my 72V DBS orbiting zero-gravity research lab, these cables came up rather short. You'd think that a company charging sky-high prices and even labeling their products with the word "sky" would understand that high-flyers like me need LONG cables! I next tried installing this product in the flux capacitor on my lavishly-appointed Aston Martin DBS. No luck, but let me tell you, I feel better than James Bond when I'm time-traveling in that car! I'm now planning to use these cables for some much-needed Deep Brain Stimulation (2.5 meters ought to be sufficiently long for that). A friend told me that DBS stood for "Divorced, Bankrupt, and Screwed" or "Drunk, Blind, and Stupid," but I no longer associate with that Philistine. When you make the kind of money I do, you can buy the kind of friends who appreciate the finer things in life.

This too?
This is the most awesomest HDMI cable ever invented by man. Rumor has it is was in fact found on the UFO crash in Roswell and only recently has modern science been able to duplicate it and produce it for consumers. This is the same cable President Obama uses to connect the white house televisions to their cable boxes some 60 feet away. You can never go wrong with long grain rice (LGR) OR long grain copper (LGC). ANYTHING long grain is better than without long grain. My Long Grain Jeep (LGJ) easily outperforms regular Jeeps, for example.

This is also a great deal, it is currently listing at $1,528.75, a steal! Amazon reports the regular list price is $1,529.00- You save 25 cents on each order! 25!!!

:(
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I enjoy reading Hardocp because if the thing sucks Kyle has a special way of letting everyone know about it.P3 1.13ghz is a good example of a proper review.

Even if it sucks alot of websites are Polishing a turd to make sure they continue to get free stuff and that my friend is a big fat turd.
 
When I hear Cornell I instantly think of Andy Bernard... I think that gives me away as a bit uneducated, but I don't care.
 
They came up with that? Reviews (like the hotel review they cited) always read "fake" to me. It's just how it is worded and the things they say.

Crap, I should have published a paper for what I thought was common knowledge ...


Obviously, fake-reviews are a very tough issue to solve. You can have all the "thumbs up/down" buttons you like and all the "helpful/not-helpful" links, but no matter what you do, the fake review people have enough accounts to bump the stuff anyways. Hell, even the "verified buyer" doesn't help because it's well within their interest to purchase a few to post the reviews.
 
So almost anything typed properly and from your point of view is fake? Awesome.........
 
I love hardforum! It is a site I visit daily! I didn't get a chance to review this site though because why review a site on a forum I am at?
 
It seems to detect fake reviews or reviews written by preteens. Both of which highly deserve to be flagged from averaged reviews. Maybe they can adapt it to remove "This game will be awesome!!!" 5-star reviews as well as "Shipping was slow." 1-star reviews.
 
I'm speechless, this software is probably absolute shit, primarily because it's following a wide set of assumptions. Almost a complete waste of time.

^
Run that through your review detector.
 
Back
Top