Core temps vs CPU temps? Feel like an idiot

entropism

2[H]4U
Joined
Dec 23, 2004
Messages
3,640
OK, so I've been having issues with my new opteron install, and getting VERY high temp readings. The question I have now is, perhaps I've been reading this wrong, and I'm a complete & total idiot. You guys decide:

Running CoreTemps on my OCed Opteron 170 (at 2.6Ghz, 1.35v), it's showing me a TCaseMax of 57c, and core temps at ~40c idle, about 60-70c at load.

Running PCWizard 2006, it's showing my core temps at load as ~65c each, with a processor temp of about ~38c.

Now, I was under the assumption that when someone says "Oh, I get 30c idle/40c load with brand X HSF" they were talking about the cores. Am I completely mistaken and they're talking about the external CPU temps? And if so, what program can I use to accurately measure what I need to be worried about?
 
Coretemp is supposedly the "most" accurate program for measuring core temperature. However, I don't like it because it reads a little higher than other programs (call me ignorant, I just like to see lower temps :p ). But you are correct about the temps. If I say that my system is 37C idle and 45C Load then I am referring to the temps that I am seeing when I look at coretemp, and thus I am reporting my CPU core temperature.
 
Well, that's what I figured. But geez, something's up with my system, and it's driving me nuts. RMAd an opteron 165 because it was so hot, same temps on an opteron 170 now. The XP-90 I was using worked fine on my A64 3500+, maybe the base warped over the past 2 years. I have a ninja on order coming in wed. night, if that doesn't work, I'm giving up. =/
 
First of all, the XP-90 I used to install with my athlon 3200 systems (low end gaming rig, sold 88 of them) would cope with the heat of the single core athlons at stock speed.

It really doesn't fare so well in a dual core, overclocked environment!

The TDP on your new "denmark" Opteron 170 is 110w at stock speeds. That should jump to at least 125 with your current overclock...

The TDP on the 3500+ was only 89w (and probably less, because even the 4000+ had the same TDP, so it seems this is a conservative measurement) at stock...

Your new CPU is putting out at LEAST 21w more than your old CPU... not to mention how much you've OC'ed it.


What is your ambient temp btw? Hows your case airflow? Post pics and I can help you optimize that kinda stuff.


LASTLY most people are saying "oh I got 30/40'c" and they're using speedfan as a reference... I'd say only 30-50% of people actually USE coretemp as reference to their posts!
 
Good last point from the last poster.

If I say I'm running at 27/42C I'm using my ITE smartguardian temps. However, coretemp is telling me more like 36/45C and usually i use ITE smartguardian
 
Arcy, that's a hell of a point you make, something I'll have to look into.

No pics as of right now (can't find my camera), but I'm using this case , with a panaflo on the XP-90 and a Papst 120mm fan on exhaust. Never been good with cleaning up wiring, but it's as pushed to the side as I can get. As far as ambient temps, I keep my house cooled to about 70f, give or take since the comp is nowhere near the central AC/heating vents.

I think the main reason I figured something was "wrong", and not that the HSF couldn't handle the job is, even OCed and running Orthos, the HSF was cool to touch. When I'd remove it to check the contact patterns in the thermal paste, it looked to be making solid contact. Add to the fact that even at stock speeds (which I'm down to until the ninja/new retention clip comes in), core temps are at 37c idle instead of 40c.
 
Little update: I put a ninja on the chip, had it OCed to 2.9Ghz ORTHOS stable after a few hours, it was idling at 34c, load at 49c. I figure when the AS5 settles in, it'll lower 1-2c or so.

I had to clock it back, however, and I'm running at 2.7Ghz right now, as I got a BSOD running warcraft, and didn't feel like pushing my luck just yet.
 
good... i know my TDX water block doesnt do as good a job on my165 as it did on my X2 3800+ or my opteron 144. I see a big diff. i have fairly agressive water cooling with a cool room and it is eating my cooling alive... like idle right now core1 is @ 35 and core 2 (the bastard core) is @ 42*C....

load they both are hitting mid 50's @ 1.45vcore.... i am looking at getting a switech storm or something else... becasue the TDX isnt cutting it right now..
 
I currently have a Conroe E6600 Overclocked to 3.33ghz stable. I am getting so many different TEMP readings. I use NVIDIA Monitor, the system BIOS, Core Temp, TAT from Intel. They all have different values. How can I determine my exact temps?
 
Core Temp and TaT should be the same since they are reading the temp from a sensor on the cpu, rather than on the motherboard. Go with what they say. Since those are what most everyone else around here uses, you'll be comparing apples to apples when you talk about temps.

If you want to know "exactly" what you're temps are, you'll need to buy a temperature prob. Probably not worth the effort if you get consistant readings from core temps and you're not an extreme o/c'r.
 
Back
Top