Core I7 vs. Wolfdale/Yorkfield

Joined
Sep 25, 2005
Messages
17
I am planning a new PC Build. Money isn't really an object, but I would like to stay around 2K or so.

What I am curious about is the real world performance of the Core I7 vs. Wolfdale/Yorkfield when it comes to gaming, as I don't do video editing, DB stuff, etc.
Would it really be worth it to build a Core I7 system when I could build a comparable system for at least $500+ less.

I would be looking at a 1GB Video card, and pushing either a Q9550/E8400 to 1:1 timings @ hopefully 1600mhz speeds.

So the simple question is -- how big of a difference does the new Core make.

As a note, I will probably be sticking with 32-bit XP Pro until Win7 comes around.
 
If your going to spend $2,000 on a new computer and built it yourself, you better be going Core i7. Save money on RAM, don't buy into the DDR3 1600 shit. 1333 is enough.

Gaming benches are good for the i7 but application are even better. Unfourtainately, if your going with a 1GB video card and I'm guessing 4GB of ram(?), you're really going to be holding yourself down by going with XP. Vista x64 is an amazing OS.\

What type of resolution are you gaming at? That makes a difference in how much you should spend.

Also, you do have a nice system already, are there games that won't play well on it?

Core 2 Quads are OK but the Core i7 is alot better.
 
I just built a totally awesome machine around a Core 2 Quad. My CPU was the Q9550 which I believe offers an excellent price/performance ratio if you aren't interested in overclocking (in which case you'd go with the Q6600).

I'd wait until Core i7 becomes a more mature technology. The boards just came out. I would expect bugs to start showing up in the next few weeks.
 
Do some work yourself and dig for some benchmarks. [H] has some, man how lazy are people these days?
 
Do some work yourself and dig for some benchmarks. [H] has some, man how lazy are people these days?

Relax... just do what I do and wait for HG, Danny, or tiraides to post, then just agree with them. :p now watch them avoid this thread, lol!!!

ooh, i agree with bigdog.
 
Uh, I'm with lowteckh on this one -- people can look for their own damn benchmarks.

Or, they could search the Intel Processors forum and get the answers for themselves.
 
Uh, I'm with lowteckh on this one -- people can look for their own damn benchmarks.

Or, they could search the Intel Processors forum and get the answers for themselves.

Ahh, so you're tired, too, eh? :p Welcome to the club. :)
 
Well one of the benchmarks I found is that the Core i7 is a huge improvement over say an 8xxx series Core 2, but only at lower resolutions. After you get over 1920x or higher, the improvement is almost null. But at lower resolutions, the higher cpu bendwith is amazing and can sometimes double youf FPS over an e8400.
 
If you're pairing an inferior GPU that can't handle high-ish resolutions with i7, natural selection will hopefully get the better of you.
 
The way I look at this is.. it's not too bad buying an LGA 775 Intel cpu/mobo. Depending on where the person is coming from or upgrading from, the important thing is he/she notices a performance improvement over his/her existing setup. The thing is to not spend too much on a LGA 775 cpu/mobo platform. Go cheap and and as long as it can deliver the gaming experience as well as an overall improvement over your old setup is where it really matters. I don't think anyone will argue about upgrading to an E8400 Dual Core or Q6600 Quad build if the price is very good and reasonable. Just don't go crazy on the spending. Upgrade to where it fits your needs and budget.
 
If your going to spend $2,000 on a new computer and built it yourself, you better be going Core i7. Save money on RAM, don't buy into the DDR3 1600 shit. 1333 is enough.

Gaming benches are good for the i7 but application are even better. Unfourtainately, if your going with a 1GB video card and I'm guessing 4GB of ram(?), you're really going to be holding yourself down by going with XP. Vista x64 is an amazing OS.\

.


i have been debating for so long if i should go with vista. im still using xp and thinking of sticking with xp on my new i7 build but you make a great argument on why i should finaly ditch xp. also, dx10 is on vista too and provides noticable difference as well.
 
I would suggest to stick with the Core2 tech. Like you suggested a 9550 is a good choice. These systems have been out for a while and are most likely much more stable than the new i7's, not to mention a bit cheaper. Since you are not doing any video editing and DB server stuff, you shouldn't notice a difference. If you are a gamer, which it looks like your are, the biggest factor is choice of video card. Also, I would go with Vista64 which would allow more than 3GB or so of memory, which XP 32-bit only allows and we all know games, these days, are becoming more resource intensive, not less:D
 
Thank you very much for the input. At least, the folks who took the time to say something constructive.

To those who weren't, you can take the time to bitch at someone but not take that same amount of time to leave a constructive opinion? Now who is the lazy tard?

I have looked at some benches but was/am hoping for some real world input, as folks build out their I7's.
 
Back
Top