Contrast ratio and viewing angle questions

DeathCloud

Gawd
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
1,004
All,
Could someone please explain contrast ratio's to me. I am looking into a new widscreen monitor and want to make sure I get a good one. I assume the higher the contrast ratio the better. Also I read alot of negativity about viewing angles on LCDs but I dont get the point. Why is this such a big deal. I never try to work on my pc from the side. I have been on the CRT bandwagon so any information on LCDs would be a great help.

Thanks in advance.
 
Contrast ratio (actually On / Off Contrast Ratio) is the ratio of the brightness of the darkest color (black) that the monitor can produce to the brightest color (white) that it can produce. Higher is better. It matters because it makes colors "pop" more, and makes things look more vibrant. LCD monitors are not as good as CRTs in producing very dark blacks, so generally monitors with higher contrast ratios are better, although manufacturers are now getting clever with systems that produce better theoretical CRs without a big improvement in actual user experience, so reading reviews regarding the monitors performance in reproducing details in dark areas is beneficial.

Viewing angles matter for certain monitors because even small movements in your chair such as slouching causes noticeable shifts in color in the worst monitors. Again while specs are good to go by for basics, manufacturers quote silly specs for viewing angles as well. If you use the pivot / rotate function that some monitors have (landscape viewing) vertical viewing angle is really important. To be honest not everyone is that bothered by slight color shifts associated with small movements in your chair, and you sound like you may not be too concerned about it. I find it mildly irritating on TN film monitors and OK on S-PVA monitors. SIPS is the best in this regard, even though the specs look no better than S-PVA or P-MVA monitors.

Oh and keeping in mind the fact that you are new to LCDs, the type of panel used determines certain things about the LCD's performance. Here's a primer of the relative merits of each panel type:
http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/articles/20inch_roundup.htm
 
Take all numbers with a grain of salt. But yes generally higher Contrast is better.

Viewing angles: Before I bought my first LCD, I thought the same, that it was a non issue. After all I wasn't planning to use my screen from the side...

Turns out the dirty little secret is the tone shifts at the slightest angles. Below is a picture from my S-PVA Dell 2007fp. This is a Panel samsung claims has 180 degrees (as insanely ridiculous as that number is to start with) viewing angles.

This picture was shot from my chair from normal viewing distance, centered behind the monitor. These are crops from the center and the edge. Even if you are pefectly centered it will be tone shifting on the way out from the center on both sides.

It may not look like much in a static image, but this is where it gets to individual factors. How much you are bothered by visual abberations. Because in use I found it intolerable. The slightest head movement made it much worse and the critical factor is the tone shifts enough that EACH EYE will see a different image. To me it looked like glare or false 3d effect(due to different angle to each eye). It was very unnatural. If I closed one eye it wasn't nearly as problematic. Put it together and I just could stand using it. I got rid of it.

Then I learned much more and carefully checked out a number of panels in store. My end recomendations to those who are sensitive to visual abertations:

1: Get S-IPS these are the best panels. Superb stability in viewing angles. Very CRT like.
2: Get TN panel and use it only in landscape mode. Horizontal viewing angles are pretty good and those are the ones that cause most issues.

That is all. I can't use VA panels at all and I can't use TN panels in Portrait mode. I now have a TN panel and have no issue with viewing angles as long as it is in Normal Landscape mode. In portrait it is just like VA, maybe worse.

I stress that this only applies to those sensitive to viewing angles issues. Everyone else (most people) can just ignore it and get whatever is cheapest, or has other features you want.

65452628.TGQ59HS0.pvaToneShift.jpg
 
Thanks for all the info. I never would have thought switching from CRT to LCD would be such a pain in my ass :D
 
DeathCloud said:
Thanks for all the info. I never would have thought switching from CRT to LCD would be such a pain in my ass :D

It may not. You may be like most people and be unaffected by viewing angles. Or you could just start at the top and get one of the more CRT like displays with S-IPS panel.

NEC 20WMGX2, HP2065 are a couple of IPS.
 
For my home setup I bought a 22" Diamondtron CRT and I'm looking for a replacement for my Dell. First monitor that has good color, low noise, 23-24", low input lag, HDCP and component video inputs with scaling will replace my Dell. The Benq and Acer come close but the lack of scaling is a deal breaker for me.
 
It may not. You may be like most people and be unaffected by viewing angles. Or you could just start at the top and get one of the more CRT like displays with S-IPS panel.

NEC 20WMGX2, HP2065 are a couple of IPS.

Yeah, and pay about five times what you would for a CRT. :(

The stopped production of CRTs waaay too soon. They should have waited until they had S-IPS at a price not much higher than a CRT. LCDs just seem to be lighter, smaller, but look a hell of a lot shittier and are much more expensive.

I thought thing were supposed to get smaller and cheaper, not smaller and exponentially more expensive.
 
Back
Top