Contemplating a new build.

devman

2[H]4U
Joined
Dec 3, 2005
Messages
2,400
I'm thinking about upgrading soon and I wanted to test the waters a bit. I haven't been following the AMD vs. Intel as much as I should have so I wanted to run this by the experts here.

The current rig I have is in my sig, it's got an AMD 64 939 4000+ single core. I'm probably gonna use an eVGA mobo and video card again because I've found there products to be reliable in my last 2 builds so I'm gonna stick with what I know.

The question is to go with:
nForce 590 AM2 board w/ AMD X2 Windsor 5200+
or
nForce 680i 775 Board w/ C2D Conroe E6600

Either way I figure I'll put in 2 sticks of Corsair TwinX 1GB PC6400
and the Video would be an EVGA 8800GTS.

The Intel set up costs a little more (maybe 50-60 if that), what I'm concerned about is the performance comparison between the two and how either would stack up against what I have currently.
 
ok well, i suspect as i write this theres gonne be some guy who posts between this post and OP stating (in caps lock and everything) the following:

"omgn00bzorz go with the intelzorz itl roxorz your soxorz."

Which would be correct. The Core 2 Duo line have the highest performers (I still believe however, that due to AMD price drops at the midrange end they're still perfectly compeditive).

So, yes, the E6600 will romp stomp the FX 5200. However, an FX 62 + Nforce 590 should not be anywhere near the E6600 and 680i. Via newegg. the differance is $90, which isnt laughable.

(edit): Neweggs price gouging on the E6600s, something to take into consideration when you decide where your buying from.

Regardless, the quoted AMD setup is the best you can get from AMD, that core wont overclock for much. The Intel board on the other hand, I suspect you'll be able to hit a whopping 4.0GHz with that bad ass setup. If I was you, and i was ready to spend that $90, id go for the intel system, infact, I'd even drop down the processer level to make sure I got that intel rig.

I really couldnt afford a high end rig, but i pushed for it anyways. The result: I score higher then a stock X6800 in the benchmarks. the graphics card I have yet to overclock, we'll see how that goes.

And as for the 680i boards. EVGA, and BFG have by far the best customer service out of Computer Board parners I've ever seen. But, interms of quality of the board its self, the Asus Striker is probibly better then EVGA 680i board. Bios has yet to be worked out but i suspect the Asus one will benchmark higher

But i have one product to put in a word for! Its completely solo, and has an interesting Engineering history: the DFI Lanparty UT ICFX 3200 (a review of which can be found here). It is the ONLY board featuring an RD600 Chipset, it overclocks, just like the 680i chipset, like mad. Its actually a pretty light chipset in terms of PCI-e lanes, nothing ground breaking. 8 to each slot but, remember, 8 lanes seems to be more then enough for every setup. The biggest indicator of which to me was the Quad SLI rig a dude in this forum setup, on the Nforce 570 chipset (8 lanes each slot, FOUR [4] lanes per core) and suffered no performance hit.

Of course, it suppots crossfire, and will probibly support ATIs Physics.

anywho, If I was you, ID go for the E6600, or E6400, and the ICFX 3200.

But, i have a 6200TC PCI-E i could use as a hold over card, until the R600 comes out. you probibly dont have the same luxury.
 
Is there any substance to all these problems I'm hearing about with the EVGA 680i? Is there a way to avoid it?

Also how big a PSU should I be looking at to power this rig, would 450W be enough?
 
Is there any substance to all these problems I'm hearing about with the EVGA 680i? Is there a way to avoid it?

Also how big a PSU should I be looking at to power this rig, would 450W be enough?
Avoid it? no, just RMA it if you get a bad board... simple as that. If you stick with a single card setup, go with the corsair 520W. If you want to move to a dual card setup, go with the corsair 620W. Both of those are made by Seasonic.

Some reading material for you:
http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2795 (E6600+ review)
http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2802 (E6300/E6400 review)
http://dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=5414 (news on the new Core2 models)
 
Back
Top