Considering a video upgrade...what's your call?

mr.dearthian

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
406
With the newest generations of games here (Doom3) and on the way (HL2), my system is alas jonesing for a new video card. I'm not quite ready to do the full upgrade of CPU, moboard, memory and video (that will come this summer or fall) but am definitely considering a video upgrade. Here is my current rig:

PIV 2.8ghz
Gigabyte 8KNXP motherboard (i875)
1GB Kingston Hyper X PC3200
ATI Radeon 9700 AIW
2x80GB W. Digital HDD's Raid0 stripe
Pioneer 16XDVD
TDK 48x CD-RW
Sony 4x DVD+/- RW
various fans and fan controller

In Doom3, I'm averaging 45fps at 800x600 High (smooth for the most part), 37fps 1024x768 (some occassional stuttering). I'd obviously like to run either 1280x1024 High or 1024x768 Ultra High (or an even higher res :D ).

What I'm wanting to know is what would be a good card to get without spending too much (in other words, will give me the most bang for my buck without being to crippled by a CPU bottleneck)? Also, will PCIe boards work in 8X AGP slots (my board isn't PCIe)? I'm not brand loyal (I've owned 2 ATI boards and 2 Nvidia boards), I just buy what gives me the most bang for the buck. When I do the CPU down the road, etc I'll probably get a higher level card (something that will be a good match for something at that time). So I'm open to all suggestions.

Mr.Dearthian
 
mr.dearthian said:
Also, will PCIe boards work in 8X AGP slots
No, but all cards for the next couple of years will have a AGP 8X equivalent that should perform pretty much the same (for the forseeable future, since we have not even saturated the 8x bus yet)
 
I think that the vanilla 6800 would be a great video card for you... it's not to much money, but at the same time, it will match your system just about right...
 
bobsaget said:
I think that the vanilla 6800 would be a great video card for you... it's not to much money, but at the same time, it will match your system just about right...

I was leaning towards either that or a 5900. Read another thread and definitely didn't think the 5900 would be too big a boost.

Which do you think would be your choice of the following at Newegg?

Here are the choices

I've only heard of MSI and Leadtek. Heard anything about the others?

Mr.Dearthian
 
mr.dearthian said:
I was leaning towards either that or a 5900. Read another thread and definitely didn't think the 5900 would be too big a boost.

Which do you think would be your choice of the following at Newegg?

Here are the choices

I've only heard of MSI and Leadtek. Heard anything about the others?

Mr.Dearthian

Going from a 9700pro to a 5900nu is a bit of a down good I mite imagine? Regardless its definetly a waste of money if your talking about upgrading :eek:

EDIT: while im on the subject of money...you never did mention how much money your looking to spend on this video card? Shit I can tell you to go and buy a x800 XT or a 6800U! And yes they are definitely worth the bang for the buck (supposing you have the bucks to get the bang of course :D ), so do tell what kind of money your working with here on your upgrade so people can give you a more educated and accurate response to your question.
 
CraftyOtter said:
The $300 6800 would be a good choice for gaming @ 1024x768 and 1280x1024 resolutions.
i agree, the 5900 core is inferior to the 6800 core. the extra money would be well spent.
 
A 5900xt wouldn't be a big enough boost. The 5900/5950 ultras and nu's are running about $350-$400+ and are at least 40% slower than a $300+/- 6800nu, so, IMO, they are NOT worth the money.

So, for about the gajillionth time this week, I say go with the 6800nu! ;)
 
Demon Diablo,
The $200-400 range was what I was thinking (when I started this discussion). After doing a little poking around, I've pretty much been able to eliminate the 5900's (previous threads in this forum nixed that one for me and your reccomendations). I want a decent boost in horsepower. At the same time, I don't want to blow major $$ on a card that is going to be limited severely by my CPU then obsolete when I do the big upgrade (I plan on getting a top-shelf card when I do upgrade to have a balanced match between CPU and GPU). That would be wasted horsepower. I just want to get the most life out of my current rig before the big upgrade and get one a good balance between CPU and GPU horsepower.

The vanilla 6800 seems to be the choice so far (looking at Newegg, the GT's are scarce for awhile, regular 6800's are a plenty). Which brand would you reccomend off of the Newegg link I put above? Obviously, I'd want want one with the 400Mhz core (which pretty much eliminates the first couple of cards). Are any of these makers better than the other? CraftyOtter reccomended the Gainward (the '$300' one). Anybody agree or disagree?

Thanks for suggestions so far, :)

Mr.Dearthian
 
How about getting a 6800GT card and then when you come to do a big upgrade, get a PCI-e mobo and another 6800GT and run the two cards in parallel.

Might need to do a bit more research into nVidia's medium-to-long term plans for SLI though, just in case it doesn't turn out to be viable in the future.

Might be the best of all worlds: a good card now that won't be wasted in the future.

EDIT - hang on - ignore me. I'm talking rubbish.
 
mulpsmebeauty said:
How about getting a 6800GT card and then when you come to do a big upgrade, get a PCI-e mobo and another 6800GT and run the two cards in parallel.

Might need to do a bit more research into nVidia's medium-to-long term plans for SLI though, just in case it doesn't turn out to be viable in the future.

Might be the best of all worlds: a good card now that won't be wasted in the future.

EDIT - hang on - ignore me. I'm talking rubbish.

This isnt possible. You cant run an agp on a PCIe mobo let alone run an agp and a PCIe together. It would be nice but not possible b/c of agp arc. Gainward is a good company to invest your money in. BFG is another good company.

Oh btw I dont know about everyone else but for me the link you posted didnt work :confused: Also the 6800nu is a good card to buy but im not sure how usfull it will be come your next "big upgrade" If eVGA makes 6800nu I suggest you buy one of those now and then in 3months (i believe thats the max. allotted time) trade in that card plus give them $100 and get yourself an 6800GT. That card will definitely more than likely do your next big upgrade pc justice.
 
Demon Diablo,
That was my thinking also (because I wanted an upgrade that would match my current rig and then go totally nuts for a topshelf one when I do the big upgrade; I figure that another generation of card will be out by the time I do next in June or so).

Sorry about the link. :confused: I was looking at the different 'vanilla' 6800's at Newegg. After reading other threads, the Gainward seems like the choice. Or, at least, something with a 400Mhz clock. Newegg also carries 400Mhz ones by XFX and MSI in addition to the Gainward. The eVga one they have is a 325Mhz core. The 400's aren't much, so I'll probably opt for that.

Mr.Dearthian
 
Another vote for the 6800, but I think you should get the GT. You're not going to be CPU limited (If you are, time to OC that 2.8). Then when you get your major upgrade, I'd stick with the AGP bus (and jump ship to AMD go for 64bit compatible CPU) You can migrate the GT to that board for a while. Then wait for the 7800. I personally think that Nvidia will be milking this particular tech node for a while (think 5xxx series) only big deal will be 512mb cards Q1 of 05.
 
Your 2.8 system is going to be viable for a long time yet, and if you are going to buy a new video card it might as well be one that will last you a little while. Maybe the 6800 or 6800GT.

The reason to spend a little more on it now?
By the time you get a new CPU, you'll have to change your motherboard to have PCI express, get new memory such as DDR2, and a new CPU socket such as the new 775 is almost guaranteed if you wait more than a few more months. So if you are buying for your current P4, give it one more big upgrade on the video then stop. Anything you get today probably won't be usable on your next rig.

And the above advice about SLI is correct. You can not SLI the AGP cards, and your current MB does not have PCI Express, so none of that matters.
 
Guys,

Thanks for all of the advice!! Ended up getting a Gainward 6800GT at Mwave for $419 (got a little frisky $$ wise when I saw they HAD one :D ). Should see it by Friday!! wOOt!!

I'll post some benchmarks before and after!!!

Mr.Dearthian
 
mr.dearthian said:
Demon Diablo,
That was my thinking also (because I wanted an upgrade that would match my current rig and then go totally nuts for a topshelf one when I do the big upgrade; I figure that another generation of card will be out by the time I do next in June or so).

Sorry about the link. :confused: I was looking at the different 'vanilla' 6800's at Newegg. After reading other threads, the Gainward seems like the choice. Or, at least, something with a 400Mhz clock. Newegg also carries 400Mhz ones by XFX and MSI in addition to the Gainward. The eVga one they have is a 325Mhz core. The 400's aren't much, so I'll probably opt for that.

Mr.Dearthian

Seriously guys, two posts with wrong core speeds and no one set him straight!

That 400 core speed you are seeing is a mis-type by the seller, where 400 MHz is the RAMDAC speed, NOT the core speed. The vanilla 6800 default is 325, and the GT is 350. Only the Ultra reaches 400 at stock. Some of the card maker oc slightly, but only by about 20-30 MHz.

Luckily, you made the right choice with a GT. Interested to see how you score, since I'm running a similar system.
 
Back
Top