Conroe: P5B, P5LD2, P5NSLi

rob75

n00b
Joined
Oct 2, 2006
Messages
11
Hi all, I need your suggestion.
I'm going to buy my newprocessor Conroe E6600,
and I have to decide which is the better MoBo to couple with.

Upon my money disposal, I suppose to have these 3 alternatives:

- P5B (chipset 965P)
- P5LD2 (chipset 945)
- P5NSLi (chipset Nvidia NF4 or NF5, I don't know...)

From various forum, I've seen that:

- P5B has the most reliable chipset for Conroe, but it shows to have some issue about Ide connections (no chance to mount more than 2 PATA...), and other problems with RAM compatibility

-P5LD has pretty price and should work fine, but has "only" 4 giga of maximum RAM allowable

-P5NSLi has an huge amount of allowable RAM (16GB), but has old chipset NF4, and it warms a lot


So now I'm completely confused, and I don't know what to decide

Please help me, any suggestion is welcome

Thanks

Roby
 
The boards aren't really in the same class. The P5B Deluxe is a medium-high end motherboard, while the P5LD2 is a low-medium end motherboard and the P5NSLI is a medium sort of mainstream SLi board.

The P5B Deluxe is easily the best of those without question. The P5LD2 doesn't have a "less reliable" chipset as you put it. All the Intel chipsets have equal reliability. Just because the P965 Express chipset was designed for Conroe doesn't mean the other chipsets don't work just as well for it. Intel designed the Core 2 Duo CPU's to work with existing chipsets with a little work, and then they released a new chipset to fill in a gap previously left by the demise of the i955x chipset from their lineup.

We'll still be using P965 and i975x for Kentsfield quad core Core 2 CPU's too. Plus the stability of the entire line up of Intel chipsets is without a doubt top notch. Intel's worst chipsets can usually match the best VIA/SIS/nVidia/ATi chipsets for stability and sometimes for performance.

The P5LD2 as stated before is lower end board, I'd advise against going with that unless you know for a fact that the feature set is sufficient for your needs now and in the future.

The P5NSLI has the nForce 570SLI not the nForce 4 SLI Intel Edition chipset which isn't the best. It's a bad overclocker and runs extremely hot. So depending on your cases design I'd think carefully about selecting a motherboard based on that chipset. The nForce 4 Intel Edition chipset would actually be better than the 570SLi due to it running cooler and having very mature drivers. The P965 chipset is really the best choice budget permitting of course. Why you would consider two PATA ports a downside I am not sure. At this point I wouldn't recommend anyone use anything PATA aside from optical drives and even then, optical drive manufacturers are comitting themselves to SATA products by the end of next year to complete a full transition away from PATA. Several drive manufacturers in other parts of the world have already done so. Plextor already offers SATA optical drives now as well.

If you really needed PATA drive support for some reason, a sub $20 add in card will do the trick. However with the falling drive prices, I would just say screw it and replace any legacy hardware with some newer better performing SATA drives. That's just me, do as you will.
 
I have the P5NSLI, it is pretty inexpensive vs the other board. Overclocking work nicely so far. Pretty stable.

rob75 said:
Hi all, I need your suggestion.
I'm going to buy my newprocessor Conroe E6600,
and I have to decide which is the better MoBo to couple with.

Upon my money disposal, I suppose to have these 3 alternatives:

- P5B (chipset 965P)
- P5LD2 (chipset 945)
- P5NSLi (chipset Nvidia NF4 or NF5, I don't know...)

From various forum, I've seen that:

- P5B has the most reliable chipset for Conroe, but it shows to have some issue about Ide connections (no chance to mount more than 2 PATA...), and other problems with RAM compatibility

-P5LD has pretty price and should work fine, but has "only" 4 giga of maximum RAM allowable

-P5NSLi has an huge amount of allowable RAM (16GB), but has old chipset NF4, and it warms a lot


So now I'm completely confused, and I don't know what to decide

Please help me, any suggestion is welcome

Thanks

Roby
 
Thanks for all your precious suggestions.
A last question: you talk about P5B DELUXE, but probably for money issues I could only buy P5B in his basic version.
So the comparaison should be done between P5B (basical) and P5LD2, P5NSLI..
Are the arguments about P5B Deluxe valid also for P5B basical, or not?
 
rob75 said:
Thanks for all your precious suggestions.
A last question: you talk about P5B DELUXE, but probably for money issues I could only buy P5B in his basic version.
So the comparaison should be done between P5B (basical) and P5LD2, P5NSLI..
Are the arguments about P5B Deluxe valid also for P5B basical, or not?

Pretty much, though the P5NSLI probably will win out in the features department against the P5B vanilla. However I wouldn't use the 570SLI chipset based on what I know about it.
 
I happen to like the P5NSLI motherboard. I switched to it from a Gigabyte DS3. It's a heck of alot more stable and less flakey. It runs a little warm, yes, but it doesn't affect stability. I don't overclock, but if you do , then you wouldn't want it.

What is it that you know about it that makes you not like it?

Shawn
 
verncat05 said:
I happen to like the P5NSLI motherboard. I switched to it from a Gigabyte DS3. It's a heck of alot more stable and less flakey. It runs a little warm, yes, but it doesn't affect stability. I don't overclock, but if you do , then you wouldn't want it.

What is it that you know about it that makes you not like it?

Shawn

The 570SLI chipset. Runs too hot, doesn't overclock worth a damn and I'd personally rather use an Intel chipset with Intel processors. Most of the time the other chipset makers can't match the Intel's for stability and certainly their drivers aren't as good. If any board using the 570SLI chipset is more stable than the Gigabyte DS3, it isn't because of the chipsets. Something was wrong with your Gigabyte, either that or some piece of hardware in your system wasn't perfectly compatible with it.

But I'd match Intel's chipsets with anyone else's any day of the week.
 
The 570SLI chipset. Runs too hot, doesn't overclock worth a damn and I'd personally rather use an Intel chipset with Intel processors. Most of the time the other chipset makers can't match the Intel's for stability and certainly their drivers aren't as good. If any board using the 570SLI chipset is more stable than the Gigabyte DS3, it isn't because of the chipsets. Something was wrong with your Gigabyte, either that or some piece of hardware in your system wasn't perfectly compatible with it.

Well, thank you for clearing up what was wrong with my DS3 build...

The DS3 has ram compatability issues then and still does now. The P5NSLI does not have any ram issues for me. Remember, overclocking is not always a deciding factor for everyone, so telling people that a particular board is junk just because of it's overclocking potential isn't very wise. As far as running hot, do you have any experience with the DS3? If so, you'd know that it runs very hot as well. In fact, I'd say it runs hotter than the P5NSLI does. I can say this because I have experience with both boards and both chipsets. Your recommendation is based on an opinion of a board/chipset, not experience.
As far as hardware compatability, if that's the case, then it would indeed be a chipset problem, as the NF570 does not have issues with the exact same hardware. The P5NSLI (NF570) board is a very stable platform for running at stock settings and maybe some minor overclocking. This is a recommendation based on personal experince. If mad overclocking is your thing, then it's true, the P965 chipset-based boards are better. This, too, is based on personal experience.

Shawn

Shawn
 
Back
Top