Confused about external DACs and LFE

joebobjoe

n00b
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
26
I am going to build a desktop audio setup. I have decided on a pair of Micca MB42X bookshelf speakers and a passive subwoofer. My rig has an Asus P8Z77V LK motherboard, which has on-board Realtek ALC892.

My confusion lies within the decision of whether or not to purchase an external DAC.

Out of all the recommended sub-$100 DACs I have seen, all of them output stereo (2.0). I understand that most people then use a speaker-level subwoofer. But does this not eliminate the benefits of having a separate channel for bass/LFE in 2.1 audio? I remember first hooking up my 5.1 home theater system and being amazed at how the subwoofer "woofed" independently from the rest of the system during explosions and stuff. Since I will primarily be using my system for gaming, isn't preserving these effects important?

My on-board Realtek ALC892 outputs a separate channel for LFE, why do all the popular DACs not?

Unless I am wrong, I am leaning towards just using my on-board audio chip.

Any thoughts?
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
There is no 2.1 audio, you create the .1 by feeding bass to the subwoofer.
5.1 and 7.1 use the LFE channel, but stereo music does not.
You can feed bass to the sub in a few ways.

Via soundcard driver software or AV pre-amp configuration, this will take front speaker bass and feed it onto the LFE channel.
By feeding a front channel line level to the sub as well as the speakers amp.
By taking a speaker level output from the amp and feeding to the sub using the subs high level inputs, or if it doesnt have them use a high to low level converter and feed it into the subs line level input.

If you want better sound quality than onboard, an external DAC can give you this if you choose wisely.
I use an external DAC for 2.0 (and a high level feed to my subwoofer) and another external DAC for 5.1.
 
Yeah I stated that badly.
Practically all the stereo music on sale doesnt use the LFE channel.

2.1 audio will require a 5.1 or more DAC.
I havent seen any 3 channel DACs on my travels.
 
You're going to need an amp for the speakers anyway. Try to find one with a variable pre-out RCA.
 
I remember first hooking up my 5.1 home theater system and being amazed at how the subwoofer "woofed" independently from the rest of the system during explosions and stuff. Since I will primarily be using my system for gaming, isn't preserving these effects important?

This is actually a sign that your setup is not really optimal :(

You don't want to hear the transition from your speakers to your sub if you can avoid it. Bass should either be non-localized (if it's just deep) or sound like it's coming from in front of you if there are higher harmonics.

A subwoofer in a 2.1 system with speaker level inputs will sometimes apply a high pass crossover to the output signal so what's going to play by the sub is not sent on to the speakers. That's not really necessary here. You're going passive though so I'm confused... how are you amping the sub and getting sound to it?

The reason the high pass is not necessary here is that here's no way those bookshelves with 4" drivers are playing with any authority below 120hz... probably roll off starts around 150 so either way you're going to need your sub playing pretty high or you're going to have a frequency gap. They say 60 hz but there is absolutely no way. Even dedicated 4" midbass drivers barely play 80hz without some kind of crazy horn setup. That's a lot of air to move for small cone area.

I wouldn't worry about overlap in the bass frequencies at all. You don't have 8" ported studio monitors or transmission lines on your desk or something.
 
Oh...

A few points:

  • I did not realize most stereo tracks do not include an LFE channel
  • Most games that output stereo probably do not support 2.1, correct? So, if I want LFE in a 2.1 speaker configuration I would have to have the game output 5.1 and have the Realtek driver mux the rear channels to the front? Is this a bad idea?
 
I kind of feel like the OP should look for another pair of speakers that comes with a matched subwoofer.

I still think the way to go is Powered Monitors/Subwoofer > XLR > DAC > USB/SPDIF > PC.
 
This is actually a sign that your setup is not really optimal :(

You don't want to hear the transition from your speakers to your sub if you can avoid it. Bass should either be non-localized (if it's just deep) or sound like it's coming from in front of you if there are higher harmonics.

A subwoofer in a 2.1 system with speaker level inputs will sometimes apply a high pass crossover to the output signal so what's going to play by the sub is not sent on to the speakers. That's not really necessary here. You're going passive though so I'm confused... how are you amping the sub and getting sound to it?

The reason the high pass is not necessary here is that here's no way those bookshelves with 4" drivers are playing with any authority below 120hz... probably roll off starts around 150 so either way you're going to need your sub playing pretty high or you're going to have a frequency gap. They say 60 hz but there is absolutely no way. Even dedicated 4" midbass drivers barely play 80hz without some kind of crazy horn setup. That's a lot of air to move for small cone area.

I wouldn't worry about overlap in the bass frequencies at all. You don't have 8" ported studio monitors or transmission lines on your desk or something.

Hm. Maybe since I am a novice what sounds bad to you might sound good to me.

I was planning on getting an active subwoofer, by the way.
 
I kind of feel like the OP should look for another pair of speakers that comes with a matched subwoofer.

I still think the way to go is Powered Monitors/Subwoofer > XLR > DAC > USB/SPDIF > PC.
Okay, but how do I handle audio that is 2.1? It would just be mixed into the stereo output of the 2.0, right?
 
I'm pretty sure the LFE can be retained when a game's 5.1 soundtrack is downmixed, although Dolby specification usually dumps the discrete low frequency channel when surround is folded down into stereo.
 
I'm pretty sure the LFE can be retained when a game's 5.1 soundtrack is downmixed, although Dolby specification usually dumps the discrete low frequency channel when surround is folded down into stereo.

Would downmixing a 5.1 soundtrack to 2.1 be worse than just going with the game's 2.0 soundtrack? I feel like downmixing might alter the way that the audio was meant to be heard.
 
Most games that output stereo probably do not support 2.1, correct?

Games generally automatically support whichever sound device you connect them to, or you can configure whether you want stereo or higher in the game.
I havent seen any game support 2.1.

So, if I want LFE in a 2.1 speaker configuration I would have to have the game output 5.1 and have the Realtek driver mux the rear channels to the front? Is this a bad idea?
If you want to use your subwoofer with stereo output, hook it up as previously stated, it does work.
 
Back
Top