Computer Shuts Off Randomly, but Infrequently

Joined
Aug 20, 2002
Messages
657
This past January, I made one last S939 investment and put together the following system:

  • Abit KN8-SLi
  • A64 3700+ San Diego
  • 1GB (2x512MB) Crucial PC3200
  • GeForce2 PCI
  • 320GB Seagate 7200.10 PATA
  • Lite-On 18X PATA DVD Burner
  • WinXP Home
  • Thermaltake 430W TR2 Power Supply
I initially ran it with an Antec 450W SmartPower (pulled from a Sonata II). By March, the system had randomly shut down a 2 or 3 times on me. It's just a spare system and isn't being monitored constantly, so I haven't been able to see these crashes take place---I would come to the system, and it would be powered down. Hitting the power button brought it back, no questions asked.

It seemed like the PSU was the obvious culprit, so I swapped it for the Thermaltake around this time. It had been rock solid since then, running 24/7 without a hitch. However, this afternoon, the same thing happened again.

Does this sound like a defective motherboard, or do I just have bad luck with PSUs?
 
Well if it stopped after you replaced the PSU then my guess would also be the PSU.
 
Hard to say because it happend so infrequently, but the TT was in for 4-5 months 24/7 correct? Its quite possible that its tired and not working well :) you could always buy a psu tester, not sure how well thatd work in this situation
 
warning : this is purely hypothetical and coming outta my a**

could use use motherboard monitor to log voltages? Could it possibly catch & successfully LOG the voltage dip or spike?

two things I'm not certain about, speed of updating within MBM, and whether it would actually be able to save any logs and even more so, keep a log during a sudden PC crash!

BTW random, rare crashes were always associated with RAM in my systems. Try upping memory volts one notch
 
BTW random, rare crashes were always associated with RAM in my systems. Try upping memory volts one notch

Did you get a complete power-down, or a BSOD?

Also, it might be worth noting that during the Antec crashes, I was using 768MB (1x512, 1x256) of generic RAM. I replaced that with the Crucial 2 weeks ago. The new RAM passed Memtest86 eight times at stock clocks/timings and voltage, which it currently runs at.
 
Have you Overclocked it?

Also is it possible to format and reinstall XP?
 
check temps ..sometimes heat can cause your psu to shut off ..also , are you plugged into a battery back up of anykind?

I had been running an IBM older battery back up for years without issue ..but after my last update to Core2 duao @3.4ghz and 8800GTS , 1KW PC P&C , 2 raptors and 2 other sata drives over 250GB ... I started getting random power downs .. I unplugged everything from my battery back up except for just my computer tower and then the random shutoffs all but stopped. went down to once every couple of weeks or so instead of every other day..I finally replaced the thing.
 
I've swapped out the motherboard, HDD, and video card for an MSI K8NNEO4-F 939 board, 500GB Western Digital SATA, and MSI 7300LE. Plus, I added an entry-level $50 APC battery backup.

Everything is at stock. The processor runs 33/50 idle/load and has passed 24 hours of Orthos small FFTs, but continues to randomly shut down. Could it be the CPU? Maybe the case (2003-era Antec Soho)?
 
Back
Top