Computer Programming vs. Computer Science

Title doesn't really matter. I have no problem calling myself a programmer, most people understand the term. I prefer the term developer, but this really depends on the context e.g. software, not property. I have no problem getting work, in fact I've taken acronyms/ certs off my CV to cut down on leads I'm not interested in.

The hard part is breaking into the field, but once you have some experience under your belt (and you're not crap) you should have no problem finding work.
 
What are the applications of each? and what makes them different?

I would say that computer science is the study of all things computer/computation related. As a field, it's where people study algorithms, systems and new technologies on a more theoretical level. Worthwhile work in this field eventually trickles down to the rest of the industry.

Computer programming/software engineering is the actual practice of implementing these algorithms and technologies, combined with some problem solving where needed. A computer scientist might come up with some new principal-component analysis and decision tree based method for location and recognition of similar content within videos. A computer programmer/software engineer might then take that algorithm and decide upon an appropriate framework and architecture for a video comparison program, and then implement said algorithm to achieve the goal of having software to compare the videos.

Or in a less glamorous roll, they might be writing code for a website that takes images and makes thumbnails out of them. It really all depends, because we're dealing with broad fields here.

It's similar to chemistry vs chemical engineering. Chemists formulate spiffy new materials. Chemical engineers figure out how to produce those on large scale for cheap.

I would say chemistry is a good analogy, yes. Someone who is a computer programmer or a software engineer is like a chemical professional of some kind (chemical technician, research technician, chemical engineer). Someone who is a computer scientist is like a chemist. You can go into computer science and become a computer programmer, much like how many people go into chemistry and become engineers or technicians.

if you suck at math, then non-liberal arts majors are not for you

I would argue that that's not true. You can study and be successful in any field regardless of whether or not you're good at math, you just might have to select different academic interests and occupations within that field. You might not understand linear algebra or discrete mathematics well enough to write complex programs, but maybe you're good at interpreting problems in a systematic way and have excellent people skills. You could be a mediocre coder, but an excellent product manager.

The guy who knows math knows how to think. The guy with the calculator doesn't necessarily know what to do with it.

...And things really get interesting when you hand the guy who knows math a calculator, which is why even people who just want to get a job writing code and aren't worried about doing extremely technical things (like writing heuristics for anti-virus software or something hard like that) should ground themselves well in math and computer science.

"Math" as in a collection of known formulas isn't whats important, it's the analytical mathematical mind, developed by learning math, that is important.

The skills in decomposing a real-world problem into tasks that can be solved with a computer are nearly identical to the skills in modeling a real-world problem to be solved mathematically, in my opinion.

This is the whole point of everything we learn. It's sad to see so many people studying computer science because 'they want a job as a programmer' and watch them reject so many important skills, subjects and ideas because they're 'never going to use them'. You're not going to sit there and write proofs about spectral decomposition, or inner-product spaces as a computer programmer, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't take a linear algebra class. Linear algebra teaches you many valuable skills that I feel anybody wishing to do quality work in the computer industry should have.

A big point of linear algebra is that it teaches us to generalize and work with things in an abstract way. You learn to deal with functions or statements not caring about whether what ever you're given is an 8x8 matrix or a real number...As long as it's a vector from a vector space, you can work with it. What good programmer can't see the parallel between that and programming? Being a math class, linear algebra not only reinforces these skills, but it also does so in the most abstract way possible. Additionally, most linear algebra classes cover proofs and logic. You probably won't need to be able to write mathematical proofs as a programmer, but learning to do them makes you a lot better at thinking about whether something is always true or not, and I personally feel like that's valuable when trying to keep track of edge cases.

Calculus isn't usually all that rigorous, but like the guy I quoted mentioned, it's all about analysis and problem solving, and when isn't that helpful for a computer programmer? It's essentially like weightlifting for your brain.

If it's down between the two, I'd pick the harder route -- you're more likely to learn a lot and push your limits. This is all personal opinion though about college.

I agree. Doing the harder route usually means doing the fundamentally 'deeper' route, and that's a great way to get a better understanding of what you're working with. Sure, a computer science degree might not center your curriculum on prominent industry languages and frameworks (like Ruby on Rails, or whatever they're hiring for at any given moment). If you learn the fundamentals well, moving to the next big industry thing is easy. If you focus on procedural knowledge and learning 'the skills', everything you know will no longer be valuable the next time the industry shifts forward.

Cisco I had a bit of trouble with mostly because it's lot of memorization of information you'd just lookup in the real world.

And what do you really want to be investing your time and money into? Concepts and ideas that require understanding, not memorization, or information and figures that, like you said, you'd just look up in the real world?
 
I'll say it one last time: Just try getting a job in the industry calling yourself a "computer programmer".

Stop it. Really. There is no point to even debating this.
 
i'd say computer programming is the application and coding of computing languages, whereas computer science is developing these languages and the mathematical stuff involved.

you are right. CS has too much math, physics, theories and other stuff which drove me nuts in college. You can get a programming AAS degree, and go to work; or if you liked it transfer to 4 year college and get a BS in CIS.

But be warned, Russians, Indians, Chinese coders and other software developers are taking away American jobs for much less. I'd suggest go for engineering, accounting, physics, chemistry, meds, nursing, etc. BTW, forget about Java as even long time pros cant get a decent job these days.
 
BTW, forget about Java as even long time pros cant get a decent job these days.

CS has physics? What?

I have the opposite problem: I'd hire a dozen devs tomorrow if I could find any that were up to snuff.
 
BTW, forget about Java as even long time pros cant get a decent job these days.

You see, I just don't know about that. Last time I was scoping out the job opportunities in my area (I'd say this was around winter time), I had sizable interactions with 4 different companies in my area. Of the 4, 3 were looking specifically for candiates to fill roles developing primarily in Java, while the other ended up hiring me for .NET development.

Beyond that, where I currently work, we've hired plenty of engineers who would describe themselves as Java developers because even though Java and .NET aren't exactly the same thing, proficiency in one can quickly adapt into proficiency in the other.

I realize that a sample size of 4 isn't all that convincing, but at least in my case I faced a very high probability of ending up doing Java work.
 
CS has physics? What?

I have the opposite problem: I'd hire a dozen devs tomorrow if I could find any that were up to snuff.

Well, all CUNY colleges require science for a BS degree. Why would anyone going for CIS take bio or astronomy I dont know. Logical choice is Physics.

How would you determine who is or is not snuffed up enough to work for you?

BTW, City has a Computer Systems degree. only 1 math class, less history, no foreign language.
 
I'm just trying to tell you how things work in the real world.


This is how my "real world" has hired folks for the past 5 years (two different types of positions at two different companies). It usually goes in this order

1. Hire from within - internal job postings.
2. Manager/Director etc: "do you guys know anyone who could do what you do that's reliable"
3. Go to a technical consulting/recruiting firm (we usually keep 2-3 on tap at any given time). Phone screen these folks first.
4. Public postings.

I suspect the "elite resume scanning" occurs at #3 because we don't have a system that does it internally. We got to step 3 for our last hire and I must have looked at, by hand, 20-30 resumes and only picked 3-4 out for interviews. I hate getting to #4.

And on the subject of #3 - probably 10 places around here have copies of my resume from various stages of my career. I try to make sure I get them a copy of my resume any time I change it. And if you find a great agency that actually gets to know you and your skills - all the better.

The one that's placed me in my last two roles has been great and they know the field and area that I'm best suited for - and they call me and ask if Im interested in stuff from time to time or ask me for referrals etc. I love to keep good recruiters as friends on linked in and if they're especially good - facebook too.

I've also seen people get placed after having a few discussions at the bar at a local "geek night" that we have in town that any "geek" is invited too.

That's how my little bubble has worked at least! (and it will change because I'm only 27)
 
Well, all CUNY colleges require science for a BS degree. Why would anyone going for CIS take bio or astronomy I dont know. Logical choice is Physics.
Some school might require a physics class for a CS degree, but that doesn't mean CS in the abstract includes physics. That school probably also requires some general education credits. Do you feel compelled to argue that CS includes Greek Literature?


How would you determine who is or is not snuffed up enough to work for you?
By interviewing them.
 
I would think CS would be more important. Keep in mind I didn't goto any university so I don't know the details of each course but I thought CS would teach you how to solve problems using a computer and programming is more about the details of implementing the things CS would teach you.

In other words, taking a programming course doesn't really teach you how to be a good programmer.
 
I'd suggest go for engineering, accounting, physics, chemistry, meds, nursing, etc.

although not that great either. Trying to find a job (as a recent BS grad), I keep coming across this:

We are looking for bright, motivated, innovative, and hardworking recently college graduate..

I'm nodding to myself, uh huh, yeah, oh yeah thats me!

then I reach

Requirements: Bachelors with 6 years, or Master with 3 years of relevant industry experience, or PhD fresh graduate

the fuuhhh?!?!
 
Well, all CUNY colleges require science for a BS degree. Why would anyone going for CIS take bio or astronomy I dont know. Logical choice is Physics.

So you're saying CS has too many physics courses, but you're also saying it's an elective?
 
Well, all CUNY colleges require science for a BS degree. Why would anyone going for CIS take bio or astronomy I dont know. Logical choice is Physics.
I took biology over physics because I was (still am) interested in bioinformatics and DNA/RNA modeling. I think flexibility on general science electives is available so people can tailor their education to their interests.
 
Back
Top