Computer died during move - suggestions? shuttle vs. hornet? Possible notebook?

optikill

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 19, 2002
Messages
91
Hello everyone,

it seems like i only post around here when i have issues - the rest of the time i just read what others have to say and ask. But anyway....

I moved apartments and my computer died somewhere inbetween. It's not that bad, but it's an added expense that I didn't want to have to deal with...

I was running:

1 gig athlon Tbird
2 30 gig fireball hdds in raid0
512 megs of ram
geforce 2 gts
hercules game theater sound card...

i know - ancient stuff. I was/AM deffinitely due an upgrade

I was considering building the following with either a shuttle 20th ann. ed. or a Hornet (more expansion) from monarch. I have no preference of chipset so p4 or amd 64 is totally cool...

so....

Case - shuttle or hornet
chipset - p4 2.8 or amd 64 3000+ no preference
200 - 250 gig sata western digital hd
512 ram (maybe a gig)
Saphire Radeon 9800 pro 128meg

I think that does it.... both systems should come out to 700 - 900 roughly.

I was also considering buying a notebook. Lately I've been pretty impressed with the new apple ibooks. I could get a loaded ibook 12 .1 inch (60gig hd, 624 megs of ram, airport extreme card, bluetooth)with student discount for 1300.

I like the idea of portability, but I'm not sure what to do. I'm a loaner computer at the moment and it just barely runs as well - so I need to do something pretty soon.

I appologize for the lengthy post. Thanks everyone!
 
Stick with the shuttle, they're the original brand who perfects the small form factor.

As for Procs, the P 2.8 I hear is pretty damn good. But the AMD 64 2800+ just came out and it's inexpensive, and kicks ass [H] style. So you might want to consider that.

http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=19-103-450&depa=1

Video card is great. No worries about that. Lots of people have it. Good HDD as well. Ram, you still have a lot of options, depending on what company you go with.

I'm not big on Apple, although their laptops are nice. But I'd only buy one for graphic design or movie editing. You'd have to shoot me first before I buy it for gaming.

-Logiks
 
I'd try to sell the old comp, saying that all components are possibly dead, with one certainly being dead.
 
cool! Thanks for the advice.

I seriously considered the hornet, but i got to wondering about it just in general. my comp that just died sounded like a 747 taxing before takeoff.

I want something quiet....

So that brings me to the shuttle....

If I go p4 - i was looking at the 20 anniversary. It's 360 bucks, but it comes with lots of goodies, or so it seems. 4in1 card reader, 16x dvd drive, carrying case (not that i would need that), and built in wireless 802.11b meh.....

I was wondering if i should get that one - or a different model...

I have no idea which AMD based system would be best...

I could use some advice...

I will be mainly using this machine for day to day activites, music, very very minimal gaiming - lots of photoshop and photo based stuff.... and probably hooking it up to a digital projector every once in a while.

Thanks everyone!
 
Go with the aniversary edition shuttle. The P4 will be better than the A64 if your just photoshopping and stuff.
Also get a gig of ram.

That will suit you perfectly.

You also said quiet. Take my advice and buy an 80mm coolermaster led fan. They are like $5 at newegg and are MUCH quieter than the standard fan that comes with the shuttle. Im using one in my shuttle now :)
 
cool i will look into that....


well.... in the mean time i decided to just focus on a pentium based system. I'm looking at either the anniversary ed. or the SB75S (pearl White) it has a 250watt psu and gigabit lan...

both look very nice. I've noticed that the prices on most of this stuff is a little cheaper at mwave.com (i've ordered there before, but long ago). Just wondering your thoughts on where to buy ..... also what specific memory should i get... there is so much to choose from - i didn't know if the shuttles were very memory picky or not!

Thanks!
 
i'm also concerned about whether or not a 9800 pro will fit in the case.... i've read the 9800 AIW pro or whatnot will most likely not fit...
 
You should have no problem fitting a 9800 pro in the case (not from personal experience). I don't quite know why an aiw 9800 pro wouldn't fit though, they are basically identical cards besides the tuner on them.

You may be thinking of an aiw 9600 pro/xt which has the coxial connection quite high and is a pain to get into tight cases.
 
I agree with everyone. Unless you really need it to be portable get the Shuttle setup. Don't get me wrong, the 12" iBooks are great. We just got one, but really, it is not a desktop replacement in any way. Load that Shuttle up with at least 1GB and pair with a nice Monitor...

Alex
 
cool, Thanks everyone! I've made my decision! Please feel free to suggest a different setup or change any hardware...


Shuttle SB75S Limited Ed. (pretty slick check it out)
P4 2.8E Prescott
1 gig Corsair XMX memory
200 or 250 gig SATA Western Digital HDD
Saphire Radeon 9800 Pro



Opinions/Suggestions!
 
I would recommend getting a P4C instead of a Prescott-- see here. They use more power than their predecessors and usually don't perform as well.
 
I'll read into that then.....

I'm mainly wanting a stable machine - rock solid - decent speed, but i crave stability, especially when working in photoshop etc....

I will probably rarely play video games - a little halflife 2, but i'm pirmarily an xbox player....



I've decided to get a Western Digital 74gig Fireball 10k rpm SATA hd - good choice? and use my external drive as my dump.

As for the memory - is there anything specific i should get? There are lots of choices!
 
You could save some $ and pick up a cheaper video card if gaming is not high on your priority list. The nVidia Ti4600 cards can be found for peanuts now and are just fine for most of today's games.

-Ace-
 
Yeps, I am still running on the GeForce Ti4600 right now and I must say, it still plays well. I was playing the Far Cry Demo a few weeks ago and it worked out just fine.

Alex
 
what about specific memory? I would like to get good stuff since I love photoshop.... also what do you think about my selecting the 74 gig 10k rpm fireball hdd?
 
also - with the reccomendations to stay northwood vs. prescott, am i off base? Would I be better off looking into building an AMD - 64 system?

I appologize for all of the questions - I'm just wanting to order my stuff today!
 
bump for memory question - Do i get ECC or non- ECC.....?

The SB75S has "Support Dual Channel ECC DDR400 Memory"

So am i to assume I should buy ECC memory?
 
ECC isn't worth it, less for more money. Stick with non-ECC.

You will definitely want a Northwood "C" Pentium IV. The "E" will burn the socket off the Shuttle motherboard, and give you a slower speed.

Because you are going to switch to a Northwood, put in a little extra and get the 3.0 Pentium IV "C." Overclocks to 3.6-3.7 GHz (although I doubt you will seriously overclock a Shuttle system).

The ATi 9800 Pro should fit just fine in a Shuttle. I have seen Shuttles with 9800 XTs.

By "Fireball" I presume you meant "Raptor" when talking about the WD hard drive. :p
 
If you get a prescott, prepare to bury that shuttle. Are you serious? A prescott in a tiny box like that? Who the hell needs a prescott anyways... Go with all that you said minus the prescott, get a northwood core.

Dont forget a quieter 80mm fan.

Ram, a gig of anything really, corsair 3200 should be fine but im not an intel guy, I dunno about ram for it.

Raptor will be a speed demon and fine.
 
upon further research I learned that the prescott would melt that poor box faster than a snowcone on a warm day....

I do appologize for all of the crazy questions :D

I just want to build a nice machine that will last as long or close to as long as the one i have now.

One last thought - Is buying a shuttle a good idea - or should I build a normal system (coolermaster case, asus board, psu) and all the fixens?
 
Originally posted by optikill
upon further research I learned that the prescott would melt that poor box faster than a snowcone on a warm day....

I do appologize for all of the crazy questions :D

I just want to build a nice machine that will last as long or close to as long as the one i have now.

One last thought - Is buying a shuttle a good idea - or should I build a normal system (coolermaster case, asus board, psu) and all the fixens?

i think unless your a huge pussy and cant lift a normal computer, they are just as portable as a shuttle. so really the only thing your buying a shuttle for is the look. if you like the look and dont care about adding lots of pci cards, multiple hard drives and optical drives, etc. than buy one.
 
that was the reason.... i like the looks and stuff....


I don't frequent lan parties or anything, nor am i a "pussy"
Perhaps I will look into building another "big rig"...

So for comparison of prices anyone got any suggestions for stable mother board?
 
Don't listen to the poster above.

If you are bringing your computer around, you should get the Shuttle. It is, without question, much lighter than some Coolermaster tower.
 
Only you know what's best for you. Shuttles are easier to move around, and take up less space, and maybe look neater. Normal cases are going to be cooler, you can probably overclock something farther in it, they can hold more drives, you can use your own power supply, you have more PCI slots, easier to work in, etc.

Personally, I'd go with a normal case. If you want something small, how about a micro-atx case with a micro-atx motherboard? Small(ish), light, yet more space than a shuttle and easier to work in.

Just my two cents.
 
Back
Top