Complete And Total Bologna...

adam7488 said:
LMFAO

Media: The type of communication used to transmit the marketing message. Most common forms of media are television, radio, newspaper, magazines, direct mail, and billboards.

Media: Forms of mass communication. Newspapers, magazines, direct mail, billboards, bus signs, radio, television and internet are some important media that carry advertising.

Remember jubei, evidence is supposed to SUPPORT your statement. Not reinforce mine. Video game isnt mentioned once, nor is it a form of mass communication.

It, in the near future, may becomea form of media, but as of now..... it isn't.... nice try...

and I do agree, it is well within a publishers reacher to attain this scenario. In fact, I bet if u called them all up right now, they'd jump at the idea.

So changing a soda machine logo is the first step towards a game completely dominated by advertising?

I think not.

American Film is a good example. Advertising before and during the movie.

Back in the day, advertising in a movie was unheard of. Now it takes place before and during, but does it by any means affect the plot of the movie or make the movie any less enjoyable? No.



You are even more of an idiot that I had originally assumed...Read the definitions. In both of those they are listing some of the more common examples of media...here, this is what you should be looking at:

"Media: Forms of mass communication...internet are some important media that carry advertising." (please don't make me find you the definitions of mass communication too :()

"Media: The type of communication used to transmit the marketing message. Most common forms of media are..."

Now, before you respond. Read the post, soak in the post, think to yourself if you have an argument, then post a reply if necessary.

adam7488 said:
I'm not blind or ignoring anything. Just taking something for what it's worth and no more. Even if I was blind??? How would cooperations be reeming me in the ass???

If I have to answer that last question, you'd never understand.
 
Wondernerd said:
This isn't new. Sierra started doing it in 1992 with the popular Liesure Suit Larry and Space Quest games. I don't think the AOL buddy will be a selectable skin in Call of Cthulu or a speed power up will be a pair of whatever the current cool Nike shoe is. It will probably be more like product placement in movies. Like the Sony PDA in Splinter Cell. You know you saw it, they know you saw it.

And wouldn't a game be a Medium since it is a singlur form of media? Or media because it is audio and visual and interactive? I cringe when the twits on the news say medias, but I'm not sure what would apply and my anti-rambling pills have worn off.

Thank you........ this guy is absolutely correct.

In my opinion a video game is medium, NOT MEDIA.
 
adam7488 said:
lol music is media??? no........ radio is media

PLEASE DO ME A FAVOR

read the definition.

What plays on the radio?
music.

who listens to music? millions of people.

Has anyone ever advertised in a song? yes.

"not media, that's a medium"

Umm,
Media is a PLURAL of medium you fucking idiot.
http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=medium

Am I the only one who took, "mass media" in high school?
 
granted, there are exceptions, not every game, has chat. Not every game is based on the internet.... is this hard for u to understand??

is HL2 an internet based , mp game??? nope, cs is however. If u consider the opening credits to a game advertising, feel free. In my opinion the opening credits are developers and publishers taking credit for the creation of the game.
 
every song is media simply becuase one in 50 artists mentions a company or product?
 
People already advertise in their own servers...it's not surprising that corporations would get involved.

Are we forgetting those random server messages that pop-up in most of our favorite games (This server ran by Black-Bag Ops, etc.)
 
adam7488 said:
LMFAO

Media: Forms of mass communication. Newspapers, magazines, direct mail, billboards, bus signs, radio, television and internet are some important media that carry advertising.

Read, comprehend, post.
http://www.childrennow.org/media/video-games/2001/
http://www.mediafamily.org/
http://www.usatoday.com/money/media/2002-12-03-video_x.htm

Sorry, but I think USA Today is a bit more credible than you are. I can say to myself "The sky is pink" and honestly believe it with all my heart. It doesn't change the fact that it's not.

Let me use the Internet once again as an example. Let's take a look at Geocities. Remember now, corporations are out to get MONEY. They could care less about the consumer, as long as the consumer's happy enough to buy the product.

When I first used Geocities in 1995ish... there were no ads what so ever. Guess they paid for bandwidth with investor money ;)

Then, a short time later, they realized "Hey, we can make money with ads."
So, everytime I logged in to update my website, I saw a tiny little banner on the bottom of the screen.

"Hey, we can make more money if the ads are animated"
"Hey, some of our users are making money by putting ads in their website. Let's tell them they can't do that in our TOS and then put an ad in a frame!"
"Hey, we can make more money if the ads pop up!"

It all starts small, and we as consumers gladly bend over and say "Yes, this is for the good of civilization!"

And hey, how's this for "Cheaper games"

Steam

I don't physically own my copy of Half Life 2. I'll never see a paper manual for it, nor a box.
The silver edition made my wallet ~$60 lighter. You'd think that cutting out the publisher, the shipper, the store shelf space, the printers, the editors, the cost of media (Yes, the word has multiple uses!), etc would mean a lower cost for me. Instead, Valve pockets a much larger profit.
 
OMG, not more tampon, and duoche ads!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!








I don't care, we have em on tv why not in games!?
I think during real hot sexy with wifie or gf that someone should step in and say "having that not so fresh feeling?".
 
Stiler said:

While this definition is technically right, it is only when using media as a plural of medium in the strictest sense. Socially, media is most often related to the news/television/etc... When we or whoever used the word originaly was using it in this sense rather than it's strict sense, so we weren't wrong :) The "misnomer" defense becomes even weaker when you look at the english language as a whole. "Bitch" is a female dog, and to use it in reference to a human girl is a misnomer, but the use has gained acceptance in the english language and has become a definition of the word. Altruism, in its strictess sense is one who disregards their own while at the same time doing all they can to improve or prolong the lives of others'. Altruism has since gotten wide usage in philosophy to define anybody who puts others needs and wants above their own and does not necessarily mean to disregard your own life.
 
Like I said in another thread. If your firewall cannot block it without breaking the game. Then return the game to the store you bought it and tell them "the ads do not work with my firewall". Proceed to buy, open, and return the game to every store you can. If merchants get pissed off, they will refuse to cary games that produce a loss in returns.
 
Ashtaka said:
RWhen I first used Geocities in 1995ish... there were no ads what so ever. Guess they paid for bandwidth with investor money
Then, a short time later, they realized "Hey, we can make money with ads."
So, everytime I logged in to update my website, I saw a tiny little banner on the bottom of the screen.

I think it was more along the lines of wanting to stay solvent as investers realized giving a product away for free isn't a good way to make money. So they took their money elsewhere. Corporations are in it to make money. So are investors. If a company(lets randomly pick stealyourlifesavings.com) sells a product, burns through 20 million dollars a day and then brags about how they may start making money in 10 years, right now they just want an IPO so they can be gajillionaires and leave the company to somebody else... My money is going to something that has a little more staying power. So stealyourlifesavings.com flounders and looks for other streams of revenue.
 
Yaaaayyyy!!!! Yet another place where I cannot move without getting more bullshit jammed down my throat. For those who think that this will turn into savings that will be extended to us gamers. I got a nice bridge up on the sale\trade forum. It could be yours if the price is right! And the only thing proven by 19.99 NFL2K5 is how much they are already screwing us over. Get out of fantasyland and take a good look around.
 
This has already started to happen. Look at Tony Hawk Underground 2. There are REAL ads in the game on billboards and such. Granted, the way they implemented it is OK in my opinion. Why? Because the ads are static, don't stream to my computer, and don't track if I spend more time grinding the sneaker ad, or attempt to get a can of soda from the machine.

If I find that a game is streaming ads, I won't buy it. Companies are absolutely out to maximize profit, not satisfy consumers. They know people will pay $50 for a game, so they won't change that price until demand changes. The demand curve determines what a company will charge and how much they will produce.

Look at how games have changed just within the last 5 years. Now, with just about every game I buy, there are child programs that are optional to install, such as GameSpy. I personally believe in a "minimalist" approach on my PC, where I install the absolute minimum to get something to work, but that's because I remember when I had to squeeze every MB out of my hard drive. But publishers, trying to maximize profits, included programs from other companies (who paid them to do so), irregardless of how I or any other consumer felt.

Video games are absolutely a form of media, and now we see that companies are going to try and maximize profit by adding more dynamic content, that they can charge a premium for. The "gamer" demographic is large, and somewhat untapped from a business point of view, so this doesn't surprise me at all. But I don't expect the majority of gamers to actually DO anything about it. And as kids start becoming old enough to purchase games, they'll see it then as normal because it started here.

Hopefully this doesn't become true. But I fear it will.
 
Note that the article on yahoo is a press release and is strongly biased. No one has really mentioned some of the specifics in the article yet. I find the quote “no impact on game play or performance” very difficult to believe. In order to display the advertisement, it will have use system resources such as memory, CPU cycles and bandwidth. Considering that games are the one of the few applications meant to truly stress a computer system, devoting these extra resources to advertising will impact system performance. Exactly how much performance will be affected remains to be seen.

I am really curious as to how the ads will be implemented. From the description, it sounds like it is spyware. I am sure the publishers will do their best to conceal this ‘feature’ from the end-user, conforming to the profile of spyware. Does anyone have a list of games that will be infected?

Advertisers are having difficulty reaching the target demographic mentioned in the article because we have a low opinion of the ethics of advertisers. By actively attempting to use spyware to reach an audience is already wary, these advertisers are displaying extremely aggressive behavior. Judging from the past behavior of online advertisers that deal in spy-ware this opinion is justified, and I am expecting the worst.

Looking at the history of television, advertisements began with a small amount of air time, which gradually grew to the point where it is today. Up until this point, games commanding $60 price tags have been generally of advertising. Given a choice, it seems that people will choose the form of entertainment that has not been saturated with advertising. This seems to be the starting point for advertising in games, and is probably just the tip of the iceberg.
 
Wondernerd said:
I think it was more along the lines of wanting to stay solvent as investers realized giving a product away for free isn't a good way to make money. So they took their money elsewhere. Corporations are in it to make money. So are investors. If a company(lets randomly pick stealyourlifesavings.com) sells a product, burns through 20 million dollars a day and then brags about how they may start making money in 10 years, right now they just want an IPO so they can be gajillionaires and leave the company to somebody else... My money is going to something that has a little more staying power. So stealyourlifesavings.com flounders and looks for other streams of revenue.

Personally, I don't buy all this, we have been using the example of companies who were giving away free things and finally decided to use advertising to make money. Unfortunately the gaming and software industries have been raking people over the coals with their prices for years, they make tons of money every year. It's just another company's way of injecting a plug for their own product in an already economically successful product. It's like me buying a car and being forced to watch an advertisement on my dash every other time I look down the check my speed, forget the bilboards on the sides of highways.
 
Don't worry I am sure there are lawyers who are already readying thier intial briefs.

I don't like it anymore than the next person, I just don't want to see any more erection pill ads then I already do.
 
I cannot believe some of these replies. We have bills running through congress trying to put a stop to the overwhelming barrage of crap that is installed on my computer, snuck into my email, or just outright thrown up in my face, whether I like it or not, but they are going to behave themselves with this one. CMON!
 
This is the most un-f*cking believable pile of bullsh*t i have ever f*cking seen in my g*d d*mn life.

f*ck those f*cking f*ckers.
 
Having Coke machines in the game and things like that can add to realism. That doesn't bother me.

Having adds that change while I am gaming that affect FPS and use CPU time will piss me off.

Taking away the game manuals and shrinking the box, was a move to save space on retail shelves and most importantly to cut production costs to increase profits for the distrubutors. It had nothing to do with us.
 
i wouldn't mind ingame advertizing that much, as long as it wasn't so blatant.

like imagine walkin down the street in a game and seeing a NVidia box in a trash can on the corner :p

from what i remember GTA3 had a lot of advertizing
 
This will suck. I'm wondering why no-one has asked what this will do to a game artistically. The article says it will "have no impact on gameplay or performance," but doesn't say how it will impact the game's mood. Imagine walking through the bloodied martian base in Doom 3, and right as you walk into the room with the giant spider-woman, running screaming and hissing at you, a giant sign behind her is illuminated by your plasma bolts reading "Eat Snacky Smores!"

The article made no reference to exactly HOW and WHERE the ads will be implemented, which means as far as we know, they could be anywhere and everywhere.

Then again, maybe I am overreacting... it's unlikely a scenario as described above would happen. I mean, we put up with the endless amounts of crap in movies and TV, why not in games? Simply because we haven't had to yet. But chances are, the big money corporations will win out over public outcries, and we will have ads. We'll probably get used to it.

But my gut reaction is still "FUCK YOU AND FUCK OFF" to advertisers.
 
Unfortunately the gaming and software industries have been raking people over the coals with their prices for years, they make tons of money every year.

They also lose tons of money every year due to piracy(I know it is copyright infringement and nobody loses anything, and everybody who is infinging intellectual property wouldn't have purchased it anyway, so lets not get into that). You take hyped games like Halo 2, Doom 3, Half Life 2 and so on, and the price will be higher to conteract the percieved losses. They can't raise the price too high, so they look for other ways to increase profit.

You could also say the same for other media. I spend a 100 or so(not sure. I don't ever look at bills) every month for cable. And what do I get? Advertisements. I pay for magazine subscriptions and I get advertisements. They should either reduce the price or give it to me for free for paying them for the privilege of watching herpes commercials while I am eating. I don't like eating pizza and thinking of festering puss dripping sores, I deserve compensation.

It's like me buying a car and being forced to watch an advertisement on my dash every other time I look down the check my speed, forget the bilboards on the sides of highways.

I bet you have a dealer sticker on the back of your car. That is an advertisement for the dealer. I charged a car radio installation place 150 dollars because after they put the radio in, they put a sticker on the car advertising their location. They removed the sticker rather then pay.

In order to display the advertisement, it will have use system resources such as memory, CPU cycles and bandwidth

It could all be done as the game is booting. You wouldn't really notice it there. Soon as you start, the game connects and is told it needs to run coke ads. When the game stops it calls home to the mothership. I do think this is taking the idea of broadband for advantage. There are still millions of the unclean connecting via dial up. I was one of them until a year ago. And it wasn't a price thing, it was a no service thing.

I don't support this idea. Personally, I don't really care if somebody watches my computer use habits. I do care if they install programs on my computer that change the experience. I really hope this is more along the lines of advanced product placement as opposed to the Sign of the Apocolypse.
 
NES version of TMNT had pizza hut logos every frigging where. Even in the hallway of of the apartment building.

What I got ticked off with recently was Mr. Nokia in Disney Skate Adventure (Tony Hawk Clone).

Mr. Nokia sends you on a mission to get ringtones for his Nokia 3600 phone. Not his cellphone, or a nokia phone, but specifically named the model number.

This is a game targeted at highly susceptable children. Humans usually don't build up an immunity to ads until around 12-14. Prior to that understanding, children view it as informative, rather than that they trying to sell you something. Go watch TV with a 4-8 year old and see how many commercials they say "I want that." to.

I fought with BB about taking it back for a month and was finally able to take the GD $50 advertisement back to them after talking to the district manager.
 
I could be wrong, but I'd picture advertising such as a soda machine swapping out textures for a company, or if a game has tv monitors, the ads play on those

then again...I don't online play so I don't really have to worry much ;)

I do feel sorry for those who do though. Don't know how this goes
 
I can just see it now.... "$5/month to disable all in-game ads! Upgrade to Platinum Package for just $5 more and receive a monthly in-game item! Upgrade for an additional $10 to our Diamond Package and receive monthly stat bonuses as well as a monthly in-game item completely ad free!"
 
Netrat33 said:
I could be wrong, but I'd picture advertising such as a soda machine swapping out textures for a company, or if a game has tv monitors, the ads play on those

then again...I don't online play so I don't really have to worry much ;)

I do feel sorry for those who do though. Don't know how this goes

eh?

from reading that it doesn't seem like it's going to be for only "online" games, but for many SP games aswell.

As long as your have a net connection while playing it'll log your i.p., then track the details of the ads, how long you looked at them, which ad, etc.
 
Stiler said:
eh?

from reading that it doesn't seem like it's going to be for only "online" games, but for many SP games aswell.

As long as your have a net connection while playing it'll log your i.p., then track the details of the ads, how long you looked at them, which ad, etc.

Which is why I think most people are upset. Some ads in games, assuming they are static and non-obtrusive, are not horrible especially if they ad to the atmosphere. For example in Max Payne, I would love to see a McDonald's ad on the TV, and then shoot the crap out of it.

But it's when they start taking information in real-time that bugs me. It's just one more thing that has to be sent/recieved, and one more thing that could break and cause problems.
 
Ok, I got a couple of idea's here that were either not touched on so far, or underdeveloped at this point.

1. All online games have a connection speed setting. I would like to postulate that the method of ad delivery is going to be different depending on whether you are 56k, cable, or on a college T1. Also, when set to LAN, I am sure you will operate in off-line mode.

2. Piracy. Can you guys think up a more efficient way to make money off of games that have been pirated? With this system in place, the company profits no matter what. In fact, I would be willing to beleive that at least 50% of all copies of games out there are pirated and that this would put many less successful games into the black which could mean that some well loved licencses could make a comeback, Think for a second about those games you LOVE that got abandoned by the publisher because no NEW people were playing them but still had a LOYAL following playing them in leagues for YEARS after they were published (mechwarrior 4 is five years old and people still play daily) This system would provide an incentive for publishers to try to create franchises that would warrant free downloadable content designed strictly to keep you playin the SAME game instead of the current model of planned obsolescence. Heck, I would even go so far as to say that a no monthly fee MMORPG is feasable. It could work briliantly if done right. Picture a cyberpunk mmorpg with targeted ads placed near static spawns...


Go ahead and flame me :) I'm used to it. But... consider this, I am just trying to come up with ways we could benefit from this.
 
In other news... the recent rash of bankruptcy fillings by video game developers seems to be directly linked to an entire lack of sales apparently due to the inclusion of spyware like technologies by startup Massive Incorporated. Though the FCC is investigating, the lead attorney Mr Understater stated that "it appears to be a simple case of asshattery committed by complete fucktards" no word yet on whether or not charges will be filled for gross incompetence.

Good news is I will save a ton because I won't buy any game with this tech, hell I still play the original UT sometimes it's not like new games are any better other than eye candy.
 
This is the email I sent to Steve, just saw the thread on the front page.

I agreee with you on the billboard type thing. I actually rather see real advertising in a game if its well placed. Like in a racing game or billboards in a city. Make the magazines on the ground real magazines, soda cans / machines real brands, office computers really Dell / Gateway / HP, that kind of thing. It makes it all more realistic, to a point. I'd rather see something familiar in a game set in the recent past or future.
I think it will open the door for a lot of abuse if not carefully monitored by the game developers and publishers. English ads in a foreign city would suck, anything in not theme related in a game like Splinter Cell, or an F-1 simulation would just be an obvious advertisement and would detract from the game experience. You wouldn't put a Pepsi add in a Starwars game, you wouldn't put any current advertising in Pirypat. You wouldn't put any advertising in Everquest, World of Warcraft, or any other type of fantasy game.

I'm much more likely to have a positive thought about a Pepsi can on a desk (its kinda cool, and I'll probably get shot standing there zoomed in on it with a scope), than a Pepsi can in a cup holder on a speeder. If they put an out of place add in Splinter Cell I am going to be pissed. Unfortunately these are the types of games that lend themselves to "real" advertising, they have huge audiences, all those kids not watching TV are playing video games.

Put all the advertising you want on objects in the Sims.

Blatant advertising at the begining of the game while it loads, like in a movie theater is tolerable. We have it already with the Nvidia, ATi, developer, and publisher branding now. Blatant advertising between levels is inexcuseable.

[/rant]

 
If the ads in the games are intrusive, I'm sure the crackers will make a fix for it.

If the ads are just "product placement" like in Hollywood movies it won't be "bad", just hella gay. Because then every computer you see in games is going to be a Mac, which is highly unrealistic.

:D
 
One word for you people.

Buffering...

Quit bitching about the defination of media, it's irrelevant to the topic, really. No one knows how this will impact things, but if it's too intrusive there will be backlash. People will either block the ad delivery or not buy the game.

If it doesn't affect game play I'm ok with it, again as long as it's not intrusive. If I see 500 objects with a brand name that's bad, if I see the same number I would expect in that setting it's OK. If I'm in a room in a hospital, I'd expect to see only a couple of items with brand names on them. If I'm in a movie theater, I'd expect a lot more...
 
wood said:
Imagine walking through the bloodied martian base in Doom 3, and right as you walk into the room with the giant spider-woman, running screaming and hissing at you, a giant sign behind her is illuminated by your plasma bolts reading "Eat Snacky Smores!"

There are already a ton of possible ads in Doom3. Even the elevator panel had a beverage advertisement, red cans everywhere, burgers complete with box. They didn't hurt the gameplay, what difference would it make if they replaced those textures with real products? Actually i keep wondering if those ads really are real products (Somebody answer please).

Oh and NFSU had mcdonalds in one of the drift tracks. Makes it more realistic seeing billboards near roads =P

But if somebody makes a hidden character/vehicle/gun that's something like what they did on the pepsi man guy. I'm gonna strangle someone. What can be more lame than a cheat to turn scatterpack missiles into coke cans =P
 
And also.

If publishers and dev's want to know why some people Warez, it's for these type of reasons.


Lame copy protection, that affects the user that actually bought the game and not the pirates.
shorter game length overall.
Price hikes (yea, games aren't already a bit high...)

and now this.

I recently bought sims 2. Installed the game and went to play, BAM "cd emulation software detected, blah blah"

god forbid people actually have burning software on the computer, which we are LEGALLY allowed to own and operate aswell as make a back up of the game, but nooooo we "could" use it for bad things.

All of these together are reasons why piracy is higher then ever, don't they understand that they aren't helping things, but making them worse?

I'd guarntee you if they dropped half that shit, put the prices a tad lower, that they'd see more overall sales and $$$.

I know i'd buy a lot more games from the stores if the prices were lower and i didn't have to deal with bullshit.

A lot of people, like me, no longer buy games from actual stores. If we do it's very rarely. (most recent game i bought was fable, but only because i got it on a deal).

Instead we wait. We wait a few weeks/month after the game came out. then we buy the game, not from the store, but from ebay/half/forums .

The publishers see NONE of this money.
This is a "secondary" market, from the consumers to other consumers.
.
 
Sly said:
There are already a ton of possible ads in Doom3. Even the elevator panel had a beverage advertisement, red cans everywhere, burgers complete with box. They didn't hurt the gameplay, what difference would it make if they replaced those textures with real products? Actually i keep wondering if those ads really are real products (Somebody answer please).

Oh and NFSU had mcdonalds in one of the drift tracks. Makes it more realistic seeing billboards near roads =P

But if somebody makes a hidden character/vehicle/gun that's something like what they did on the pepsi man guy. I'm gonna strangle someone. What can be more lame than a cheat to turn scatterpack missiles into coke cans =P

I don't think anyone is arguing about Static, well placed "fitting" ad's. Which would "realistically" look fine placed where they are. Like seeing a Pepsi vending machine in a modern office building or something.

The problem is out-of-place advertising, "streaming/updating" ad's that will put some kind of load somewhere on things (what about 56kers trying to d/l or play online?).

then the actual logging of your i.p (which to me, is personal info, since it can eventually break down to who you are, etc if they tried to get the info from your isp). Then sending the data of ad "x" looked at for "x" time, etc.
 
I made this for another forum with the same topic ;)

add.jpg


yeh i know should be "Mrs." but im not editing it
 
adam7488 said:
LMFAO

Media: The type of communication used to transmit the marketing message.

Thus if a game is used to transmit a marketing message, it becomes media. Your own words.

Thanks for playing.
 
Back
Top