Comparison's between X800XT PE and 6800U

smcgee85

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 23, 2004
Messages
174
Tell me if I'm wrong.

I've noticed two things about comparison's between the X800XT PE and the 6800U.

1. Their not comparisons between the the X800XT PE and the 6800U. Their comparisons between the X800PRO and the 6800U many times. I thought that the 6800U was supposed to be the equivalent to the X800XT PE.

2. People keep saying that with Nvidia's new drivers the 6800U will pass the X800XT PE. They say it almost as if ATI isn't coming out with another driver for the X800XT.

These are two things that I've seen in reviews, forums, etc over and over again that have really gotten on my nerves. Is it just me or have other people noticed too?

Smcgee85
 
It's true. As far as the driver issue. Nvidia has a lot of headroom to work with in the 6800 series. The X800s aren't anything more than the 9800s with 12 or 16 pipes and higher core/memory speeds. I don't feel that ATI will be able to get as much of an improvement with their drivers as Nvidia will with the 6800s. I could be wrong and it will be a $500 mistake if I am... lol :eek:
 
StArWaRrIoR said:
It's true. As far as the driver issue. Nvidia has a lot of headroom to work with in the 6800 series. The X800s aren't anything more than the 9800s with 12 or 16 pipes and higher core/memory speeds. I don't feel that ATI will be able to get as much of an improvement with their drivers as Nvidia will with the 6800s. I could be wrong and it will be a $500 mistake if I am... lol :eek:

lol

Smcgee85
 
Once again tell me if I'm wrong.

The only diff between the X800XT PE and the 6800U besides clock speeds is the SM 3 stuff. If I'm right that won't even take effect until games support it. People are claiming 30-50% increases on games that don't support it. Which means for now, ATI should have about the same headroom as Nvidia.

Smcgee85
 
smcgee85 said:
Once again tell me if I'm wrong.

The only diff between the X800XT PE and the 6800U besides clock speeds is the SM 3 stuff. If I'm right that won't even take effect until games support it. People are claiming 30-50% increases on games that don't support it. Which means for now, ATI should have about the same headroom as Nvidia.

Smcgee85
It only takes a couple weeks to add SM3.0 support to a SM2.0 game.

Scott
 
sonyman said:
It only takes a couple weeks to add SM3.0 support to a SM2.0 game.

Scott
Um. No.

If by support you mean work with the SM 3.0, then yes a month or so to change/patch the game. But for a game to be based on SM 3.0 and fully utilize it, try not until 06'
 
Why, Farcry works perfectly with it. Nice displacement mapping; some people were definetly having too much fun with that :)
 
It doesn't take long to 'patch' a game to SM3. Honestly, why did they even name it SM3, it's more like SM 2.1.

As for the drivers, it's true, and if you don't like it tough. Compare the performance parity between the 60.72s-61.45s and the 4.5s-4.7s and you'll notice Nvidia has done alot more for performance than their counterpart [granted that they HAD to since ATI cards were beating them rather thourougly at launch]. If that's not enough, compare the original dets that the FX5800 launched with and the later 50xx Dets...there was a huge performance increase. The FX line went from being complete and total shit to something that was actually almost competetive. They did this with crap hardware. So the question practically begs itself...what can they do with good hardware like the NV40. Guess we're going to find out soon hopefully.
 
Yea people have already forgot what a turn around nVidia did with their 59XX cores around last 03. nVidia was having alot of trouble keeping up with ATI's 9800 pro and XT until they released some new drivers that fixed alot of their DX9 issues. After that the 5950 was every bit as fast as the 9800XT, especially at 1600x1200. And the 5900XT owned the mid-range market upon its release.

If you will look up some of those large scale ATI driver comparison reviews floating around on the net you will see that for the most part ATI has had very few huge performance boosts come from driver updates. The last review like that i saw at Madshrimps shown like a 2-3 fps increase at best from each driver update over a scale of like 5-6 releases.

The 60.72 -> 61.34 release by nVidia is showing as much as 30fps and MORE increases in certain games such as Painkiller and UT2003. And most of the other games are seeing AT LEAST 5-10 fps gains. And this is just the beginning. nVidia will most likely lay down another driver update soon that will increase the performance gap even further.

The 6800 ultra has a ton of headroom if you have a CPU to keep up with it.
 
Yup, and all these drivers are still 'beta', we still haven't gone from one offical NV40 driverset to another. Nvidia must have hired leather-clad domimatrixes equiped with chain whips and set them loose on their driver team.
 
Vagrant Zero said:
Nvidia must have hired leather-clad domimatrixes equiped with chain whips and set them loose on their driver team.

lol :p
thats a interesting way to put it. but i agree. this is like the 5th new driver rumored or released in the past week or so lol.
 
X800's are more of a 9600XT with 12-16 pipes and 256bit GDDR3, since the core is a low-k .13 micron. and the 9800's are .15 micron.
 
Any ideas? This thread is slipping downward and I'm not done with it. lol

Smcgee85
 
It's been talked to death, there is a lot to be determined. You are in a state of limbo, as most of us are.
 
smcgee85 said:
I would have to say there is something weird with this review. In almost every review I've read including the hardocp review the x800xt pe beats the 6800U 9 times out of 10 by a pretty good margin.

How much headroom do you think Nvidia has? Enough to pass the X800XT PE?

Smcgee85


I noticed that the Ultra only pulled ahead when AA and AF were not used.... who here doesn't want some AA and AF....?!?
 
There's also the possibility that future NVIDIA driver updates will have minimal impact on performance. It's very hard to speculate about the future and at this point it's little more than wishful thinking. The only way to be certain is to wait and see.
 
smcgee85 said:
I would have to say there is something weird with this review. In almost every review I've read including the hardocp review the x800xt pe beats the 6800U 9 times out of 10 by a pretty good margin.

the hardocp review was like 10 or so drivers ago ;)
 
smcgee85 said:
I would have to say there is something weird with this review. In almost every review I've read including the hardocp review the x800xt pe beats the 6800U 9 times out of 10 by a pretty good margin.

How much headroom do you think Nvidia has? Enough to pass the X800XT PE?

Smcgee85

The [H]OCP review was done with the 60.72 drivers. We're currently up to 61.45 with the 61.5xs being circulated around the devs and tier-one people.

Edit: Whoops :eek: didn't notice there was a page 2.
 
Vagrant Zero said:
Nvidia must have hired leather-clad domimatrixes equiped with chain whips and set them loose on their driver team.

Or they could just be sly enough to realize that holding performance increases back from the consumer generates talk about their cards and helps sawy them from buying the competition
 
i wish hard would do a review with the so called 50 % performance increase drivers


smcgee85
 
im guessin they will do a review of 6800U vs x800XT-PE again when we get WHQL'ed drivers or somthin heh. might be a while ;x
 
SnakEyez187 said:
Or they could just be sly enough to realize that holding performance increases back from the consumer generates talk about their cards and helps sawy them from buying the competition

Or they could live in this dimension where work = power * TIME. But you're right, it makes perfect sense to cripple the performance of your product. Shame on you Nvidia.


...Next.
 
It shouldn't be hard for nvidia to get whql drivers like Ati do all of the time. I always associated whql with quality certified. With as much hacking on drivers coming from ati and nvidia. I see this as a good thing. As I am sure the nvidiots will as soon as they get one out that's whql and beating ATi.
 
Vagrant Zero said:
Or they could live in this dimension where work = power * TIME. But you're right, it makes perfect sense to cripple the performance of your product. Shame on you Nvidia.


...Next.

That has actually been thought of by many people many times along the days of nvidia cards. It was just too convienient that as soon as they needed power to bypass a competing product *BAM* magic. And as said before, there is nothing magical about driver programming. It's like an ace up the sleeve, I am sure Ati does it as well. Don't make it seem like it's impossible, you will only be fooling yourself.
 
for all we know as soon as the magority starts believing nvidia is winning th battle ati could pull the rabbit out of the hat and increase their performance by 50 %
 
so which way is direct x leaning on this one
are them an ati still big buddies
i guess the next version of dx could tip the boat either way
 
I personally kinda dont like AA, it seems like things have a little blur to them (to me).

I like the crisp lines on a nice 1600x1200 display with no AA.

Unless you have a flat panel that only has native 1024x768 or1280x1024, etc. I dont see why you would use a lower res with AA than a higher res. with out. (assuming about similar performance)

Granted some people would like to play at 1600x1200 with 4aa/8af. but I've never been too fond of AA. I do love high quality AF.

PS. back to the subject. Nvida's 6800 should have a lot more headroom for driver improvements. Look at their track record, they have always refined their drivers and added considerable performance to new generation cores. ATI can add performance also, but I think most of it has been already tweaked out, since this core is basically a 9600/9800 core with more pipes.
 
MeTaSpARKs said:
I noticed that the Ultra only pulled ahead when AA and AF were not used.... who here doesn't want some AA and AF....?!?

Me. On my mobility 9700.

But if I were to pay $500 for a video card I should be able to turn up everything to the max in every game that comes out in the next year and still play everything without a stutter(which I would be able to do with the x800XT PE, not sure about the 6800U)
 
Once again tell me if I'm wrong.
The only diff between the X800XT PE and the 6800U besides clock speeds is the SM 3 stuff. If I'm right that won't even take effect until games support it. People are claiming 30-50% increases on games that don't support it. Which means for now, ATI should have about the same headroom as Nvidia.

Don't forget that the Nvidia part

1. Blocks a PCI slot

2. Needs 2 molex connectors.

3. Needs an expensive power supply.

4. Uses a Noisy Leaf blower for cooling.
 
Back
Top