Comparing different Wireless business solutions?

jnick

2[H]4U
Joined
Sep 25, 2004
Messages
2,888
We have been having some MAJOR networking issues at my job over the past 4 months. I work as the "Senior Systems Tech/Systems Admin" for a college. Since the start of the semester the wireless in the residence halls has been...non-existent. Constant signal drops, slow as shit...it was completely unreliable. Since this has come to our attention, we have been full throttle on getting it fixed. Our Director and CIO brought in Cisco and MERU networks to put in their best wireless solution for a trial period in the two buildings which had the most complaints (they also happen to be the largest!).

However, by the middle of December, we have to make a decision on which vendor to go with so we can get the rest of the Residence Halls wired up by the start of the Spring semester.

Therefore, my CIO came to me asking how can we test the two solutions to find which truly gives us the best wireless solution. We have already went to the buildings, hosted an event and has feedback from a bunch of students. They all say their wireless is now "perfect". So here we are hearing each vendor state that they have the best product followed by the students in the dorms stating that the wireless is 1000x better.

Are there any tests we can put each "building" through to see which solution is the better of the two?

The CIO was thinking of doing some sort of Gaming tournament using Xboxes or PS3s all on wireless and see which building holds up the best through the game play. However, while this may be a good PR move I don't know if it will give us the data we need.

Any suggestions are appreciated!

Thanks!
 
Use netflow/snmp to actually chart the network usage? Anything else is purely anecdotal as far as evidence goes.

If the site surveys are done properly along with proper capacity planning either vendor's equipment will likely be sufficient. Other factors to consider are: which vendor is your staff more familiar with, what are the long-term costs (maintenance contracts and the like), initial deployment costs, etc, etc...

There's a lot more to choosing a good solution beyond which one gives you the best ping for WoW (or whatever).
 
Thanks for the suggestion. I'll definitely present that option to our CIO.

Any other ideas on comparing the two?
 
If price isn't an issue, I would be more at ease going with Cisco. But as for testing the two.. I'm clueless.

I'd be curious to see what would happen if you unplugged a WAP randomly and see how it effects coverage. But that's not really a "standard" to test, just a curiosity test.

 
how are these access points going to be secured? Are they going to be hidden from students? or secured in a way that the drunks can't screw with them? unplug shit, pull them off the wall, etc, etc?
 
In case you haven't considered it have a look at aruba networks wireless stuff too.
 
I keep hearing good reviews about the Mikrotik and their wireless. Very similar to Cisco's stuff. Maybe you can ask Greg Sowell (http://gregsowell.com/) since he does the Mikrotik University now (http://mikrotikuniversity.com/) and probably welcomes questions.

I'm curious to know what devices/setup your CIO ended up testing from Cisco or MERU Networks. Might be best to just use Cisco for ease of management and support. Get support on your controller(s) and just buy a new access point when it dies.
 
If price isn't an issue, I would be more at ease going with Cisco. But as for testing the two.. I'm clueless.

I'd be curious to see what would happen if you unplugged a WAP randomly and see how it effects coverage. But that's not really a "standard" to test, just a curiosity test.


Not a bad idea. Especially should an AP go down, we can test how each solution will handle it.

how are these access points going to be secured? Are they going to be hidden from students? or secured in a way that the drunks can't screw with them? unplug shit, pull them off the wall, etc, etc?

They are not "secured" to my knowledge other than typical screws. We've had wireless on campus for a LONG time. We actually were one of the first college's with it, at least in NY. Since then, we have yet to have a damaged AP from students, which in all honesty is shocking!

I keep hearing good reviews about the Mikrotik and their wireless. Very similar to Cisco's stuff. Maybe you can ask Greg Sowell (http://gregsowell.com/) since he does the Mikrotik University now (http://mikrotikuniversity.com/) and probably welcomes questions.

I'm curious to know what devices/setup your CIO ended up testing from Cisco or MERU Networks. Might be best to just use Cisco for ease of management and support. Get support on your controller(s) and just buy a new access point when it dies.

I can find out. All I know is we have Catalysts 2975 for evaluation from cisco. As far as the APs, I don't have a model.
 
Back
Top