Comparing 2 EVGA Geforce 9800 gt cards

courtney01

Gawd
Joined
Nov 25, 2008
Messages
619
1. EVGA (the link is for a 1GB card, but I'm interested in the 512MB version. All the other specs should be the same between the two): http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130391
2. EVGA: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130435

I can't find much info on #2 on the web, so I was wondering if anybody has experience with that and would be able to help me compare it to #1 (aside from the obvious dual slot cooling aspect). Any suggestions or things I should be aware of like known issues for either of these cards? I game very infrequently, so even though I know these cards aren't top of the line, they will be more than enough for me, and anything I do with them will probably look great to me since I don't get hung up about low or high fps. What I am interested in is which would be the quieter card (if there is any noticeable difference, since the one person who reviewed #2 on newegg said it was quiet) and if there is a noticeable performance difference between them.
 
You should be good to go with the 512MB card, it is a good card and they look identical apart from the ram. I have the 8800gt, which everybody says is almost the same and it is quiet. If you are not doing much graphic intensive stuff it will serve you well and won´t heat up causing the fan to spin at 100%.
 
You should be good to go with the 512MB card, it is a good card and they look identical apart from the ram. I have the 8800gt, which everybody says is almost the same and it is quiet. If you are not doing much graphic intensive stuff it will serve you well and won´t heat up causing the fan to spin at 100%.

Just so I don't misunderstand, you're saying I should get #1?
 
I bought the evga 9800 gt dual slot cooled card yesterday. But I just found out that it only has a 1 year warranty period (2 years if I register it). I've been looking exclusively for cards with lifetime warranties, and I thought all EVGA products were lifetime, but I misread their terms and conditions and it turns out only some of their products have it. Should I just keep the card I ordered or cancel it and pick one of the cards with a lifetime warranty?
 
If you want quiet and have some room in your case, get an Accelero S1 Rev 2. My XFX 9800GT (looks the same as your last link) ran at 60°C idle and 75°C at load with the stock 1-slot cooler. With a BIOS edit, it got down to 55°C for a bit.

With a passive S1 installed (just the side case fan blowing on it), it idled at 45°C and got around 58°C under load. With a slim 100mm fan on the S1, it's now 40°C and 48°C, and it's still quieter than stock.

The biggest problem with the S1 is that it's big. It will take up the slot next to your video card (like a 2-slot stock cooler would). If you want to put a fan on it (their 2x80mm Turbo Module or a generic slim fan), that'll take another slot. If you use a regular case fan, it would take up about a slot and a half for just the fan. The S1 is also wide; it sticks out a couple inches past the top of your card. If you have a narrow case, it may not fit. In my Cooler Master RC-690, I had to take the plastic trim piece off the S1 and the wire grille off my side case fan for it to fit.

Also, the S1 is dumping heat into your case. If you have poor airflow, it won't work as well. A 2-slot stock cooler will exhaust the hot air outside the case. The S1 does come with a vented slot cover to use, so you can aim your fan to direct the exhaust out the back, but it won't be completely channeled out the back like a 2-slot stocker does.
 
Back
Top