Comeback for PCI?

King of Heroes

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 26, 2008
Messages
2,006
Was looking over the specs for new P43/P45 motherboards and noticed that both the MSI P45 Neo3-FR and the Gigabyte GA-EP43-DS3R going to be packing 4 PCI slots each. Were the complaints about lack of PCI really that bad? I assumed people had just accepted it and started moving over to PCI-E. Or is this principally for businesses, professionals and the like that may still have some critical PCI devices lying around? Even then, 4 seems like alot to me...
 
Everything business/professional has been PCIe or PCI-X (legacy) for a long time now. Only thing left in the PCI arena is consumer products. Sounds like a typo or a way to cut corners...
 
alot of devices arent on PCIe yet or there is no need for it like sound cards, tv tuners , modems and other items...

why should people buy something new when they dont need it just for a new slot.
 
Sound cards, modems, and TV tuners are all available on PCIe simply because people desire to move away from an aging bus simply because there's is a newer solution. PCIe was actually first deployed to network adapters...too bad PCIe x1 is slower than PCI 2.2 huh?
 
Sound cards, modems, and TV tuners are all available on PCIe simply because people desire to move away from an aging bus simply because there's is a newer solution. PCIe was actually first deployed to network adapters...too bad PCIe x1 is slower than PCI 2.2 huh?

For all intensive purposes it isn't. Though PCI v2.2 is capable of 66MHz signaling most PCI devices are legacy devices that are 33MHz and 32bit. They are only capable of 133MB a second transfer rates compared to 250MB of PCI-Express x1. Lets' not forget that PCI-Express is a serial bus architecture and isn't sharing bandwidth as PCI does. Also a PCI v2.2 device is going to be 3.3v while most PCI cards are 5v. PCI v2.2 requires the device to be 66MHz, 32bit and requires 3v signaling in order to be complaint. If there is nothing else being shared on the PCI bus then the device can theoretically operate at 533MB a second.

Source here.
 
I agree in general but that P45 board he spec'ed out has very little on the PCI bus, definitely allowing it to exceed 250. A lot of older boards have integrated sound, network, ide, etc on PCI but newer chipsets have all gone PCIe.
 
With my new board (Gigabyte GA-MA770-DS3) I am overjoyed with it having no less than 4 PCIe x1 slots and two PCI. Two PCI slots is enough for my purposes (and I imagine for most people), while leaving plenty of room for expansion as PCIe cards become more plentiful and cheaper.
 
Since they started putting Sound Blaster X-Fi cards in PCI-Express I've had no need to have PCI slots anymore.
 
it's true that some X-Fi cards are now on PCIe, but not all of them, especially including the Prelude. with that said, a sound card is about the only thing i'd be willing to buy in PCI form. i don't have any old PCI devices laying around, let alone any i'd actually want to use, but i'm sure some people do. with HDTV being what it is, i wouldn't be willing to buy a TV card on PCI. modem... isn't that an exhibit at the museum of natural history? :D

possible explanations for boards with so many PCI slots:

marketing psychology: i certainly can't speak for anyone else, but when i see a mid-high end motherboard that's missing an expansion port (totaling 6 instead of 7), there's a little voice in my head that says, "i understand that adding that last port might make your design more difficult, but you've got engineers, you've got an R&D budget... FIX IT!"

the lemming effect: sure, i've never used more than 3 ports on a motherboard, and i can't see using 7 for a home system. but, if it were between two boards from equally reputable companies, and one had empty space for expansion ports whereas the other had PCI slots... i'd probably go with the later. it seems possible to me that some of the manufacturers out there are loathe to remove these ports. i'm sure Biostar doesn't want to be the only guy on the block with only 4 or 5 expansion ports on a standard ATX mobo.

spare parts: this is the same theory i had about gigabyte's iRAM. if you've got a bunch of spare PCI slots in laying around, and slapping them on lower-end boards won't appreciably increase the cost to manufacture them, then why not? better than simply writing it off as a loss.

simplicity of manufacture: this is where i'm being much more speculative, but it seems like it'd be much easier to fab a PCB with 4 PCI slots and 3 PCIe slots than fewer PCI and more PCIe. i might well be wrong here. this doesn't mean mATX boards would be simpler to produce as well, since all the other circuitry needs to fit on a smaller PCB.

so, just some speculation... english speakers and others using the roman alphabet still use QWERTY keyboards for the most part, despite the fact that the layout was patented in 1874 and designed to be difficult to use.
 
Meh I like PCI slots. I don't really want to buy a new soundcard just because a slot changed if I happen to still be happy with my old one. My PhysX card is still PCI and is as important now as ever with support taking off. I wouldn't want to have to replace my PCI SCSI card with a PCI-E one just for the one 15k scsi drive that I still use or have to stop using the drive either. I got my P35-DS3R specifically because it had 3 slots; I wish it had 4.
 
I've got two Geforce GTX 280's in SLI as well as an LSI MegaRAID 8308ELP SAS/SATA RAID Controller that is a PCI-Express x4 card. I've only got one PCI slot and I'd just as easily use a PCI-Express X-Fi instead. Right now I'm using onboard audio which has been ok for me thus far.

Needless to say PCI isn't important to me at all.
 
The reason PCI is still around as much as it is, is most likely due to market inertia.
That is, PCI, let's be honest, is pretty damn good. In fact, it's good enough for the VAST amount of users. It's what they are used to and comfortable with. IF you just up and changed, many people would ask why there were so few/no PCI slots.

Now, enthusiasts are different, as we want the newest, fastest and best. But for the average joe, he will never see the difference in performance, just that is new, different and scary...

I still have people come in and ask for "those new duo cored processors" (No, there's no tpyo there)
 
I seem to remember ISA slots hanging around for a while too. I even got some not too old Socket 462 mainboards with ISA slots on them. Now that is old tech.
 
I seem to remember ISA slots hanging around for a while too. I even got some not too old Socket 462 mainboards with ISA slots on them. Now that is old tech.

Yeah ISA died way past its' prime.
 
Heh, Isa slots bring back memories, most notably some idiot PC shop owner whom was having a discussion with a customer about a new sound card the customer wanted, the owner said its a no go since your pci slots are filled with a video card and a modem and their would be no room for a sound card, but he says, I have this external thingymajig that only costs X amount and will do the job perfect instead.

I just happened to be behind the customer and looked into his now opened pc and saw an empty Isa slot and I pipped up, ah but wouldnt an Isa soundcard not do the job, Pc shop owner looks at me like I have the rabies and he has the shotgun cure and then he shits himself into answering " ummmm, no that wouldnt work either" :) I just looked away.

I didnt say another word, I ended up buying a pack of DVD's and left and never went back :)

I think Pc shop dude never had any Isa sound cards and instead of trying to order one for him, which he used to do for ppl, he used to order many parts if they werent in stock, he tried to sell him a useless external piece of shit that probably cost 10 times as much as an isa card.

But I still wonder today how an isa soundcard wouldnt work in a isa slot :confused::D > ninja edit with double backflip and headbutt.
 
Since they started putting Sound Blaster X-Fi cards in PCI-Express I've had no need to have PCI slots anymore.

Creative will have you believe that WoW sounds much better with a pcie XFi than with a pci XFi, only 1 or 2 years after they explicitly said that the pcie interface makes no difference in the sound quality at all. That was when everyone was moaning that creative should make a pcie xfi.

Creative sure are an amzing company to make sound, sound better from pci to pcie, bunch of geniuses. :)
 
Creative will have you believe that WoW sounds much better with a pcie XFi than with a pci XFi, only 1 or 2 years after they explicitly said that the pcie interface makes no difference in the sound quality at all. That was when everyone was moaning that creative should make a pcie xfi.

Creative sure are an amzing company to make sound, sound better from pci to pcie, bunch of geniuses. :)

I never thought the PCI-Express versions of the card would sound better than the PCI versions. However now that they offer a PCI-Express version I see no reason to go PCI anymore. I'm not saying people should dump their PCI sounds cards. Not at all. However if for some reason you are changing motherboards or building a new system you don't have to bend overe backwards to keep that PCI sound card as now you have other options.
 
actually creative explanation was that PCI-E had a much higher latency than PCI

I actually don't get creative , that they aren't doing research to make better, cheaper (doesn't have to, but hey) soundcards / api / software . Just because they think they are the best...

No more creative for me, creative labs is an insult to the meaning of creativity and innovation
 
I never thought the PCI-Express versions of the card would sound better than the PCI versions. However now that they offer a PCI-Express version I see no reason to go PCI anymore. I'm not saying people should dump their PCI sounds cards. Not at all. However if for some reason you are changing motherboards or building a new system you don't have to bend overe backwards to keep that PCI sound card as now you have other options.

Dude, I knew you didnt think that, I just posted that because thats what creative said, their is a link to it on the forums, something about WoW sounding soooooo much better with their pcie XFi's, I didnt think for one second you bought it because you thought it might sound better when we both know that probably the only difference between pci and pcie is latency, I was basically pointing out how when creative only had pci xfis on the market they said their was no need for pcie, now that they have pcie on the market its a case of " WoW sounds soooo much better through pcie" when earlier they said pcie wouldnt do jack.

I would go pcie for a soundcard if and when I buy another, cuz all meh pci slots are filled up and its about bloody time shit came out for empty pcie slots, but I just couldnt force myself to go creative again, pcie or no pcie, if I was buying another xfi it would have to be Auzentech just for their driver support, something that creative doesnt have.
 
Dude, I knew you didnt think that, I just posted that because thats what creative said, their is a link to it on the forums, something about WoW sounding soooooo much better with their pcie XFi's, I didnt think for one second you bought it because you thought it might sound better when we both know that probably the only difference between pci and pcie is latency, I was basically pointing out how when creative only had pci xfis on the market they said their was no need for pcie, now that they have pcie on the market its a case of " WoW sounds soooo much better through pcie" when earlier they said pcie wouldnt do jack.

I would go pcie for a soundcard if and when I buy another, cuz all meh pci slots are filled up and its about bloody time shit came out for empty pcie slots, but I just couldnt force myself to go creative again, pcie or no pcie, if I was buying another xfi it would have to be Auzentech just for their driver support, something that creative doesnt have.

One thing I've noticed is that Creative quits updating drivers on their legacy hardware really fast. I'll keep a Creative card, and then I'll start to have problems with it after about a year and a half to two years, and then it won't work right with some game and I'll go out and buy a new card and suddenly all is right with the universe.

In short, Creative's driver support sucks ass.
 
In short, Creative's driver support sucks ass.


I hear you loud n clear Dan, as someone already said, Creative got to the top in their niche and decided that since they are at the top that they can stop trying.

I dont know if they have numptee's for a software team, or if they have a "who gives a fuk if our product is shit, the fools will still buy our product because they need EAX" attitude and a "we wont release new drivers for our products because it costs us money to make and test new drivers when we can be having huge beer lunches and strippers with said driver support cash"

After the Fiasco with that dude who haxed creatives and auzentechs drivers to make better drivers with unlocked features which creative deliberately locked so they could exploit us yet further, I think that will have repercussions that will only be felt in a year or so's time, especially now that some great new sound cards are on the market from new sound card companies, creatives time of lording it over us mere mortals and not giving a flying fuck about us is slowly coming to an end, Vista was the start, then that dude who made his own drivers and now good soundcards from companies who werent in the sound game before, slowly but surely, creative will have to adapt and get inline or go the way of Ageia.
 
I hear you loud n clear Dan, as someone already said, Creative got to the top in their niche and decided that since they are at the top that they can stop trying.

I dont know if they have numptee's for a software team, or if they have a "who gives a fuk if our product is shit, the fools will still buy our product because they need EAX" attitude and a "we wont release new drivers for our products because it costs us money to make and test new drivers when we can be having huge beer lunches and strippers with said driver support cash"

After the Fiasco with that dude who haxed creatives and auzentechs drivers to make better drivers with unlocked features which creative deliberately locked so they could exploit us yet further, I think that will have repercussions that will only be felt in a year or so's time, especially now that some great new sound cards are on the market from new sound card companies, creatives time of lording it over us mere mortals and not giving a flying fuck about us is slowly coming to an end, Vista was the start, then that dude who made his own drivers and now good soundcards from companies who werent in the sound game before, slowly but surely, creative will have to adapt and get inline or go the way of Ageia.

I think that Creative's hardware has always been decent, but the software just gets worse all the time.
 
agreed, its the software and the time it takes them to release new software. I have a feeling that unless thousands upon thousands of ppl complain to them about problems with one set of drivers, then until then they wont release new ones, only when ppl complain to creative do they start to think about takin action, I cant understand why when they release a new product that is being touted as the best soundcard to hit the shelves for years, why do they continue to sit on their hands and do nothing instead of trying to keep refining their software so that the product gets even better and that along can and will push up sales big time, yet they refuse to work like that and are content to have one of the shittiest names/reputation in the business., it astounds me, if only I could run a profitable business like that :)
 
One thing I've noticed is that Creative quits updating drivers on their legacy hardware really fast. I'll keep a Creative card, and then I'll start to have problems with it after about a year and a half to two years, and then it won't work right with some game and I'll go out and buy a new card and suddenly all is right with the universe.

In short, Creative's driver support sucks ass.
Same story with anything produced by EA Games. After its prime is past, so is support.
 
All I can say is any future expansion card I buy will be PCIe. I tend to get 3-4 years of life out of sound cards and other devices, so I certainly don't want to paint myself in a corner buying a PCI card.

I remember when I was purchasing a board for an Athlon XP however many years ago and was obsessing over boards that had 6 PCI slots. Neither then or now have I ever used that many expansion slots on a motherboard. So the fact that they're tossing all those PCI slots back onto boards for old time's sake seems to be a step backwards to me. Two PCI and 3 PCIe slots, save the one for a graphics card, should be an ideal combination for most system builders, IMHO.
 
actually creative explanation was that PCI-E had a much higher latency than PCI

I actually don't get creative , that they aren't doing research to make better, cheaper (doesn't have to, but hey) soundcards / api / software . Just because they think they are the best...

No more creative for me, creative labs is an insult to the meaning of creativity and innovation


Creative's true deffinition for latency is their driver development. I was still waiting to try Vista SP1 in combination with my Sound Blaster Audigy SE (p17.sys driver not SP1 compatible) when I finally upgraded.

Interesting how the latest boards do support SP1 though.
 
There are plenty of boards with few or no PCI slots. It's nice that MSI and Gigabyte build a few boards with more PCI slots for the few people who want/need them.

In my case, I'm building a MythTV system and want four tuner cards. The best tuner card value for me was the Kworld 115 PCI card. So I needed a minimum of four PCI slots to install the tuner cards in the backend server. If there was a comparably priced PCIe tuner card, I would have needed a MB with four or more PCIe x1 slots, which is not all that easy to find either.

There is even a P45 Gigabyte board with 5 PCI slots, but it only has 4 SATA channels, so I went with the MSI P45 neo3-FR which has four PCI slots and 8 SATA channels. Both of them have one each PCIe x1 and PCIe x16 slots.

Unfortunately, the MSI board does not have IEEE 1394. Their website lists it as an option, but I've never found anyone selling the version which includes it. On the board I bought from Newegg the spot for the IEEE 1394 chip, JMB381, is not populated and the rear connector is not present. I think the version with IEEE1394 installed would be P45 Neo3-FIR instead of FR.
 
alot of devices arent on PCIe yet or there is no need for it like sound cards, tv tuners , modems and other items...

why should people buy something new when they dont need it just for a new slot.

Simply for progress. ;) Its OK. Change is good. You can let go... :p
 
Change isn't always good, as often the change isn't need or shows no benefit to the past, at least not right away.

if it aint broke, dont fix it!
 
One thing I haven't seen mentioned is that just because a board has that many slots doesn't mean someone has to use them all.

With the way people are with cabling and cooling options, it's nice to have options on where to put different cards. Especially with my TV tuner cards, I don't like to pack them too close to my sound card and video cards. With two slot boards, everything is crammed together. With 4-5 slot boards I can space my cards out how I want.
 
Something to remember for the business side of things are the RAID cards. Some PCI RAID cards ran between 1k and 2k. People are not willing throw that setup away just because there s a slightly faster version. Not to mention the people that spend that kind of money aren't going to want to temp fate and upgrade that setup in fear of loosing data.

Sound cards, network cards etc to the Consumer are not a big deal to replace. In a production environment it is a catastrophe as its almost guaranteed the new stuff will not work the same and require new software to figure out etc. Time lost on fixing / configuring new cards is money lost.
 
Something to remember for the business side of things are the RAID cards. Some PCI RAID cards ran between 1k and 2k. People are not willing throw that setup away just because there s a slightly faster version. Not to mention the people that spend that kind of money aren't going to want to temp fate and upgrade that setup in fear of loosing data.

Sound cards, network cards etc to the Consumer are not a big deal to replace. In a production environment it is a catastrophe as its almost guaranteed the new stuff will not work the same and require new software to figure out etc. Time lost on fixing / configuring new cards is money lost.

Most corporations are going to use pre-built boxes(Dell, HP, etc.), I don't see them transferring over older legacy RAID cards to new systems. If they want higher end drives and drive controllers, they'll order these things with the new systems. I've been in IT for 12 years and I've never transfered hardware from old machines to newer ones and I've done server replacements for a multi-tude of companies. Lets' also not forget that most of your higher end server boards are going to have PCI-X slots and expensive PCI-X RAID controllers. Those are still prevalent in server systems today. However no one will be using a PCI-X card in a PCI slot in that type of enviroment as they'll take a huge performance hit. As for high end PCI cards, well there haven't been any in quite some time.

There is no reason to buy PCI cards today unless you need something really specialized that isn't available in newer bus types. I'd wager that most devices are so it shouldn't be something anyone should seriously worry about.
 
Back
Top