Comcast To Pay $16M For Blocking P2P Traffic

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Comcast has agreed to pay out $16 million for blocking P2P traffic but the company has still not admitted to any wrong doing. The case will be finalized in June.

Specifically, Comcast was subject to a heated class-action lawsuit elicited by irate customers for blocking P2P file-sharing packets, in particular BitTorrent, in 2007 and 2008. At that time, Comcast denied accusations that it was responsible for slowing down or otherwise impeding BitTorrent, but eventually conceded that it had engaged in controversial network "traffic management" techniques in order to free up bandwidth.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
the old 'no contest' plea. yeah, we all know what that really means (GUILTY AS HELL)
 
So who gets to see this money? :rolleyes:
I've unfortunately been a Craptastic customer for 4 years.
 
I would love a piece of that, but I'm sure not a dime will go to the customers inconvenienced by this crap.
 
Lawyers!!!!!
Just another money grab by the lawyers who had no real interest in changing anything.
 
Under the terms of the settlement, affected Comcast customers involved in the lawsuit are to receive damages of up to $16 million - sans attorney's fees - for their extended inability to access Bit Torrent. However, details of the agreement stipulate that each affected customer won't receive more than $16 from the settlement.
Uh so the real winners are the lawyers. Here's the kicker, Comcast will most likely increase rates to cover this "loss."
 
Probably means they will change their services and only offer the faster services if you sign an agreement which then stipulates that you will not use P2P services on their network or agree to be throttled. This text will inevitably be buried deep within the contract where no one ever reads it.
 
Well I did speak out on this subject when it first came up. I wrote to the FCC during their public comment period using easy to understand language and at least one person read what I wrote. Via Ars Technica from last year:

I believe that Comcast Communications is using an application called Sandvine to insert a proverbial “dial tone” into a data stream. There are security measures put in place to prevent a hacker from sneaking data into a data stream, but as Comcast can monitor those streams they can perfectly forge an RST packet that will be interpreted as coming from the other party.

I'm sure my internet bill will be unaffected by this judgment because, you know, to do otherwise would be vindictive.

Now I am left I wondering if the government is going to do anything with regards to net neutrality.
 
Now I am left I wondering if the government is going to do anything with regards to net neutrality.

As am I. I hope they get their act together and push forward to put a stop to all of this. I hate paying maximum for mediocre service that throttles my connection. I would switch to another service but Comcast has a huge monopoly where I live. :(
 
Comcast blows balls... I live in a comcast town and i'm paying the same for 8 down 3 up as the very next town over that has optimum 50 down... go figure
 
Where's my check?

Oh.....right. There won't BE one. :rolleyes:

The most anyone might see is a discount coupon toward a service upgrade with a short-term window of availability ..... or some other crap like that.

Might as well add this $16 mil (along with all the other class-action lawsuits) into the Vaporware thread.
 
This is the image that pops in my head whenever I hear about Comcast.

comcass.jpg
 
Well I say lets all flood their service with P2P traffic. Make a Comcast.sucks.where's.my.part.of.the.16million.torrent garbage file that is pure rubbish and just takes up like 20 gigs that we can file share. :D:eek::D
 
I was a comcast subscriber during that period and hope that i see my $16 :rolleyes:

 
Well I say lets all flood their service with P2P traffic. Make a Comcast.sucks.where's.my.part.of.the.16million.torrent garbage file that is pure rubbish and just takes up like 20 gigs that we can file share. :D:eek::D

even since they verbally threatened to terminate me (a paying customer) just because i was using their service too much, i have made sure i use right to the limit they allow every month. sometimes its just leaving orb on and letting it download something from my own network... it gets sent to the net then sent back for no reason other then to get what i pay for:p.
 
SWEET, I get part of this because I have been affected by their asinine tactics!


Wait... what?! You're saying this money is going to be used for lawyers to jack off into and snort crack out of? No one influenced by Comcast's business tactics is getting any of it? Oh... GOD BLESS AMERICA
 
even since they verbally threatened to terminate me (a paying customer) just because i was using their service too much, i have made sure i use right to the limit they allow every month. sometimes its just leaving orb on and letting it download something from my own network... it gets sent to the net then sent back for no reason other then to get what i pay for:p.

LOL that's awesome.
 
Personally, I think every Comcast customer should do this: Use all the way up to the max. traffic allowed - protest the unadvertised caps on an "unlimited bandwidth" connection, and make Comcast admit: The average Comcast user does NOT use 4GB of combind traffic a month, and 250GB caps are BS.

I can hit Comcast's 250GB cap in less than 24 hours, with their mid-tier speed package (about 24mbit down).

3Mbyte/sec * 60 sec * 60 min * 24 = 259,000Mbytes. Ooops, over the "limit".

Why bother with Comcast's 50mbit tier, when you'll hit the cap in what, 12hrs?
 
You could have ended your statement with "Why bother with Comcast"... I've got my fingers crossed FiOs is on it's way here soon.
 
its true. given that all comcast internet plans cap at 250gb (if your 8mb or 16mb it doesnt matter, your cap is 250gb) that means that every plan is actually 1mb/sec sustained over 30 days. thats why i went with the 8mb plan, because technically all the plans are ripoffs. i even told this to a cs rep, and it took her a few minutes to understand that it is NOT 8mb connection.... its 1mb connection sustained, up to 8mb if needed. if they would advertise it like that i would have much less of a problem with them.
 
I honestly wish I still had Comcast, the ISP I use now is an absolute joke..Mediacom anyone?
 
Back
Top