Comcast Backtracks On Data Caps

Oh, and this CEO seems to really feel comfortable speaking out both sides of his mouth. Does he really think his message to investors won't reach everyone else? If anyone is naive, it's government. "We aren't doing anything greedy right now" will be heard as "we won't do anything greedy after the merger".

Well, companies do sometime float trial balloons in these speeches ... remember how the airlines danced around fees for checked bags at first and now it is standard ... with Spirit leading the way carry on bag fees are next ...

ISPs and Wireless providers are similar ... they will float ideas and see how much attention they get ... if it gets too much negative attention they will abandon or postpone or repackage the idea ... once one company pulls the trigger then the others watch to see how it was received and worked (and copy it if they don't need to be different for business reasons)

I view caps as a stopgap for vertical integration ... eventually the ISPs will buy the digital providers like Netflix and Redbox so they can offer a fully vertical approach like Google ... if Google can use the data they collect on their customers effectively to build a profitable enterprise then the other ISPs will probably relent on the data caps in favor of the much more valuable customer metadata ;)
 
People like me with cable and FIOS choices aren't going to see data caps. They are so fiercely fighting each other, the first to introduce a cap will see all their subscriptions lost.

But not many people have those choices, now do they? Something tells me that Google is waiting for such an occasion, to suddenly roll out their Fiber service across the US. They clearly have no interest in areas like NYC which already have cable and FIOS competition. They want places with only cable.
I agree. Google has its own selfish reasons to get into the ISP business. It's awesome though to watch how cable and phone companies respond when it's announced Google Fiber is coming to a new city. Almost immediately, you start hearing about new fiber services and/or 5X - 6X speed increases in those areas. Of coarse, TWC/AT&T etc. announce the increases in speeds or supposed fiber deployment have absolutely nothing to do with Google is coming to town. These asshole execs look comical when they do this crap. Screw them, they can go pound salt.

I just wish Google was more serious about their fiber rollout. Their primary motivation still seems to be just to shame incumbent ISP's into not fucking the internet up too badly.
 
Again, proof of this throttling?

You know what's probably is happening, which is pretty much what Netflix's former CDNs to comcast has said is happening? Comcast is refusing to upgrade the links between them and the CDN. Similar result, but it isn't throttling. They can simply say they cant afford the costs, and it would likely stand up in court.

That's really just playing games with terminology. On the residential ISP's side it's throttling, and on the other (peering) side it's playing games with bandwidth ("refusing to upgrade the links") to get what you want. Call it what you want, but it's just as bad as throttling. I like to call it extortion, because that's exactly what it is.
 
Then explain why in the Atlanta, GA area there is a 300GB data cap being enforced. And for those that didn't know this includes both upload and download usage.



Sure you don't offer it, but you pretty much forced Netflix into a deal where they have to pay you to deliver content to the end users
Fellow Atlanta resident here. Did the Atlanta office not get the memo about caps?
 
AIUI netflix paid to interconnect directly with comcasts network and to be able to operate servers within comcasts network. Not for prioritisation.

Do you have any sources to the contary?

Yes; I can't find the original article I read previously, but this one does a decent job: http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/02/netflix-packets-being-dropped-every-day-because-verizon-wants-more-money/. Basically, because the ISP's want on the content wagon they are extorting the tier 1 and 2 providers where they really should be allowing for more peer sharing.
 
I call BS.

I'm in Knoxville TN and we have a definite data cap of 300Gb listed on my account page.
We get 2 free overage months and then, after that, we are billed $10 per each 50Gb block beyond that.

I personally know people who have received the overage notices for going beyond the data cap.
 
I call BS.

I'm in Knoxville TN and we have a definite data cap of 300Gb listed on my account page.
We get 2 free overage months and then, after that, we are billed $10 per each 50Gb block beyond that.

I personally know people who have received the overage notices for going beyond the data cap.


Knoxville, TN here also and same story here. I know of a few cord cutters who have gone over their limit a few times as well. Hell, I'm on Charter (I live in Maryville) and since we cut the cord a few days ago I have noticed that our video streaming has started to get throttled. I need to start looking into a VPN
 
We're living in a transitional stage. Companies are dieing because they're trying to cling to their outdated business models, and technology is forcing them to change.

This, and they are hell bent to continue growing their revenue without actually DOING anything fundamentally different. They just want to find ways to creatively re-price all their existing services in ways to keep the train moving.
 
I just wish Google was more serious about their fiber rollout. Their primary motivation still seems to be just to shame incumbent ISP's into not fucking the internet up too badly.

I don't know why Google was teasing everyone with their fiber service. Maybe it was a scare tactic. But Google does have good reasons to push for more data. Their entire existence depends on it. If data caps are enforced then things like add blocking will become a normal thing. Website ads eat more data then the website itself, and YouTube relies on commercials they show before starting the video itself. But cut all that out and suddenly you save a lot in bandwidth.
 
Comcast definitely has 300gb data caps in Nashville, TN as well. I just pray that Google fiber comes in and literally everyone in Nashville switches because of how many people dont like comcast here.
 
What he said is EXACTLY what he meant. Data caps are 100 percent coming in the few years. Especially so if we don't push the FCC to start making rules that prevent ISP's from continuing this "Wild West" type activity with what the Internet will be molded into.

We must deny the merger between Comcrap and TWC , we need clear and well defined rules for how pathways can be used and we need eventually (probably won't happen) we need a Bill of rights for users on the Internet that includes privacy rights. We fail to at least do 2 of these then everything about the Internet and its access will be subsidized.

No, we really don't need the government legislating or regulating the Internet. The Wild West strawman you abhor is nothing more than the mechanism by which the Internet became what it is today.

I do agree that the Comcast/TWC merger should be blocked, though—and likewise, AT&T's attempted purchase of DirecTV.
 
Comcast definitely has 300gb data caps in Nashville, TN as well. I just pray that Google fiber comes in and literally everyone in Nashville switches because of how many people dont like comcast here.

Google Fiber is a false hope. At its current rate of expansion, you might get it by the year 2150.
 
Last time I checked I got an email for using over 300gb and reaching my cap...so there is no longer a cap now?
 
This information applies only to XFINITY Internet customers in Huntsville and Mobile, AL; Atlanta, Augusta and Savannah, GA; Central Kentucky; Maine; Jackson, MS; Knoxville and Memphis, TN; and Charleston, SC.
In these markets, the data amount included with all XFINITY Internet tiers will be 300 GB per month. We will offer additional gigabytes in increments/blocks of 50 GB for $10 each. http://customer.comcast.com/help-and-support/internet/data-usage-plans-expansion-data-plan

Those who are in the cities above have a 300GB cap, the no caps anywhere in the country is a lie; unless we are no longer considered part of the US. I live in Charleston paying $66.95 for a 25/5 connection.
 
Those who are in the cities above have a 300GB cap, the no caps anywhere in the country is a lie; unless we are no longer considered part of the US. I live in Charleston paying $66.95 for a 25/5 connection.

What you have there is not a "cap".

It's what Mr Cohen refers to as a "flexible data consumption plan" which "includ[es] a plan that enables customers who wanted to use more data be given the option to pay more to do so"

Basically, they have implemented a cap, while weaseling around the term "cap" by giving you the "option" to pay extra to bypass the cap.

This makes Mr Cohen a Weasel
Buck-thw-weasel-buck-19181251-426-320.jpg
 
And then this statement: "To be clear, Comcast has never offered paid prioritization, we are not offering it today, and we’re not considering entering into any paid prioritization creating fast lane deals with content owners."

How is this not straight out lying when Netflix just got through paying for prioritization? Holy crap this guy is a sleazeball.

How is it true? They didn't pay for prioritized traffic. They paid to be collocated with comcast data centers. Their traffic moves at the same speed anything collocated internal to the network does. Yes, it kind of rings false when they were traffic shaping netflix trafic from other networks to be slow, but technically they did not pay to get that traffic prioritized or to stop them shaping traffic. They paid for rack space and network from comcast. It's a very carefully worded statement that is technically true while being ethically and morally full of shit.
 
I only say cap, cause I'm sure no one would voluntarily give them more money other than what their monthly amount is. You're right it's not they are going to cut you off once get passed 300GB but whose going to keep paying $10 for 50GB chunks rather than just ration throughout the month then binge the remainder at the end of the month.
 
http:///kw4pokf

I want to pay cable companies 2x the cost per gigabyte.
Since I know that is cents probable less than a cent, then a metered per GB connection will save me lots of money, of this I am sure, even with netflix or whatever.
Hey at 2x it is 100% profit.
 
Its time for netflix to take compression seriously though. H.265 or whatever.
 
Something is removing the words ''
I take something in the filters, Its not my intention to pollute the board.
Here is the full link, I thought it was interesting.
http://blogs.howstuffworks.com/brai...eally-cost-a-look-at-the-worst-case-scenario/

Although I don't dispute that internet costs might be higher than they should be, I think you have to be careful of condensing the estimated costs down to just the cables. ISPs have employees and that incurs extra costs ... they pay taxes (theoretically) and that adds extra costs ... they must pay infrastructure costs related to communication with other backbones or providers on the internet ... etc, etc, etc

Although I don't advocate public ownership of the internet backbone, it will always be cheaper for a city or other public (non profit) entity to provide the service than for a publicly traded private entity ... even Google (which is offering some of the cheapest service) doesn't offer it for free (and they have a model which depends on usage, so they need their users to access the internet frequently to support their ad revenue, other services, and populate their user metadata databases)
 
I just got a popup window from Comcast while on ebay saying that I am at 90% of my 300GB data cap.
So this is BS of not having a cap.
 
Although I don't dispute that internet costs might be higher than they should be, I think you have to be careful of condensing the estimated costs down to just the cables. ISPs have employees and that incurs extra costs ... they pay taxes (theoretically) and that adds extra costs ... they must pay infrastructure costs related to communication with other backbones or providers on the internet ... etc, etc, etc

Although I don't advocate public ownership of the internet backbone, it will always be cheaper for a city or other public (non profit) entity to provide the service than for a publicly traded private entity ... even Google (which is offering some of the cheapest service) doesn't offer it for free (and they have a model which depends on usage, so they need their users to access the internet frequently to support their ad revenue, other services, and populate their user metadata databases)

You don't want the government owning the backbone. It is much harder to control multiple backbones than it is to control one that you own.
 
I just got a popup window from Comcast while on ebay saying that I am at 90% of my 300GB data cap.
So this is BS of not having a cap.

Hope that this was just a fluke. Maybe Comcast didn't get the memo on this subject.

If this Time Warner deal goes thru wait til your bills goes thru the roof. Comcast will want to recoup those billions in this buy out of TWI. You haven't seen nothing yet.
 
http:///kw4pokf

I want to pay cable companies 2x the cost per gigabyte.
Since I know that is cents probable less than a cent, then a metered per GB connection will save me lots of money, of this I am sure, even with netflix or whatever.
Hey at 2x it is 100% profit.

You are assuming that there is zero other costs. The cable companies will never give you an accurate rolled up cost per gig. It is far higher than what you think it is.
 
Back
Top