Comcast Appeals FCC Traffic-Blocking Ruling

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Somehow I just knew this wasn’t over yet.

The appeal, filed Thursday in the U.S. District Court of Appeals in Washington, challenges the FCC's ruling on August 1 that Comcast's throttling of BitTorrent traffic last year was unlawful--the first time any U.S. broadband provider has ever been found to violate Net neutrality rules. The FCC issued a cease-and-desist order and required the company to disclose to subscribers in the future how it plans to manage traffic.
 
It seems like Comcast is just asking for bad PR. They're doing things that not many people agree with or like and yet it always seem like they want to alienate their customers even more. I'm not proud to be a customer of this company, but their all I have :(
 
I hope the FCC drops da hamma down on them for real this time. The little slap on the wrist they gave Comcast was laughable at best. Someone at the FCC needs to plant their boot up some asses.
 
It seems like Comcast is just asking for bad PR. They're doing things that not many people agree with or like and yet it always seem like they want to alienate their customers even more. I'm not proud to be a customer of this company, but their all I have :(

They don't give a rat's ass. Their at the top in the US market, and its not like a large chunk of their customer's have other options...or even care about this issue.

In their mind it is an acceptable risk to gain bad PR.

Think about it this way, how many of their customer's are actually affected by the traffic shaping issue? How many of these customer's have other ISP or cable options? How many of these customer's will actually go through the effort of switching companies? Once you figure out the number of people that actually fit this criterion, you find out the actual number of people is relatively low compared to their entire subscriber base.

That being said, I think the FCC should review Comcast's appeal, then determine that they should have given them huge fines the first time.
 
I did and I went to a slower alternative too. I also got my dad switched over when he saw he could get a bundle deal with the DSL & satellite (he can get way more football games). I also got my oldest friend switched over, and his brother, and his parents.

So that's five people. It's up to people who pay attention to this stuff to educate the people around us, so start doing your job. ;)
 
I'd normally be hoping for huge fines put on Comcast from the FCC, however I don't really want to see my monthly bill go up at the same time.

Comcast and Qwest are my only options out here in Utah and unless Comcast starts completely sucking there's no way I'm going to 1.5Mb DSL from 8+Mb cable, it's just to bad that Comcast knows that.
 
I did and I went to a slower alternative too. I also got my dad switched over when he saw he could get a bundle deal with the DSL & satellite (he can get way more football games). I also got my oldest friend switched over, and his brother, and his parents.

So that's five people. It's up to people who pay attention to this stuff to educate the people around us, so start doing your job. ;)
Believe me I have. In the Kansas City area, there seems to be plenty of alternatives... Time Warner Cable, ATT DSL, and Everest, then of course there is satellite. I already have convinced one person to switch from Comcast to ATT.

However, if you want decent speeds, you really have 2 options: Time Warner or Comcast, and they seem to be divided into small geographic areas, and if you have one, you don't have the option of the other AFAIK.
 
Believe me I have. In the Kansas City area, there seems to be plenty of alternatives... Time Warner Cable, ATT DSL, and Everest, then of course there is satellite. I already have convinced one person to switch from Comcast to ATT.

However, if you want decent speeds, you really have 2 options: Time Warner or Comcast, and they seem to be divided into small geographic areas, and if you have one, you don't have the option of the other AFAIK.

Yeah but it sucks ass in a shit load of areas though. In my area you can get AT&T DSL or Time Warner, that's your choice. While in other area's you get mabye some other flavor of DSL and Comcast, but not both Time Warner and Comcast. AT&T sucks bigtime in my area, they have real shit connections. Sigh wish I could get FiOS. :(
 
I live just outside of Houston and the ONLY thing available here is Comcast. No dsl. no other cable provider.
 
I switched from Comcast (8Mbps) to Qwest DSL (7Mbps). Then I got accepted to the Warhammer Online beta, which required a 9.3GB client download over bit-torrent. I was pleasently surprised at how well the DSL handled it. I'm certain that I never would have got the download speeds that I did, had I still been with Comcast. Now Qwest is advertising a "fibre" connection with, up to, 25Mbps. So I'm hoping that more people will ditch Comcast. I'd sincerely like to see them go out of business!
 
It's HARDLY over. Hell, they haven't even stopped sending BT resets per the FCC order yet.
 
They wouldn't be pulling this shit if they actually had competition worth noting in a majority of the areas they service.

That said, its ridiculous how there isn't more competition between the broadband companies.
 
Yeah but it sucks ass in a shit load of areas though. In my area you can get AT&T DSL or Time Warner, that's your choice. While in other area's you get mabye some other flavor of DSL and Comcast, but not both Time Warner and Comcast. AT&T sucks bigtime in my area, they have real shit connections. Sigh wish I could get FiOS. :(

I live near Houston and Comcast used to be Time Warner. Fios need to make it's way down to the Houston area.
 
If they invested some of the obscene profits they make into upgrading and improving their network,bandwidth wouldn't be such a problem.The main reason I haven't switched from DSL to cable is their TV service is so bad that I figure any increase in speed would problem be offset by constant reception problems.Better to wait for FIOS.
 
What bothers me about the caps , is the future.
If the caps go up over time, great .. if not ... then there will be problems.

More and more people are watching hi-def streaming content instead of buying dvd, downloading iso instead of buying software, and online games use more and more bandwidth.

I think they are worried that more users are going to the internet instead of their cable service. At the moment, this is not the case, but it is slowly going toward that direction.
Just look at how much media we stream - from mp3 & podcasts, hulu, torrents, youtube, and it just keep going.

And if they are hurting for bandwidth, why do they push the voip so much.
It is all about profits. The less they have to spend on upgrading their network, more $$$ in their pocket.

I am glad I have Charter down here, and i hope they don't do something like this in the future, but no one knows for sure. Time will tell.

If FIOS starts to get in more placed, i bet they will start to change their toon a little.
 
I am glad I have Charter down here, and i hope they don't do something like this in the future, but no one knows for sure. Time will tell.

Some might call me crazy but where I used to live we had Charter and I liked them. Their prices were high ($50 for 3mb/768k), but their service was super reliable and I NEVER had the problems with them that I have with comcrap. Never lost synch, speeds never dropped, etc. Wish we had Charter down here...or FiOS.
 
Looks like they haven't learned their lesson yet. If the future calls for online distribution of games and video then they're going to have to learn that companies like microsoft are soon going to be handing the majority of material costs over to our ISPs. If they don't do some serious investing soon there will be lots of unhappy customers, lots of court battles and appeals, and of course legislation will find a way to take away more freedom from us as they lose sight of the reason they've put everyone on the spot and continue labeling all p2p traffic as highly illegal activity which can lead to half a million dollar fines and jail time to the customers.
 
What does it take to file an amicus curiae brief filed showing just how well forging TCP resets fit any reasonably well crafted definition of criminal hacking?

I suspect the EFF can take time off of losing cases that will make damaging precedent to shock the judge with what they are doing.

Personally, if I wanted to sue the government to keep doing something shady, I'd at least want to make sure it was not a crime.
 
Their prices were high ($50 for 3mb/768k), but their service was super reliable and I NEVER had the problems with them that I have with comcrap. Never lost synch, speeds never dropped, etc. QUOTE]

QOT: $49.99 - 10mb/1mb $39.99 6mb/512k $59.99 16mb/2mb

Speed is great .. and never down
 
Their prices were high ($50 for 3mb/768k), but their service was super reliable and I NEVER had the problems with them that I have with comcrap. Never lost synch, speeds never dropped, etc.

QOT: $49.99 - 10mb/1mb $39.99 6mb/512k $59.99 16mb/2mb

Speed is great .. and never down
 
Back
Top