Clean Space is the Right Way

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
Even though it has been several years since Sammy the Satellite first blessed our lives, his message is still very relevant. All while this heartwarming character brings with it a loving warmth and humanness, it cannot be allowed to distract us from the real problem at large. Some company's old space junk is going to crash into something soon, and likely take out a DirecTV satellite and keep me from seeing a football game. This must be stopped, and the Brane Craft Phase II is wanting to make this a reality. The basis of the idea is to wrap old space junk up in aluminum foil and hurtle those back towards the Earth, in the general direction of Australia, and hope those burn up before hitting the ground.

Check out the video.

Think of the latest idea of collecting space junk as something akin to a hungry tiger pouncing on its prey. Aerospace Corporation says its Brane Craft will wrap itself around debris orbiting Earth and drag it back down through the atmosphere, causing it to burn up and never again threaten satellites or astronauts.
 
"...hurtle those back towards the Earth, in the general direction of Australia..."

Space junk VS giant spiders and kangaroos!

Sounds like an idea for a super low budget sci-fi movie
 
We should probably aim them at best Korea and Russia since they are two of the worst offenders of just leaving their shit up there when done. The US and ESA has rules about de-orbiting at the end of mission life particularly for LEO satellites where it is getting over crowded.
 
Bah. Typical weak Euro viewpoint. "Your wittle satellites get a booboo? Ohhh. So sad." Real 'Murican satellites are made from STEEL. Like they should be. This "field of debris" is more like a "field of dreams", keeping the riff-raff out of space. Until you can loft 3 metric tons of Krupp, err, 'Murican amor, you don't have space program!

Oh...and when the video talked about "slamming nuts into you" as if it were a BAD thing, well, they lost me.
 
Time to start experimenting with solar sails and downgrading to garbage cans. Kevlar/mylar material on articulating "umbrella" to sail into a path of debris.
 
Time to start experimenting with solar sails and downgrading to garbage cans. Kevlar/mylar material on articulating "umbrella" to sail into a path of debris.
Agree. Isn't it less energy intensive to boost out of orbit than to de-orbit? Plus now we can litter the entire solar system and really get the attention of ET
 
Agree. Isn't it less energy intensive to boost out of orbit than to de-orbit? Plus now we can litter the entire solar system and really get the attention of ET
A trash heap would be easier to locate and snag than an accelerated debris field.
Edit I remember a story abou some nano velcro like stuff proposed too.
 
Damn who would have thought that when zero rights are needed to do something somewhere companies/countries/etc will just fuck it all up because "shit's free yo!"
 
Okay. Take that euro halon collider thing they keep talking about. Yeah. How they made that black hole? Do it again. Send it up to orbit. Once around should do the job. Presto.

'Murica came up with that!
 
Or imagine the massive radio telescope that could be made by aggregating the thousands of satellites that are functional but useless because of orbital decay. Attach small robotic boosters with guidance , send those suckers out of orbit, align and synchronize all of them, aggregate all the signals and process them. A radio telescope the size of the solar system.

Google could do this with apple amazon and Microsoft. Since the data is not immediately monetizable no one would make money. But think of all the data they could gather.


Until they find ET and it tells us some magical secrets . Then they could advertise to ET AND REALLY MAKE MONEY
 
One of these days, some tiny bolt or paint chip that blew off a space craft will hit a maned space craft and kill everyone. A paint chip coming at you at 8000m/s (legitimate velocity) will kill you and destroy just about anything it hits. There are over 500k objects larger that 1cm in space right now, good luck tracking all of them.
 
Isn't space just like 62 miles up into the atmosphere? Would the satellites need to fall at a very steep angle and fast velocity to achieve an atmospheric burn?
 
Isn't space just like 62 miles up into the atmosphere? Would the satellites need to fall at a very steep angle and fast velocity to achieve an atmospheric burn?
Yes and No...

Generally speaking they're already at orbital speed (a wide range of speed) and they're not shielded so most likely they'll burn up nearly no matter the trajectory they enter the atmosphere. We will have to worry about much bigger parts which may survive re-entry.
 
One of these days, some tiny bolt or paint chip that blew off a space craft will hit a maned space craft and kill everyone. A paint chip coming at you at 8000m/s (legitimate velocity) will kill you and destroy just about anything it hits. There are over 500k objects larger that 1cm in space right now, good luck tracking all of them.
Well if you're lucky they're all traveling in roughly the same direction in which case it's not coming at you at 8000 m/s
 
As long as the first one lands on wherever the Clinton family is at the time, I'm game!
 
As long as the first one lands on wherever the Clinton family is at the time, I'm game!

Now now lets be civil. I may vehemently disagree with their politics and think they should never be given any power ever again but I dont wish them dead. Just politically eviscerated which I think already happened last Nov ;).
 
Or imagine the massive radio telescope that could be made by aggregating the thousands of satellites that are functional but useless because of orbital decay. Attach small robotic boosters with guidance , send those suckers out of orbit, align and synchronize all of them, aggregate all the signals and process them. A radio telescope the size of the solar system.

Google could do this with apple amazon and Microsoft. Since the data is not immediately monetizable no one would make money. But think of all the data they could gather.


Until they find ET and it tells us some magical secrets . Then they could advertise to ET AND REALLY MAKE MONEY
Terrible, this idea. Sounds interesting still.
 
Now now lets be civil. I may vehemently disagree with their politics and think they should never be given any power ever again but I dont wish them dead. Just politically eviscerated which I think already happened last Nov ;).

I don't want them dead either.

I just dislike them enough to want them to collectively shit themselves as a massive chunk of burning, obsolete tech lands just out of reach with a spectacular KABOOM!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kju1
like this
Why Australia, wouldn't it be better into the sea ??
At the speeds of re-entry, an object might fly a few hundred or thousand miles before hitting the ground. If you start re-entry over Australia, it will likely end up in the south pacific if it ever makes it through the atmosphere. If it goes straight down instead, it might kill a kangaroo that no one cares about.
 
At the speeds of re-entry, an object might fly a few hundred or thousand miles before hitting the ground. If you start re-entry over Australia, it will likely end up in the south pacific if it ever makes it through the atmosphere. If it goes straight down instead, it might kill a kangaroo that no one cares about.

Even aiming straight down the rotation of the earth, friction from air resistance, and small uncounted deltas in the calculations will pretty much ensure it wont go straight down.
 
nothing major will happen until some important military satellite got taken out by debris
then in a blink of an eye, you will see all these leaders of the world lining up in some UN press call to usher in a taxpayer funded alliance to clean up space.
 
Back
Top