Chrome OS Pushes People into 'Careless Computing'

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The founder of the Free Software Foundation says that Chrome OS is "pushing people into careless computing." He also said extensive use of cloud computing was "worse than stupidity."

Google's new cloud computing ChromeOS looks like a plan "to push people into careless computing" by forcing them to store their data in the cloud rather than on machines directly under their control, warns Richard Stallman, founder of the Free Software Foundation and creator of the operating system GNU.
 
Yea, it isn't a great idea for some people


but 95% of the population doesn't even know what a backup is, or how to make it

or care about anything but using shit on the web

I honestly, truly feel that cloud computing will be one less headache for most of the world
 
The founder of the Free Software Foundation says that Chrome OS is "pushing people into careless computing." He also said extensive use of cloud computing was "worse than stupidity."

Gotta disagree with RMS. I think this whole cloud computing thing where end users are not responsible for their data is fantastic. People have a choice, some want control over their junk, some don't care. There are options for both types.
 
The whole point of the cloud is to make internet devices an appliance. The big downside is that this allows business interests and government(s) much easier access to mine your data.
 
While I do not find cloud computing particularly beneficial to me. If this guy honestly thinks the average person is worse off with this then their own. Then he is MASSIVELY overestimating the typical users security practices.
 
the majority of the population will notice no difference between "careless computing", and the way they already use their computers.
 
While I can see how this "could" be beneficial to the average Joe, I do know none of my data will ever be on the cloud.
Not that I have anything to hide, but it's my data. I run backups weekly. As long as I still have a choice in the matter I'm keeping my crap in house.
 
Clearly not a marketing type. This isn't careless computing, it's carefree computing!
 
This might be the first time I want google to fail. I really don't want the control to be forcefully put in the hands of someone else. It's not even about data for me, it's about knowing how much processing power I have and being able to use it and to what extent I deem necessary.
 
If you think vendor lockin is bad now, just wait until it is the vendor that actually has all your data. :eek: What is to stop Google deciding to charge money to access their services and your data 5 years down the road?
 
Using chrome os is careless computing either way. It's akin to releasing windows 1.0. Fresh and full of vulnerabilities that havn't been discovered yet.

As for the cloud, they can keep their vision of their future of clouds to themselves.
 
If you think vendor lockin is bad now, just wait until it is the vendor that actually has all your data. :eek: What is to stop Google deciding to charge money to access their services and your data 5 years down the road?

Their shareholders.
 
This might be the first time I want google to fail. I really don't want the control to be forcefully put in the hands of someone else. It's not even about data for me, it's about knowing how much processing power I have and being able to use it and to what extent I deem necessary.

and of all companies, google, who wants all your data for marketing reasons......

I just don't trust them or anyone to hold my data, they can literally do what ever they want with it and you would never actually know even if their terms states they dont or wont.
 
Cloud = Modern mainframe
Cloud = no control of your own information
Cloud = no privacy
Cloud = that guy from Final Fantasy 7
 
Google want all your information! not happy with just your search results and info collected from google sites, now they want your monthly budget spreadsheets, photos of your dog and angry unsent letters to your ex!
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
All they have to do is store the data encrypted. Then who cares if they get hacked?

And of course someone from the free software foundation wants Chrome to fail. They want Linux to succeed.
 
What, you mean people aren't already carelessly computing, with hardly anyone falling for Nigerian money scams, malware, viruses and browser hijacking?
 
I really don't see Google having anyone's best interest in mind. They're in the business of selling off people's information and habits; With cloud computing, they'll know what and how you use your computer at all times.

Lot's of good information for marketer's, but also a lot of potential for abuse.
 
Is so sorry for WD....when tehy gonna step up to this bullshit Seagate crap? Or is that MyBook taking it's toll finally?
 
Gotta disagree with RMS. I think this whole cloud computing thing where end users are not responsible for their data is fantastic. People have a choice, some want control over their junk, some don't care. There are options for both types.

The BIG problem is that MOST people don't worry or even care about being free. Much Less fighting for it. All that matters is living a comfy mediocre life. Sad part of the story is that the people that do care are much less and are always affected by the overwhelming majority of the others.
 
All they have to do is store the data encrypted. Then who cares if they get hacked?

And of course someone from the free software foundation wants Chrome to fail. They want Linux to succeed.

Too bad that even linux doesnt want linux to succeed.
 
I really don't see Google having anyone's best interest in mind. They're in the business of selling off people's information and habits
Google doesn't sell your personal information. They use your information internally, with your consent, to deliver ads that are better targeted toward your interests. Users benefit from this by receiving free services which Google provides (and which many other providers charge for). They also benefit from the ads themselves, in many cases.

In reality, Google's entire business model revolves around your best interests (and trying to satisfy them).
 
Wow, you'd think a forum of supposedly technologically savvy user base would be more informed and less conspiratorial about Google.
 
No different than trying to access files created by MS software without paying off Microsoft. Also look at the EULA sometimes. You just gave MS the right to do anything with the computer that you paid for them to own.

Their server == not yours
Proprietary software == not yours

Wow, you'd think a forum of supposedly technologically savvy user base would be more informed and less conspiratorial about Google.

It isn't a question of conspiracy. You are talking about an organization consisting of 20,000 (maybe I shouldn't have asked google :)) people required by law to be working on returning shareholder value. Claiming that they are doing something else is the nutty option.
 
This is like a total stranger reading your journal or diary full of your utmost personal experience, vendettas, life etc...

...all the while you just sit there giggling like an idiot in Pollyanna mode.
 
I think the point the guy is trying to make is even with Windows PC running no antivirus by idiots the data safe and sound at home or work.

You guys aren't newbs. You know data can be recovered from drives 99.9% of the time by a lab if software can't do it and you all know very few infections have ever destroyed data or stolen it. Slowdowns, hijacking, redirects, ad pop-ups and the like hardly threaten data.

When bad stuff happens, joe sixpack takes his computer to a tech and, save for the odd horror story, everything is peachy again. Simply company file, nasty pics of the missus and pictures of baby are A okay.

Pure cloud computing represents a fundamental change to all of this. There is no data on the machine and joe sixpack won't even know that until its too late.

Who's going to warn him? The douche at best buy thats just trying to meet sales targets or that old lady in the Costco/Walmart computer department?

When this system breaks, for whatever the reason (government policy, legalities, hackers, eartthquake, lost passwords and credentials, bankrupcies, company sold, whatever) you are truly and totally proper screwed. PERIOD.

We may know this, but joe sixpack won't until it's too late.
 
The whole point of the cloud is to make internet devices an appliance. The big downside is that this allows business interests and government(s) much easier access to mine your data.

All my important information is already in the cloud. In fact, the only data I have locally is data that I don't care if people mine.

Data I already have in the cloud:
Bank information (online banking, electronic statements, etc...)
Email
IMs
Social crap (facebook, twitter, forums, etc...)
pr0n

Data on my 3tb drives:
Music
Movies
pr0n
games

I'm betting most of you are the same. Chrome OS doesn't suddenly mean you have to put all your information into Google's servers. That would be completely unnacceptable. Instead, the only extra data Chrome OS will encourage people to give to Google is how they have Chrome setup (bookmarks, extensions, and themes) - to that I say awesome, storing that in the cloud is ideal anyway because it then synchronizes across multiple computers.
 
I think he needs to rephrase his comments. Not all cloud computing is giving control of your data away. In this particular use with Google there is definitely cause to a little concerned given their track record with personal data lately... But many companies have cloud computing solutions that keep as completel control of the data for the clients as possible over the internet. There are many private clouds as well. Cloud computing isn't as nebulous as he claims.
 
I think the point the guy is trying to make is even with Windows PC running no antivirus by idiots the data safe and sound at home or work.

You guys aren't newbs. You know data can be recovered from drives 99.9% of the time by a lab if software can't do it and you all know very few infections have ever destroyed data or stolen it. Slowdowns, hijacking, redirects, ad pop-ups and the like hardly threaten data.

When bad stuff happens, joe sixpack takes his computer to a tech and, save for the odd horror story, everything is peachy again. Simply company file, nasty pics of the missus and pictures of baby are A okay.

Pure cloud computing represents a fundamental change to all of this. There is no data on the machine and joe sixpack won't even know that until its too late.

Who's going to warn him? The douche at best buy thats just trying to meet sales targets or that old lady in the Costco/Walmart computer department?

When this system breaks, for whatever the reason (government policy, legalities, hackers, eartthquake, lost passwords and credentials, bankrupcies, company sold, whatever) you are truly and totally proper screwed. PERIOD.

We may know this, but joe sixpack won't until it's too late.

I would like to drink the laced purple koolaid your on. Of the 120 recoveries attempted by my company in the past year, only 20 were successful. Now these were all recoveries done for drives that had physically crashed, meaning there was some physical damage to the drive, about 90% of these were caused by overheating which lead to the eventual click of death. That is well short of your 99.9% mark. There are many things that can cause damage that is unrecoverable. And the recovery methods used were the highest available, including sector by sector and bit to bit physical copies. You cannot always reconstruct the data or save all of the data.
 
If you think vendor lockin is bad now, just wait until it is the vendor that actually has all your data. :eek: What is to stop Google deciding to charge money to access their services and your data 5 years down the road?

Who is to say you can't keep your data locally as well. .Seriously do you think that you won't be able to save that to a traditional storage device? FFS all you foil hats make me cranky.

Also why wouldn't they charge a fee for online data storage? Everyone else does.
 
I can see an advantage from a business perspective, but I personally hate the idea of the cloud. As long as I can remote into my home network from some other computer, after installing some basic software, and authenticating, I am perfectly happy. I agree, once the data is on another system than your own, it is no longer your data. Screw the cloud. Maybe we should all just accept wired chips under our skin as well, to better assist us when we get lost and need a gps to help us find Burger King..
 
I would like to drink the laced purple koolaid your on. Of the 120 recoveries attempted by my company in the past year, only 20 were successful. Now these were all recoveries done for drives that had physically crashed, meaning there was some physical damage to the drive, about 90% of these were caused by overheating which lead to the eventual click of death. That is well short of your 99.9% mark. There are many things that can cause damage that is unrecoverable. And the recovery methods used were the highest available, including sector by sector and bit to bit physical copies. You cannot always reconstruct the data or save all of the data.

You don't have to be insulting.

The company I turn to when all my methods fail has been able to get back the data every time so far. And have customers bring me bad drives on a regular basis.

These are drives with siezed motors, broken heads, "click of death", blown i/o controllers., you name it. If the drive needs to be completely rebuilt with a new motor, heads, realigned platters or a firmware lockup resolved they do that.

They got data for me from dead drives on RAID arrays that other companies with Level 5 clean labs could not.

Is this a guaruntee or 100%? NO, but

Unless you are willing to say you are the best in the world and if you can't do it nobody can, don't be a jerk.
 
I don't like my data in the cloud when it could be safe on my pc, but I do like that my phone snycs with google all my phone numbers and contact info. So if I lose my phone tmobile gives me a new one I log in with my google account and I am back up and running. I keep a local copy on my pc when I remember to back it up, in case google loses a server or two with my info on it.
 
I don't like my data in the cloud when it could be safe on my pc, but I do like that my phone snycs with google all my phone numbers and contact info. So if I lose my phone tmobile gives me a new one I log in with my google account and I am back up and running. I keep a local copy on my pc when I remember to back it up, in case google loses a server or two with my info on it.

Google has tens of thousands of servers. I think it's safe to assume that Google keeps multiple backups of everyone's data whether they signed up for it or not in case a server fries rather than a user makes a mistake.
 
Back
Top