Chipsets: Via vs NForce

’m‚³‚ñ

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jun 20, 2003
Messages
7,300
I've had less experience with VIA, I had a shuttle board with a VIA KT333 (or was it KT266?) chipset. It was a pretty lousy OCer. So, the question is, which chipset would you choose? And, what are the differences between a VIA chipset and a NVidia chipset?

Anyone have any experiences with either (haha, what a wide open question. :p)?

I'm assuming that VIA has more of a server background... Is that true?
 
Absolutely no one is going to recommend Via chipsets over Nforce2 chipsets. Thats all you need to know. I concur.
 
If overclocking is your goal, the only thing you need to understand is locked Pci/Agp(Nforce2) -vs- Not locked Pci/Agp(Via)


Nforce2 will win that argument everytime.

Laterz.
dafanman:cool:
 
Originally posted by dafanman
If overclocking is your goal, the only thing you need to understand is locked Pci/Agp(Nforce2) -vs- Not locked Pci/Agp(Via)


Nforce2 will win that argument everytime.

Laterz.
dafanman:cool:

Ahh, yes. That might be why my SCSI card never worked in my Shuttle. :p I have my PCI locked at 33 mhz in my Epox board. I don't even know where the option is in my FIC mobo's BIOS. :p
 
So, the question is, which chipset would you choose? And, what are the differences between a VIA chipset and a NVidia chipset?

For overclocking?
NForce 2 Ultra, probably one of the DFI boards.
The VIA chipsets do not have locked PCI/AGP buses.

You can get a KT600 board with (mediocre) SATA for a damn good price though, the Abit KV7 is <$60. And you don't need matched DIMMs to get the best performance out of the platform - since it's single-channel only you can buy a single 512MB DIMM and be assured you'll get all the bandwidth you can.

I'm assuming that VIA has more of a server background... Is that true?

No.
VIA has historically been the consumer chipset manufacturer with "the most features", and use to have hard drive throughput issues.

Nvidia only very recently began making chipsets, and has also had drive issues, mostly with optical drive incompatibilities (forces reverting to the stock XP drivers, which use a lot more CPU time and decrease hard drive throughput - see lostcircuits HDD articles)

Neither manufacturer has ever been really server-oriented.

If money is not an important consideration, go Nvidia.
 
Originally posted by leukotriene
For overclocking?
NForce 2 Ultra, probably one of the DFI boards.
The VIA chipsets do not have locked PCI/AGP buses.

You can get a KT600 board with (mediocre) SATA for a damn good price though, the Abit KV7 is <$60. And you don't need matched DIMMs to get the best performance out of the platform - since it's single-channel only you can buy a single 512MB DIMM and be assured you'll get all the bandwidth you can.



No.
VIA has historically been the consumer chipset manufacturer with "the most features", and use to have hard drive throughput issues.

Nvidia only very recently began making chipsets, and has also had drive issues, mostly with optical drive incompatibilities (forces reverting to the stock XP drivers, which use a lot more CPU time and decrease hard drive throughput - see lostcircuits HDD articles)

Neither manufacturer has ever been really server-oriented.

If money is not an important consideration, go Nvidia.

I'm not really looking for a board, just wanted to make a topic for this forum. :) Like, an FAQ, almost.

Honestly, I've seen more NForce boards for cheap than VIA boards. Hence I got the FIC AU13 with NForce, and then again, an Epox 8RDA3+ with NForce.

Heh, being an AMD d00d, I completely forgot about Intel. :p oh well, they are solid, but have done shoddy work in the past (cough, cough dell hp compaq cough).
 
From all I have read and experienced, if you want good OC with occasional finicky setup behavior, nForce 2 is the way to go.

If you want cheap, generally stable with less then stellar OC, go with Via KT600 chipset.

(before ya fire up the flamethrowers, this is just my opinion on what I've read/experienced)
 
via is fairly inexpensive, and the overclocks may not be as high, but it maybe worth it to some people because of the included features, like sata
 
Originally posted by chay80
From all I have read and experienced, if you want good OC with occasional finicky setup behavior, nForce 2 is the way to go.

If you want cheap, generally stable with less then stellar OC, go with Via KT600 chipset.

(before ya fire up the flamethrowers, this is just my opinion on what I've read/experienced)

I agree, OCing on NForce2 is flakey. I have an old Super Socket 7 board with a K6-2 on it, and that sob REALLY OC's. Getting a 400 mhz OC out of a 450 mhz CPU is just a bit nuts. :p With an Socket 370 HSF designed for a PIII, this thing is actually stable. I wish the NForce2 would give that kind of an OC. I think my Chipset is holding me back on my OC, stability wise and speed wise. :( I really need a new HSF for the NB. I'm limited because my SLK 800U is already resting against the NB HSF...
 
I have been looking for information on this. I am going to buy a motherboard tomorrow, and the chipsets seem so much the same, feature wise.

My #1 concern is stability. Which one has better drivers and doesn't crash as much? So far, I can't get any good answers. My driver experience with both vendors has been good, but I can't trust either one 100%. I don't care about overclocking, but the locked PCI feature of nForce2 looks appealing. I just want something that absolutely works, without switching over to Intel.

Regarding the part about mixed ram: I have 128mb, 256mb and 512mb dimms. The 512 is faster and comes from a different manufacturer. Am I going to have problems with a nForce board?

It's so confusing. In the past, I always chose VIA because their bad reputation only came from people comparing their chipsets to Intel; while nForce1 was overhyped just because it was a nVidia product. But now that these new chipsets are out, things have changed so much.

P.S., Can anyone comment on the RAID functionality of KT600? I'm sort of reluctant to use it.
 
Originally posted by Demogorg0
I have been looking for information on this. I am going to buy a motherboard tomorrow, and the chipsets seem so much the same, feature wise.

My #1 concern is stability. Which one has better drivers and doesn't crash as much? So far, I can't get any good answers. My driver experience with both vendors has been good, but I can't trust either one 100%. I don't care about overclocking, but the locked PCI feature of nForce2 looks appealing. I just want something that absolutely works, without switching over to Intel.

Regarding the part about mixed ram: I have 128mb, 256mb and 512mb dimms. The 512 is faster and comes from a different manufacturer. Am I going to have problems with a nForce board?

It's so confusing. In the past, I always chose VIA because their bad reputation only came from people comparing their chipsets to Intel; while nForce1 was overhyped just because it was a nVidia product. But now that these new chipsets are out, things have changed so much.

P.S., Can anyone comment on the RAID functionality of KT600? I'm sort of reluctant to use it.

Both chipsets shoudl be stable at stock speed, and the drivers really depend on the board's maker.

RAM is a mixed bag here. Your fasts RAM is going to run as slow as the slowest, unless you overclock the RAM. That shouldn't be too much of a problem, unless you really care about that. With those sizes of RAM, you won't be able to run DDR in dual mode. If you got two 256 meg chips, you could probably get it to run in dual mode with the 512.

I wouldn't touch a VIA RAID chip. :p However, the actual controller chip is probably the same one as used on the NForce2 boards. :p So, it shouldn't matter that much. ;)
 
Well, I think that the RAID functionality is built into the hard drive controller on the VIA southbridge. The boards don't appear to have third party chips for this. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Is there any way to lock the pci/agp bus on an VIA board? Like bios updates or anything?
 
Originally posted by LANKING
Is there any way to lock the pci/agp bus on an VIA board? Like bios updates or anything?

My Shuttle had a divider for the PCI bus I believe. I'm not sure if any other Shuttle boards or any other VIA based boards do, though. But I do not believe that it is possible to lock the PCI bus on a VIA chipset.
 
You should get a KT133 board. Those sure were sweet.....NOT.



Nforce2 no question.
 
Originally posted by chay80
From all I have read and experienced, if you want good OC with occasional finicky setup behavior, nForce 2 is the way to go.

If you want cheap, generally stable with less then stellar OC, go with Via KT600 chipset.

(before ya fire up the flamethrowers, this is just my opinion on what I've read/experienced)

No flames from me - I agree.

Overall stability = VIA
Overall performance = nForce2

Just one example, Me = GigaByte mobo w/ KT400A, 2500+, 1 x 512 MB, uber stable, tiny OC. Daughter = GigaByte mobo w/ nForce2, 2500+, 2 x 256 MB Dual Channel, flacky, but faster than mine.

That's pretty much it.
 
Originally posted by somecallmeTim
No flames from me - I agree.

Overall stability = VIA
Overall performance = nForce2

Just one example, Me = GigaByte mobo w/ KT400A, 2500+, 1 x 512 MB, uber stable, tiny OC. Daughter = GigaByte mobo w/ nForce2, 2500+, 2 x 256 MB Dual Channel, flacky, but faster than mine.

That's pretty much it.

So far, my NForce2 8RDA3+ is pretty damn stable. It's a bitch getting an OC going on it, but once it's all set up, it's fine.
 
i used to own the old soyo KT333 dragon lite, and i never had a problem for the whole year i owned it. but of course i never overclocked at all.

then i upgraded to the 8RDA+, sold that , got the shuttle sn41g2 (nforce2), sold that got the sn45g (nforce2 ultra400).

i liked the perfromance and features i got from the nforce bunch. and stabilty wise BOTH were on the same level imo

but if i had a choice, nforce2 ultra400 all the way :)

(ignore the intel in my sig ;))
 
I loved my original nForce board (Abit NV7-133R), but the nForce 2 is total garbage, IMO. I tried the Epox 8RDA and MSI K7N2 Delta-L (2 of the MSI), and all three boards would give me hang ups (according to each boards diagnostic debuggers) on the RAM...of which I tried 3 different sticks...each a different brand. Samsung, Kingston, Buffalo. NONE worked on the NF2's for me, despite working perfectly fine on other boards, including my KT400 one. The 8RDA and the first K7N2 worked fine until I attempted a small OC. The 2nd K7N2 never would POST.

I wanted to OC and went with a P4 instead.
 
regarding to Master [H] post, the nforce2 is picky on ram too. i had to use the corsair xms to get it working right

-paulm
 
I kinda figured that would fix my problem, but I felt it was ridiculous to have to buy some XMS or other high-end RAM just to have a box work.
 
Originally posted by paulmofyourhand
regarding to Master [H] post, the nforce2 is picky on ram too. i had to use the corsair xms to get it working right

-paulm

That is what I have seen on the nForce2 systems that I have set up. With Crucial or Corsair, I've had excelelnt results. The system my daughter built has Buffalo (Samsung chips) - she was on a budget and was calling the shots - she'll learn about 'cheap memory'. I got my board before the the nForce2 mobo's were stable, or relatively stable.

What I have found, and find odd, is that an nForce2 mobo, with an ATi vid card tends to be more stable than with an nVidia GPU... Not always, but I build 5 to 10 systems a month for peoples, and that's the way it seems to go - regardless of the GPU generation (GF3, 4, FX or from the 7500 to the 9800...).

But yah - I will agree about the memory, and Corsair seems to work great in all the boards - while Crucial works good in some and Kingston will in others. Cheap RAM = odd results with nForce2, then again YMMV...

Peace,
Tim
 
Back
Top