Cheapest Card that can murder everything except Crysis

cinnaminbuns576

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 8, 2007
Messages
131
Ok so we all know unless you have an insanely good system with then 8800gt or gtx or the high-end Radeon etc etc etc then you wont be able to play Crysis on amazing settings... BUT....

What, in your opinion, is the cheapest card i could get that would be able to play Bioshock, COD4, HL2 ep2, and the newest Unreal Tournament all on Max or very close to Max settings?? I want an 8800GT obviously but with supply and demand its being overpriced and under-available. I just wanna go and buy a worthwhile card. What would you all recommend? Price is an object, but i dont have a limit or anything... (meaning... card doesnt have to be under $100 or anything... it can be whatever... just wanna know the cheapest i can get that can play all those games).
 
If I were you, I wouldn't go Radeon at this point. The 3870 contantly loses to 8800GT in every benchmark, for example in UT3, it loses by 20 FPS. Just check Newegg daily for 8800GTs, theyre usually in stock at least once a week for a whole day
 
hardocp's UT3 review today showed the 3870 and 3850 being great cards for the money.

8800gt is faster overall but its more expensive also. the radeon 3850 seems to be the best bet if your looken for bang for buck.
 
not to get off subject... but according to these 2 posts... youre saying the 3850 or 3870 or 8800GT are the cheapest that can run these at max or near max? cuz the whole thing im trying to find out is the CHEAPEST card i can get that will run it to my specs. If 8800GT is the cheapest thats fine... but i figured there'd be others that could run it as well... since there obviously was alot of people playing Bioshock and COD4 etc before the new 8800gt came out.

Also im running q6600 quad core, 4gb DDR2 800 ram, Antec 900 case that keeps everything nice and cool, 700 watt power supply
 
HD3850 would be the cheapest, get two of them if you have a Crossfire mobo. I would recommend the 512MB version.
 
My 8800GTS 320mb for $200 runs all those games amazingly well! :p But seriously I would go with the 3870 if you could find one. Think I saw one in the hotdeals section for $220 or so. If not then the Radeon 2900GTs are around $150 on newegg that or an X1950PRO.
 
everyone keeps telling me to go spend $300 on the 8800GT which is overpriced... im looking for the CHEAPEST card to run those games... which i know 8800GT is not the cheapest cuz those games were out before that card came out! HULLOOOO
 
everyone keeps telling me to go spend $300 on the 8800GT which is overpriced... im looking for the CHEAPEST card to run those games... which i know 8800GT is not the cheapest cuz those games were out before that card came out! HULLOOOO

all the old cars that could play the games max out are more expensive then the GT.. so you're looking for a cheap card that performs well. check the suggestions in this thread.. they're a good starting point. Maybe a 8800gt 256mb? might choke out on max settings due to less ram though
 
The 3870 is USELESS, the 3850 wins bang for the buck, a great deal, but the 8800gt is the only good higher end card besides the gtx/ultra.
 
Would help to know what resolution you are going to be running at. If your on a 17 inch with only 1280x1024 then we are talking about a much different card than if your running a 24+ inch widescreen.
 
if looking new, get the 3850, if you are really tight on cash get a 7900 GS (the seem to be a lot cheaper than the x1950 pro new)

If you are open to buying used it a totally different ball game. an x1900 xt 512 can be had for 120 these days. About $100 less than a 3850 when you include tax and shipping.
 
how patient are you? 8800GT should drop in price early next year

I'd try to get a 256MB 8800GT if you don't game at high resolutions. That's $210 and offers better performance than the ATI cards.
 
The 3870 is USELESS, the 3850 wins bang for the buck, a great deal, but the 8800gt is the only good higher end card besides the gtx/ultra.

Don't say the 3870 is worthless you flipping troll, I have one along with my 8800GT and the 3870 is as fast, in some games the 8800GT murders the 3870 when AA/AF is enabled, but besides that the 3870 is not a card to overlook. Be more informative and get your info straight.
 
I currently have a 22inch samsung with a native 1680 x 1050 that i'll be running games at (hopefully).

The funny thing is with my 15 inch Viewsonic... i could run HL2 almost maxed out with 1024 x 768 on my GeForce FX 5500 !!!

Now with my GeForce FX 5500.... instead of running HL2 max on a 15 inch.... it is struggling JUST to run the desktop on my samsung 22... It lags like a mug when doing window transitions and dragging and dropping things. So yes i do see what you guys are talking about how my screen res. and monitor size will make a big difference.

So assuming I run at 1680 x 1050... or POSSIBLY one step down from that... i'm lookin for cheapest card that can run those games. Do you think ANY of the GeForce 7-series cards can handle it... considering i have the q6600 and 4 gigs of ddr2 800 RAM?
 
I have a 20in monitor at 1680 x 1050 with a 7900 GS (being replaced soon with a 8800GT)

I don't have Crysis or any of the new games though. Oblivion is probably my most hardware intensive game and it runs decently without using AA/AF.

Since COD4 is newer and a FPS, I'm assuming you wouldn't be able to run it on max with a 7900GS and not sure how much better any of the other 7 series cards are in the grand scheme of things.

Having top of the line components in the other area will help but the power of the GPU is generally where it matters most. If you want to max out on COD4, then it's not going to be cheap. If you want cheap but still good settings, then I'd think the 3850 would be the best bet.

Cheap - 3850 - $170
Medium - 3870 - $230 or 256 8800GT - $210
Best - 512 8800GT - $279
 
The 3870 is USELESS, the 3850 wins bang for the buck, a great deal, but the 8800gt is the only good higher end card besides the gtx/ultra.

So wait, I don't think I am understanding you....

Are you saying that the $15 more expensive card which is also faster, has better RAM and a MUCH better cooler is useless because it is a mere $15 more????? See because in my opinion I will take my 3870 that I paid $215 for from Best Buy fucking 8 days a week over the 3850!!!!!! IMHO the 3850 512MB is useless at this pricepoint :confused:
 
i get the dang GeForce 8800 GT at Best Buy with my discount for like $216 so now i'm trying to weigh whether i should wait awhile for that to become readily available, or jump on a 3850 with my discount for even less and just get an okay card.

Any idea how the 8600 GTs are?? (both 256mbs and 512mb if they make such a card)
 
i get the dang GeForce 8800 GT at Best Buy with my discount for like $216 so now i'm trying to weigh whether i should wait awhile for that to become readily available, or jump on a 3850 with my discount for even less and just get an okay card.

Any idea how the 8600 GTs are?? (both 256mbs and 512mb if they make such a card)

I believe that the 8600s have similar performance to 7900s but with Directx 10 capability. Cannondale said "the 8600gt is fine for COD4 and max settings at 1024x768." in the other thread.

Waiting is always better for best price/performance. But can't wait forever obviously cause there's always something new and improved coming out.

Do you get the 8800GT (512) for $216? I should have had you buy mine for me lol
 
yea i know its just above $210 somethin that we get the card for. Only problem is its literally out of stock EVERYWHERE. and i mean EVERYWHERE. Checking district, territory, and national stock counts... EVERY best buy is out of them. (except the idiot store in St Louis says they have 1 but its wrong cuz someone prolly stole it and no one can find it). Ive tried ordering it from multiple different ways / sources / warehouses and they're all unavailable or on backorder. The entire week we ran the add where it was like $239... not one best buy that i knew of had it in stock... lol so it was kinda a pointless sale / slap in the face for anyone who wanted one.
 
I agree. i believed the rep that they would have more. I could have just gotten one for 249 but I waited and it then was at 269 for Visiontek. everyone likes them so much I just had to spend a bit more and just do it.

tomorrow it comes :D
 
I think ill sum up the cards from my perspective:

You really gotta mention a budget, if your after res's above 1600X1200 and/or play games that often contain vast expanses of high-res polygons (such as RTSs, LOMAC), your going to want the 512mb buffer. If the 8800GT 512mb is out of your reach, an HD3850 512mb would be a minimal step down in performance for a significant step down in price.

If your doing lower res gaming 256mb cards will do you just fine. If the budgets high enough Nvidia is soft-launching the 8800GT 256mb as I write this post. Again, for a minimal step down in performance, and a reasonable step down in price, the HD3850 is an excellent choice.

If you run a monitor with a low dot-pitch, AA is probably for you, and it would seem it would be better to go after an 8800GT in this case. It seems the hit from AA on AMDs RV670 is much more minimalized then on their R600, they still take a bigger hit from it then Nvidias 8 series cards seem to.

On top of this, each game has a preferance to what cards it prefers. Far cry for example had the R600 outperforming the GTX in far too many situations. You should take a look and see what your favorite game performs best under: AMD architecture or Nvidia architecture.
 
This is [H], forgive people for not comprehending what you mean by cheap card that will get you by. Many people who think that they are [H] can't get over the fact that the 8800GT is one of the fastest cards in the market, only being "slightly" more expensive but their brains can't reach the connection with "cheap" which means value for money in your case.

According to TG Daily, the ATI 3850 offers the most value for your money. You get the most FPS per buck as per this awesome chart.

fpsperdollarmk4.jpg


This would be my recommendation to you because it will "murder everything except Crysis". Consider that I was previously on a x1950 Pro and I could still "murder everything except Crysis" including Bioshock, COD4, etc...but for the FPS increase and value in the 3850, you cannot beat that.
 
Careful as the chart doesnt state whether they are all 512MB or 256MB or a mix.
I couldnt find the chart on their site (wot no link?)
Get a 512MB card or you will cry later.
 
Ok my little cents right here are. I run CoD4 with everything INCLUDING AA all the way and pull a dang decent 47fps on average. With my 3870.

With ur cpu which is better than mine you should pull around the same if not higher. With ur BB dicount with them being 215 at BB it sound like a good deal.
 
I agree with those who are recommending the 3850. It will run all the games you mentioned maxed out or close to it at 1680x1050. The 256mb version is selling for $180 all over the place. You can also play Crysis on a 3850 with everything set to "High", but forget "Very High" settings.
 
Up to 1600x1200, the 8800 GT 256 is faster than even the HD 3870 512.

Thats not entirely accurate. You cant declair a line like that as there are just too many factors, but yeah, the 8800GT will outperform the HD3870 512mb until you hit higher textures and high resolutions, save software problems.
 
X19*0xt and x19*0xtx are more than enough for all of those games. My x1950xt is enought to run cod4 and ut3 maxed w/ 2xaa & 8xaf at 1440x900. They can be had for around $110 on ebay.
 
Back
Top