Celeron M, have they improved at all?

Joined
Oct 11, 2005
Messages
18
My friend has been looking to buy a laptop and recently spotted the new Gateway convertible tablet PC and asked me about. Coincidentally I have seen a couple recent reviews and so far they are pretty good (amazingly enough since it is Gateway). Here is a link to what engadget found.

My first question is should I trust Gateway? I have had problems with them in the past but I am willing to forgive and forget if they are making a turn around.

Second, she isn't a power user really and doesn't want to spend a lot of money and wants to know if the Celeron M is worth it or if she should spend the $300 or so extra dollars to upgrade the CPU. I know she wants to do it mostly for digital drawing but nothing especially intensive like massive layers of photoshop. I haven't really read anything positive or negative on the Celeron M so any input would be greatly appreciated.
 
i wouldnt trust gateay myself, but the celeron M is fine. its bascially a banias pentium-m (1mb l2 w/ 400bus) with no speedstep, so slightly lower battery life than a real pent-m
 
Would you say upgrading to the pentium M would be worth it? Do you know of any convertable tablets that are worth it in the say $1000 range?
 
if she is not a power user and doesnt spend significant time away from a power outlet, the pentium-m is not worth it, no.

ive had quite a few problems with gateway (both laptops and desktops) but the last machine we bought from them was in 2001, so they might have gotten better.
 
Trusting Gatway: The quality of their notebook computers has gone up a good bit in the last year, from what I've heard and seen. The folks that I know with Gateways are having fewer problems per user than the folks I know with Dell Latitudes, and the Latitude line is pretty reliable.
 
Do you think there would be much performance difference between the Pentium M and the Celeron in things like light Photoshop usage? She is mostly just drawing and maybe doing a few color layers but that's it. No lens flares or filters or anything like that. I saw this notebook at Best Buy and it seemed just as sturdy as the rest there and the like the Dells as well but I want to think of the future and make sure in a year her laptop isn't breaking. I know for a typical user that makes them want to run away from computers all together.
 
Let me answer that:
Had an eMachine, which turned into Gateway; I was tempted to buy the identical Gateway when mine got stolen. I loved it.
I couldn't afford the Gateway, so I bought a Latitude; I hate it. I'm selling it to buy a Thinkpad.

Regarding Cel-M vs. P-M:
My Latitude came with C-M 1.5 Banias. I swapped in my own P-M 1.5 (also Banias). There is absolutely zero difference in performance, but my battery life went up from 5.5 hours on average to just over 6hours. Half an hour, or 9% battery increase due to SpeedStep. How important is battery life to you?
 
9% battery life for a 30% price increase isn't worth it to me, and I am sure she would never notice. How recent are your Gateway experiences? Mine are from atleast 5 years back probably more and it was always a wrestling match but I am never one to hold a grudge.
 
The Gateway and Dell owners I'm referring to use their notebooks very, very heavily. In the last year and a half, the Gateways and Latitudes I'm talking about have been beaten, and the technical problem rates for the Dells are probably twice as high as they would be under more normal levels of usage. The Gateways are experiencing problems 1/3 to 1/2 as often. I'm not saying the Gateways are necessarily twice as durable as the Latitudes, but they're certainly at least as good here.
 
glad to hear that gateways have gone back up in quality

if i were buying anything but thinkpads, id consider them again :p
 
Well ladies and gentlemen I appreciate your info. I know a couple years ago the two worst words in computing you could of heard were Gateway and Celeron but it looks like they both have turn themselves around. Thanks a lot for all your help.
 
I actually bought a Gateway 6020GZ about 3 months ago. It has a 1.4 Ghz Dothan Celeron M. I have been very happy with it - mostly running email and word processing, but the occasional photoshop work. I have been very happy with this particular computer - both with the computing power and the gateway product quality.
 
Back
Top