Can't decide on best server solution

Jordan1

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 1, 2005
Messages
1,733
I currently have most of my important files on a secondary hard drive in my main system. Whenever I feel things have changed enough, or when I have time, I use SyncToy to update new files to a equal sized external hard drive. I am running out of space and would like to step up to something more secure and automated. I shoot and edit lots of photos at times and don't like the risk of losing data (and lots of editing time). I am leaning towards a couple solutions but would like more input.

I'm on a tight budget. I want something with 4+hot-swappable bays. I'd like to have at least 2 drives installed from the beginning, both with the same data in case one fails I will have a perfect backup copy--I'm not sure RAID is the best way to do this. From what I've read WHS might be my best option. However, I don't own it yet. But I do have access to about every version of Server 2003 and 2008; legitimate copies, of course. I know it would be a complete overkill with 2003/2008 but ATM I am comparing the acer Aspire Easystore H340 w/WHS to building a cheap mid-tower, AM3 45W system w/ 2003/2008, the latter being cheaper, more, customizable, has video, etc. But would it be easy enough to accomplish the above with 2003/2008? I also don't have much experience with 2003/2008 and will be studying to get the certifications for them very soon, which is another reason I'd like to put it to one or the other to use.

Besides backing up my every growing data, I would also like to host my website on the server at some point. I also have a couple of other computers on my network that could use semi-regular backups, whether it be scheduled or manually.
 
While you can duplicate most of WHS' features with 2003/2008, it would not be as easy nor would you have the duplication feature of WHS.
 
I was afraid of that. Here is what I'm looking at if I would build. I decided to reuse some stuff that is currently not being used for anything. Now it looks like I have an obvious best choice. I'm open to any suggestions.

$0 - Old beige case
$149.98 - 2 x 1TB WD Green drives
$54.99 - GA-MA74GM-S2 AM3/AM2+/AM2 AMD 740G Micro ATX
$39.99 - Antec earthwatts EA380 380W
$13.99 - Rendition Crucial 1GB
$0 - Sempron 2800+ 1.6GHz AM2 (laying around)
$104.99 - SUPERMICRO CSE-M35T-1B Black 5 Bay Hot-Swapable
$10.49 - Scythe KAMA FLEX SA0925FDB12L 92mm (for drive bay)
$94.99 - WHS, if I must
=$469.42

or Acer H340:
$389.99
$74.99 - 1TB WD Green drive (already has 1TB drive)
=$464.98
 
Gah! I was leaning toward my home built system. Any reason in particular to go for the Acer instead of the other system posted above?

Simple, cheap, and it will work out of the box. If you want you can go your home built route, but if you only need 4 drive capacity, I'd go with something that I will have the least amount of problems with.
 
Simple, cheap, and it will work out of the box. If you want you can go your home built route, but if you only need 4 drive capacity, I'd go with something that I will have the least amount of problems with.

Very true. I can't see myself filling up more than 4 bays anytime soon. The only thing I don't like is the lack of video in case something went south and I needed to have access to the machine off of the network. But I've heard that can be added/modded into place later.
 
[LYL]Homer;1034531026 said:
Technet? WHS is available there.

MSDNAA. Unfortunately I don't have access to WHS. Only the stuff meant for professional work environments.
 
As the old saying goes, once you have lots of storage, you can't get enough of it. ;)

Heheh, hopefully I can keep the data to am minimum.

I like the idea of being able to swap out any hardware easily if I go the home built route. But the small form factor of the Acer is nice too.
 
There was a time when I thought that a couple of hot swap bays in a tower would suffice. I've got (4) 3-in-2 hot swaps gathering dust to prove it. As Syntax said, once you have to storage, you'll need more.

I can see both sides of you're delimma. It just depends whether you want to play with the config, or you want it to just work.
 
I ended up going with the home built and ordering a rebadged Lian Li V2000B. Because its such a beast of a case I ditched the hot-swapable 5-bay for the time being. Not what I was originally thinking but I wanted to have more options later on and the case was a steal. Sure, I could have went with a Norco but I'm not ready for that yet. ;)
 
I ended up going with the home built and ordering a rebadged Lian Li V2000B. Because its such a beast of a case I ditched the hot-swapable 5-bay for the time being. Not what I was originally thinking but I wanted to have more options later on and the case was a steal. Sure, I could have went with a Norco but I'm not ready for that yet. ;)

You bought that case for four hard drives? ..........

Not to crap on your parade, it's not the ideal case for stacking hard drives.
 
You bought that case for four hard drives? ..........

Not to crap on your parade, it's not the ideal case for stacking hard drives.

Yes, I can't see myself using more than 4 hard drives ATM. I've never put together one of these cases before but it seems like it would be decent for storing lots of HDDs. Unless they are just hard to work in? Overkill..now, probably yes.

Pic from Lian Li gallery:

_DSC0285.jpg


another I found:

oh96di.jpg
 
Back
Top