Can GPUs get hotter with age?

UltimaBoB

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 24, 2006
Messages
215
I've had the following computer for 16 months:

Antec P180 Case
Enermax liberty 620 watt PSU
Intel E6700 CPU
2 x HIS ATI 1950XTX GPU in Corssfire
Soundblaster X-Fi Extreme Music
ASUS P5W DH Deluxe

For 13 months or so it worked fine. But now it seems to have gone to hell. The temps started rising and the CPU seemed to slow down. When I installed games, old games, the games would tell me my CPU did not meet the min requirements. Every program would take about 5 to 6 times its normal CPU load.

The tech I had come in told me that the GPUs were too hot and that I could not run both of them. He took one out and everything is fixed.

But how can there have been no problem for 13 months and then a problem?

BTW i didn't do anything to help with heat. I installed no extra fans, no thermal paste, no 3rd party fan speed programs etc... All my coolers are stock. The tech says that two 1950XTXs were too hot to have run without taking extra heat precautions - that I had no margin for error - when the system was first built. So it ran okay for awhile, but over time stuff degrades and now it is just too hot without adding cooling etc...

Does this make any sense? Should I have been adding cooling from the beginning?

I want to put my second card back in.
 
Have you made sure it's not all full of dust, and that all the fans are working?
 
Does this make any sense? Should I have been adding cooling from the beginning?

Yeah, you should have. Add the largest, low RPM fans you can fit in your case to get decent airflow without a lot of noise (Vantec Stealth fans come highly recommended here).

Airflow is doubly important for Crossfire and SLI setups because it increases reliability and lifetime of the cards due to all the heat these boards throw off. That's why your CPU was throttling down - too much ambient heat.
 
Everything is super clean now. A tech cleaned all the heatsinks and parts. But no checking for fan damage or thermal compound status etc...

But still the problems persist. I'm a computer newb working in Korea dealing with Korean speaking techs. My "translator" knows zero about computers. So the communication gap is what is killing me. It is hard to know if the tech I am using is an idiot or not.

Why would my set-up work fine for 12 months and suddenly not work?

Could fans and barings have degraded? Thermal compound degraded?

So you are saying that the original tech was right that while I did have enough cooling with all stock components to get by - there was no marin for error? As soon as stuff degraded and cooling dropped i hit the red zone and my CPU throttled?

Trying to communicate adding fans and complex cooling solutions might be hard. I have the money, what about ditching the two 1950s for a single nvdia? Would that cool things down enough you think seeing as a single 1950 seems to be running fine?

Or given that I have run the comp at two high a temp fopr awhile, are there some things that simply have to be done? A friend at home said communication gap or not, after running at overheat for so long I simply have to check the heatsink, thermal paste (and reapply new stuff), and fan barings for my CPU fan. He said stuff could be degrading and even if the single GPU seems to be working okay now, heat could still rise if mainteance isnt done and throttle me with only a single GPU.

Does that make sense? Do I need someone who knows what he is doing to look at all my fans and heatsinks and thrmal compunds even if I don't add more? I hate complicated crap lol
 
Actually, Yes, but usually not very dramatically. A CPU's traces slowly burn away over time like a Lightbulb Filament. (VERY SLOWLY) OCing and increasing tempratures accellerate the process, but it should take many years for something to finally break, unless you have some sort of a short that is causing an increase in heat, but you would think that would trash the processor.
 
Your fans are probably just dying. And yes, they die with age, many with even premature deaths.
 
I have heard that P180s are bad cases for GPU cooling. Can anyone recommend me a better case?
 
thanks for the recommend.

If I want to get both my 1950s back and working and wait for GPU upgrade, and since fans probably need replacing, is upgrading to a full tower case a decent idea?
 
All of this just does not sound right.

Did you change ANY variables before this happened? Did your computer ever crash and then started acting weirdly?

What is the current state of the computer? Are both cards installed or is one 1950xtx out? If you can re-install the x1950xtx, then do it. Do the problems come back? Now download Intel Thermal Analysis Tool and AtiTool, with both of the cards installed. Start the programs at idle and see what the temperatures look like for the processor and for both graphics cards. That should tell you if your problem is thermal. Also, is your motherboard dust free as well? And are all of the fan filters on the case dust free? Simply pulling them out and vacuuming them should do the trick.

I actually noticed that my cpu temps and hard drive temperatures were pretty high and after I had cleaned the single front fan filter on my P150, the temperature on the cpu dropped ~5 degrees and hard drive temperatures dropped around 6 degrees celcius as well.
 
thanks for the recommend.

If I want to get both my 1950s back and working and wait for GPU upgrade, and since fans probably need replacing, is upgrading to a full tower case a decent idea?

Upgrading to a full tower case when running in crossfire/SLI is ALWAYS a good idea. The more fans and pathways you have, the cooler the system will be! Positioning of the fans is key of course for the best cooling, but the extra room of a full will definitely benefit.

I'm surprised you're even running crossfire in a mid.

Also, most will disagree with me and say 620ps for crossfire is fine, but I'd say bump it up!
 
I have heard that P180s are bad cases for GPU cooling. Can anyone recommend me a better case?

the antec 900 looks like it got shot with a tommygun.LOL you cant expect much better airflow. although it does get a bit dusty. i love mine.
 
There is no dust in the case at all anymore. The tech is coming over tomorrow to try to add the sound card now that he has established that everything works fine with just one gpu and no sound card. He is pretty sure the issue is thermal. I guess we will see.
 
All of this just does not sound right.

Did you change ANY variables before this happened? Did your computer ever crash and then started acting weirdly?

What is the current state of the computer? Are both cards installed or is one 1950xtx out? If you can re-install the x1950xtx, then do it. Do the problems come back? Now download Intel Thermal Analysis Tool and AtiTool, with both of the cards installed. Start the programs at idle and see what the temperatures look like for the processor and for both graphics cards. That should tell you if your problem is thermal. Also, is your motherboard dust free as well? And are all of the fan filters on the case dust free? Simply pulling them out and vacuuming them should do the trick.

I actually noticed that my cpu temps and hard drive temperatures were pretty high and after I had cleaned the single front fan filter on my P150, the temperature on the cpu dropped ~5 degrees and hard drive temperatures dropped around 6 degrees celcius as well.

the tech has cleaned thoroughly. There were no real probelsm for 12 months then it started getting slow, crashing occassionally. The CPU started getting weaker and weaker - to the point that when I installed new games they would measure the CPU and say it was insufficient. The immages on my game screen used to shake back and forth.

Now all is well, but not Soundcard and only one GPU. The tech is supposedly isolating the problem and wanted to see if it worked this way. Then he'll try adding the soundcard.

As for fans::

At the corner between the top of the case and the back there are two fans. One at the back of the top and the other at the top of the back.

There is a fan on the CPU and then there is another small fan, very small, coming out of the mother board at a 90 degree anle right behind the CPU. Weid, no idea what it is.

Then there is a PSU fan.

There are no fans in the front of the case.

Dust is gone and everything has been cleaned - or so I have been told. But I don't know how good a job he did or didn't do.

The wires and cords seem to be managed from the initial build - but from an amateur's pov don't seem to be managed ideally and may be messy and interfere with airflow.

There are NO fans whatsoever in the front of the case. No drive fans were added despite most of the drive slots being empty and covered up (only single DVD burner/player and a 150 GB Raptor HDD).

Not sure these are enough. Would adding more fans in the drive bays etc... and fixing the fans be enough, or is a case change probably needed?
 
not knocking on the koreans or anything but always double check what they do, i would say rearranging PSU cords and getting some fans in the front of the case to get a sufficient case flow going, as far as the fan coming straight out of the mobo that is most likely the northbridge cooler.
 
snip

Not sure these are enough. Would adding more fans in the drive bays etc... and fixing the fans be enough, or is a case change probably needed?

I think that with both 1950s installed, yes, you should get one 120mm fan installed in the front of the case. Also, tell the tech to flip the fan that is right at the top of the case above the cpu so that it blows cool air from outside onto the cpu. This configuration cools the cpu better than having the fan exhaust the air.
 
so you think that with enough fans I could do okay with the P180 and no new case?

Should I buy aftermarket coolers for my GPU? Thermal compound?

Also, on my mobo should there be a way to fit the cards so that the sound card is not right between the GPUs and getting cooked from both sides? I don't need the wifi card.
 
Can you post pictures of your system? Aftermarket cooler would be good, but not wholly necessary. And no, you do not need to change your case, it should be fine with proper placement and configuration of the fans.
 
Back
Top