California Makes Non-Solicitation Contracts Illegal

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
IT sales guys (or anyone in sales) should listen up. If you’re working in CA and signed a non-compete/non-solicitation agreement with your employer, you may be surprised to find out that a recent CA Supreme Court ruling has made those contracts illegal and non-binding. The fallout from this should be interesting in businesses such as support services as salespeople have more leverage to essentially hold their company hostage.

[Attorney John] Lecrone doesn't think other state courts are going to follow in California's footsteps. He notes, "Most other states allow non-compete and non-solicitation agreements as long as they're reasonable."
 
i signed them but I just disregard them usually as most say you cant open your own business or work for a competing one for two years WTF is that shit, for making my sign shit like that your just begging for me to go sell your business secrets to someone else.
 
There were a few game companies that did that. Couldn't do freakin' art for another company. Bullcrap.
 
Business secrets aren't the problem. Stolen customers are. I've seen that happen from time to time. A field service rep has a loyal following and then tells them all, "Hey, I'm starting my own business, come with me." Then the employer looses a good employee (good performance wise, not ethically), and good customers. The employer provides a job, training and benefits, and the employee shows his disloyalty by screwing them over.

Sometimes the contracts go overboard (you ought to see what they wanted our engineers to sign!), but the resonable contracts are usually not a big deal.
 
Business secrets aren't the problem. Stolen customers are. I've seen that happen from time to time. A field service rep has a loyal following and then tells them all, "Hey, I'm starting my own business, come with me." Then the employer looses a good employee (good performance wise, not ethically), and good customers. The employer provides a job, training and benefits, and the employee shows his disloyalty by screwing them over.

Sometimes the contracts go overboard (you ought to see what they wanted our engineers to sign!), but the resonable contracts are usually not a big deal.

that's rarely the case. we all know how companies try to get over on the employees. and if some of these companies were so loyal they wouldn't outsource.
 
Yeah sorry dude, most of the reason people quit and open their own place is because employers are shit, and eventually some people want to open their own business, and if that guy made relationships with his customers and got those customers for his employer, and he knows once he is gone they will receive inferior service compared to what he can and has been giving them what is wrong with taking them.

It comes down to even if the guy left and stole customers, if the company making him sign the contract knew how to operate a business and take care of customers it would not be an issue.\

Now sometimes you just cant do anything about it, when I worked for a water company that split from the main company they were owned by two iraqi brothers, I worked for the business that split from the first one, anyways they started around 2003 and a sales pitch because of the war was, your buying water from a terrorist and someone who knows saddam fucked, yeah kinda. Did they treat their employees horribly, and customers also and not use proper filtering procedures when treating water and sold water that was "distilled" that never was? Also a yes, the distilled thing is important with people that are having kidney issues.
 
I kinda agree with this CA law. I always found non-compete agreements to be a impairment to the development for new business. Some of them are reasonable such as "dont steal our customers", others are very strict such as "you can't work in this industry for 2 years", etc.

I personally think it's a good thing to have competition open up.
 
Business secrets aren't the problem. Stolen customers are. I've seen that happen from time to time. A field service rep has a loyal following and then tells them all, "Hey, I'm starting my own business, come with me." Then the employer looses a good employee (good performance wise, not ethically), and good customers. The employer provides a job, training and benefits, and the employee shows his disloyalty by screwing them over.

Sometimes the contracts go overboard (you ought to see what they wanted our engineers to sign!), but the resonable contracts are usually not a big deal.

But are non-compete clauses the right solution? Why did the company hire the guy or keep him after he was hired? If he was ethically shady, then did he really show loyalty to the company in the first place?
 
Non-Compete's are nothing but a way for companies to intimidate workers. If a company is worried that one employee will leave and take all their business, well, they better treat that one employee pretty damn well and try to keep them employed.
 
Easy, If enought people read the contract, and didnt like it, they wouldnt work there.

Too many people agree to things these days, and then whine about all this as BS, because they dont have integrity to honor their word as they agreed.

Dont like the contract? Dont sign it. California has no right to invalidate existing contracts for an agreed and legal practice.
 
Easy, If enought people read the contract, and didnt like it, they wouldnt work there.

Too many people agree to things these days, and then whine about all this as BS, because they dont have integrity to honor their word as they agreed.

Dont like the contract? Dont sign it. California has no right to invalidate existing contracts for an agreed and legal practice.

riiight and all those who don't sign will be happy to crawl into a cardboard box and sustain themselves on air and water, while the jobs they could use are outsourced and done for far less thus hurting your local area..
 
It doesn't affect me personally, but I'm all for making those crappy contracts illegal.
 
I signed many non-compete contracts, including some that essentially stated that everything I did on or off work was the property of the University. I always knew that if push came to shove, I could litigate my way out of them, but they were really there just to make sure I didn't share company or government secrets. The worst contract I ever saw was when my brother looked into doing a 3 month contract job through Robert Half. When he brought me their contract, which they wanted him to sign on the spot, before even giving him an offer, I laughed. They stated everything he created during his time with them, would be either their or the client's intellectual property. He was forbidden from working with anyone else or finding other contract employment for 6 months after leaving them. Since my brother is a contractor, that would deprive him of his livelihood. I should dig through our records and post the full contract, because it was full of so many illegal requirements that I don't think the paper was worth what it was printed on.

My brother made me proud when he inked in the modifications that needed to be made to the contract, pointed out inconsistencies in their contract and handed it back to them, asking to have their legal team review the changes and contact him back. I thought they wouldn't call him back after that, but he has pretty high level specialties, so they kept calling and increasing what they would pay him (reached $500 per hour), but they couldn't modify their contract. He never signed their contract and he ended up, finding other work.
 
Business secrets aren't the problem. Stolen customers are. I've seen that happen from time to time. A field service rep has a loyal following and then tells them all, "Hey, I'm starting my own business, come with me." Then the employer looses a good employee (good performance wise, not ethically), and good customers. The employer provides a job, training and benefits, and the employee shows his disloyalty by screwing them over.

Sometimes the contracts go overboard (you ought to see what they wanted our engineers to sign!), but the resonable contracts are usually not a big deal.

I kinda agree with this CA law. I always found non-compete agreements to be a impairment to the development for new business. Some of them are reasonable such as "dont steal our customers", others are very strict such as "you can't work in this industry for 2 years", etc.

I personally think it's a good thing to have competition open up.

Both of you bring up good points. It really comes down to what the contract calls for. I don't like how this came down. I think companies should be able to have better non-solication agreements then what that article is calling for but then again we are caling about California which as a rule hates companies.

I've signed a few of these agreements in the past. I have also refused to sign some. The ones I've signed generaly were about me either moon-lighting doing the same thing, solicitating former clients if I left, etc. Those make sence.
 
Most of these types of agreements where already illegal in California.

However, I lost a chance for a new job a few years ago due to one of these agreements (the job was with a customer of the company I was working for).

I was working on the help desk of a software company (way below my skill level, but that another long story) and I applied for an IT position with the new company. the IT staff knew me and though I'd be great fit for the possition. The new company's HR/Legal department told the IT manager they could not higher me since there was a non-compete clause in their contract with the software company I was currently working for.

Even though thier legal department agreed that the contract was not enforable in California, they didn't want to "sour" the relationship with my current employer, since they knew he would make a stink about contract if they hired me.

Took me over a year to finally find a better job, and the owner of my old comapny still tried to make a stink. Lucky the new company I was working for told him to pound sand :)
 
Sounds like more development and high end jobs leaving California.

Move them to other tech friendly states like... umm Texas that is what I say!! ;)
 
I'm glad they are doing away with this. It hard for people who are trained in a specific area and then have to move to a different company, but "can't" due to some dumb ass contract.
 
in Ontario, Canada, all you had to do was show the court that such a contract was making your lively hood impossible (aka. could not find work or generate income) and the courts would generally toss them.

f you had as little respect for those non-solicitation contracts as most people did, you pissed on them all the time...however, NOT having to jump threw hoops in CA looks like a good thing.

Another reason to treat your employees well
 
Back
Top